Does illegality equal immorality?

0 votes

Rep. Byrne's view on Immorality and Illegality. She thinks everything that is illegal, is also immoral.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WWPBGRqyo9c&feature=channel_page

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Interesting Question

If illegal=immoral
then she probably believes legal=moral
If so, then might makes right,
or might makes wrong.

Then her vote against

the Constitution makes her an immoral and criminal individual.

1976-1982 USMC, You can thank me for my service by voting for Dr. Ron Paul, President 2012

I'll agree with tannim on some basic premises

There are plenty of things that are illegal but are not immoral, such as hemp usage, and there are plenty of things that are legal that are immoral, such as price fixing.

In a word, NO

Immoral is a ethical construct with occasional religious connotations for those still stuck in that mode of thinking.

Illegal is a sick raptor.

Lots of illegal things are very moral, and lots of legal things are immoral. There is some overlap, but only in the cases of force and fraud, which is where the law should really focus anyway.

Lol, definitely not. Some

Lol, definitely not. Some things that are illegal are moral, like disobeying an SS officer in Nazi Germany.

Ventura 2012

Too many laws are imoral

according to natural law.

completely and totally disagree.

I can't stress that enough. Just think of the easy way out...it must work both ways right? So if it is legal then it is moral? That is surely an easy one.

Depends on where you look for your authority in the end..do you wait for government (Beasts) to lay down your moral path, or do you follow God's word, or at least the conscience that He gave you.

One is putting your faith and guidance in Man (6)
the other is putting your faith in God (7)

Get the point?

yes but...

two types of "law" are being discussed... in the case of 'minimum wage' civil law must take precedence because a contract is drawn up between the two parties and both parties have natural rights to their property...

when the two laws conflict, natural law always takes precedence

In my law

which is governed by the Word of God, i am to pay employee's daily and in cash so that they can feed their families.

Next?

she is trying to maintain

an indefensible position...

she is blurring "civil law" with "natural law"... she will be forced to redefine...

or the interviewer is purposely blending the two together in order to trap her which seems to be more likely...