0 votes

Why we will lose in Afghanistan

"What we are hardly ever told about the country is that it has been for 300 years the scene of a bitter civil war, says Christopher Booker

As both Britain and America are plunged into an orgy of tortured introspection over what we are doing in Afghanistan, a further very important factor needs to be fed into the discussion, because it helps to explain not only why we have got into such a tragic mess but also why our armed intervention in that unhappy country is doomed.

What we are hardly ever told about Afghanistan is that it has been for 300 years the scene of a bitter civil war, between two tribal groups of Pashtuns (formerly known as Pathans). On one side are the Durranis – most of the settled population, farmers, traders, the professional middle class. On the other are the Ghilzai, traditionally nomadic, fiercely fundamentalist in religion, whose tribal homelands stretch across into Pakistan as far as Kashmir.

The staggering cost of crazed quangocrats Ever since Afghanistan emerged as an independent nation in 1709, when the Ghilzai kicked out the Persians, its history has been written in the ancient hatred between these two groups. During most of that time, the country has been ruled by Durrani, who in 1775 moved its capital from the Ghilzai stronghold of Kandahar up to Kabul in the north. Nothing has more fired Ghilzai enmity than the many occasions when the Durrani have attempted to impose their rule from Kabul with the aid of "foreigners", either Tajiks from the north or outsiders such as the British, who invaded Afghanistan three times between 1838 and 1919 in a bid to secure the North-west Frontier of their Indian empire against the rebellious Ghilzai."

continue reading here
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/columnists/christopherboo...




Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

they'll win at what they're

they'll win at what they're there for. they won't win the fight.

Guerrilla wars...

are always won by the guerrilllas.

Guerrilla wars end when the guerrillas quit fighting....and they can go on for a long time because they never compete in a major battle. It is death by a thousand knife wounds. We will never win this fight...It's deja' vu allover again.