It's not good enough to be aware of the false left/right paradigm
On the surface, it seems like we can rejoice over the fact that we do not subscribe to silly polarized teams that so obviously cloud our thoughts. But a scratch beneath the surface, reveals that there is a core problem that we are not addressing in ourselves. Most dailypaulers can easily identify when others have fallen victim to the left/right paradigm, however, there is more to it than just mere successfully identification in others. Let's explore the idea for a moment to see how it could be affecting our daily routines.
At it's core, the false left/right paradigm pins left liberal Democrats versus right conservative Republicans. This is achieved through constant repetition from pundits, teachers, parents, media, and other social upbringings. By the time the child has grown up, he is very clear on the fact that the entire body politic is a 30-second sound byte of which can be framed up in a left or right world. Unfortunately, by subscribing to one team or the other, the child grows up to become very apt at seeing the atrocities committed by the opposing team, while being hopelessly blind to seeing the atrocities committed by their own team.
The team-player mentality clouds our judgment. This is just the fact of the matter.
But even if we do not subscribe to the left or right paradigm, we are still very susceptible to the clouded thinking of the team-think mentality.
Let me see if I can explain it this way.
Everybody on the Dailypaul, is fully aware of the obama loyalists who mindlessly accept this administration's dysfunctional policies because, to them, he is "one of us." Right?
Likewise, we are fully aware of the bush loyalists who have defended and apolgized for the bush/cheney tyranny for 8 years straight.
It is oh-so-similar to watching football fan loyalists. You can always count on the call on the field being "wrong," if it is against their team. Even after watching the replay in slow motion from 3 different angles, football fans are still absolutely livid over the bad call that everyone can clearly see was a good call.
Alan Watt, in Jones' latest documentary, goes on to explain that this is actually a very natural behavioral problem with human beings. We identify ourselves in tribal teams, and cheer our tribal leaders on in hopes of winning. We lose our senses, in that we are actually being disenfranchised in our decision making process, because our thinking is being done for us.
I'm paraphrasing now, but Watts calls it a "alpha hypnotic state" which can "change an entire block of nations, by taking them on certain paths." Most people want to belong to the same group as everyone else. So, he explains, "we will bounce ideas off of each other and reaffirm what we already know, since we both heard the same information from the same authoritive sources -- having absolutely nothing to do on whether or not the information is utter nonsense."
I recently had a knee-jerk reaction to alex jones fans who attacked me because of a critical analysis I posted of his latest film. They said I was a cowardly troll who lied about my credentials as an activist, and finally, must be dating a worthless blow up doll for a girlfriend. (ouch.)
but, taking a step back, I can see just how nefarious this team-think problem is.
Instead of rejecting the comments outright, I took this as lesson and demonstration of the enormity of the problem, explained by Watts above.
We tend to be very good at identifying the attrocities committed by the left/right. But "they" are not the only ones stymied, here. We have also unwittingly subscribed to the team-think mentality. We are Republicans, conservatives, liberals, we are libertarians, we are anarchist, paleoanarchists, truthers, enlightened ones, people who "are awake," or we are just plain dailypaulers. What does this mean? This means, as it turns out, that we are also just as unlikely to see the atrocities committed by our own team as anybody else.
So it is, even if we do not subscribe to the left or the right paradigm, we still behave like we are on tribal teams. And, in the end, we feel good that we are not victims to the paradigm. but the truth is, we need not be so proud, since we haven't really escaped in the first place.
It is not good enough to be aware of the false left/right paradigm. In doing so, we have only created a new caveat -- a new team to which we faithfully subscribe to. Our fearless tribal leaders, Kokesh, Griffin, Jones, Schiff, Rand, Ron Paul, and others, tend to get put on pedestals (and perhaps, rightfully so.) But, with that being understood, it is of utmost importance to sharpen our observational skills and have a willingness to accept the same criticism that we would hope a bush or obama supporter to hear.
Thanks for reminding me, that I am certainly no exception to this, either. Welcome to the tribe.





















Excellent post.... I like your style
Unfortunately I think the instinct for survival is a very strong motivator to wanting to believe that you have a TEAM behind you. Right now we learn every day of all of the various threats to our survival as a free people, and the DP "army" is in battle mode. Nothing wrong with passionately pursuing the truth and trying to spread it. But we tend to get impatient with those that are not QUITE as knowledgeable, or convinced, or perhaps are off track on certain issues. We tend to see any disagreement as CRUCIAL to the survival of the species!!!!! Anyone who is not a "purist" is often considered a traitor, or a plant, or a spy. We have been betrayed so many times by those we thought we could trust, that we are all a bit paranoid when we hear a hint of something that may signify a "trick".
None of us knew most of what we learn here a few years ago. Right now the movement has gone from a little seed to a field full of little sprouts. But little sprouts can turn into a jungle IF they are given water, and air and good soil. They will die, however, if they are STOMPED on by the farmer, or are choked out by the older plants.
I also agree with your post below that it is only through a revolution of consciousness that the world will change. Nothing wrong with activism... but even if ALL of the current freedom candidates won their elections...it is the mindset of the populace that has to change in order for there to be progress.
____________________________________________
A Man's Country Is Not A Certain Area Of Land,
Of Mountains, Rivers, And Woods,
But It Is A Principle......
And Patriotism Is Loyalty To That Principle .
- George William Curtis
Thomas Jefferson: “Indeed, I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just, that His justice cannot sleep forever."
Viva La Revolucion!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FmaTNf4YhEs
thank you!
and i don't mean to say activism isn't going to work. indeed, it is the only thing that has ever worked.
what i mean to say is that we would be best served to focus our activism on spreading the philosophies of freedom, and spiritual truths about life -- instead of, say, debating economic policy,
(the dysfunctional economic policies, that we are hurting from today, are a reflection of the core false beliefs about life, in the first place.)
i appreciate the comments.
Whoa
WHO on our team has "committed atrocities? Who on our team has even been in power to commit atrocities?
I agree, no reason to beat
I agree, no reason to beat ourselves up over nothing. We can do enough by criticizing some of the actions of our intellectual fathers(Founding Fathers) regarding slavery, central banking, and killing Native Ameicans.
Ventura 2012
criticizing? or making observations that make some unhappy?
if somebody said i was ignorant on the subject of astronomy, i may get upset because he called me ignorant.
but the fact remains, that it is a statement of fact, since i honestly don't know anything really about astronomy.
this is an example of how statements of fact tend not to be brought up because they rub people the wrong way. but the problem is not with somebody saying i was ignorant on astronomy. the problem lies with me for taking offense.
perhaps, not so severe a word.
but there are a few things that i find atrocious, that i don't think i'll bring up in this thread at the moment.
Well watch what you say
Because when someone hears phrases like "atrocities commited" it sounds as if you're saying these guys actually bombed the little brown people or something along those lines.
i'll try to be more careful
by the way, alan watt has described "political correctness" as another example of the "alpha hypnotic state," in case you were wondering.
And I thought...
that you just got on a team as a way to play a game you really liked. Of course some team sports are team sports like soccer or basketball - games where players are required to play both offense and defense. And others are team sports like football - where generally you're playing either offense or defense and there is the possibility that you may have to switch mid play (fumble, interception) Still others are teams in which players play both offense and defense, but the situation is prescribed - baseball, cricket - you are either batting or in the field. And then there is a sport like amateur wrestling or track and field where you are a member of a team, but you have to perform always on your own. There are probably some situations I've missed (games aren't limited to sport) but, no matter what kind of team you are on, don't forget it's the sport that you are playing, be true to the game and be a good sportsman. Simple rules for simple lives.
Assert Your Authority
Assert Your Authority
Bring out the hatchets and
Bring out the hatchets and let the self immolation begin.
On a serious note, we should always question our beliefs and our premises. We should question our authorities and verify that we have not strayed from the first principles of liberty.
I am not afraid for this community. There are so many who are so paranoid here, that every action and mass movement of significance is questioned for possible advancement of authoritarian and anti-liberty forces. (I mean the word paranoid in the most respectful and kindest of ways. I am sure you all understand.)
republic
yes very good.
People are rewarded by the brain via stimulation for conversing and agreeing with those who reflect points which resonate with their own, and conversely, are also rewarded by the same mechanism to blindly argue the points of those which are contrary to their beliefs. People basically stim-out on arguing opinions of which they feel strongly (and likely as you say by having verified information reflected back at them by other sources, be damned you all got it from the same source).
I would agree that for the most part collectively identify ourselves to a cause, but i will say (with the utmost respect to you all) is that if theres anything ive learned from this forum is that while politically aligned the closest with you all, by all other measures i find myself largely incompatible with the views most people here hold.
I think some people here (j-bragg, FMoL, et al) would argue that even us as the 'third half' of the political spectrum is largely blind to the world that we actually live in today. We cling to bible and constitution to proclaim the 'correct' path as we interpret our founding fathers had intended, and regardless if that is true, its largely irrelevant in face of the historic events which have happened since then.
I think that in a sense there needs to be a campaign of true education of our nations hidden history of events and law in order to bridge the profound gap of knowledge of the situation we all find ourselves in today. We should all know at this point that information often lies and should also know that history is written by those who own the printing presses.
Admittedly i was entrenched into the fear and panic which is disseminated by this community by nearly all of its headline topics (aside from the occasional cheery off-topic topics) for a very long time. I contributed to the campaigns i felt might actually make a difference and i was really gung ho on pro-constitutionality and libertarianism and was finding myself seriously misaligned with most of my friends and family (ok pretty much all of them). It was thanks to a few members on this site i led onto a track of education that goes far beyond what we inherently believe to be true today, things like living in a constitutional republic and that our govt should operate under limited powers and that states are sovereign and this and that - things which all SHOULD be true, ignoring the history which has happened from the start until today.
It would be very encouraging if more people would take the plunge so we can spend more time actively educating ourselves on the real system of law that we operate under today and what freedoms (read privileges) we're granted. that way we can learn how to truly defend and protect our property and rights under proper law.
Otherwise i feel like mainly i come here to the community to read the latest headlines of whats going on in the world from an alternative perspective.
I share your skepticism
i share your skepticism on those that stick to the Bible or the Constitution as examples of something that we can strive for to resolve today's problems.
Like you said, if history is any indicator, then that obviously won't work. Maybe, long ago in the past, we have been able to solve things with a tweak to an economic policy here, or a tweak to a military policy, there. But that cannot possibly work, today.
That is because our foreign policies, domestic policies, economic policies, and military policies are all based on our root beliefs about life. Sure, maybe one day the anti-war protesters will succeed in getting our troops out of the war on terrorism, but how long will it be before our government goes into yet another unnecessary war? You see, it will only be a matter of time before our core beliefs about life start reflecting in policy, again. And obviously there are a few false beliefs that our leaders subscribe to. Such as the one that killing people is an acceptable means of settling disagreements. Or the one that taking from others is okay, so long as it is done in the name of altruism. Or we believe that God is a vengeful, spiteful, hateful God, so we behave with vengeance, spite, and hate, ourselves. We believe we are separate from eachother, so we kill ourselves and steal from ourselves, without the slightest hint of irony. We believe we powerless mice in a pre-determined maze, so we give our personal creative powers away and leave it up to others to mold our future.
That is why the next revolution is going to be a spiritual one. One that will change our core beliefs about life. It will only be then, when our foreign, domestic, economic, and military policies will make a functional change -- since they can no longer be based on archaic, false, dysfunctional inaccuracies of the past.
Good point
As John Adams said, "The Revolution was effected before the War commenced. The Revolution was in the minds and hearts of the people; a change in their religious sentiments of their duties and obligations....This radical change in the principles, opinions, sentiments, and affections of the people, was the real American Revolution."