Will a S604 failure jump start the Repeal The 17th Amendment movement?

0 votes

While Dr. Paul's bill HR1207 enjoys the support of 72% (314/435) of the House, the companion bill in the Senate, S604, has been mired for quite some time at only 31% (31/100). To make matters worse, Judd Gregg (R-NH) recently stated that he would filibuster against the bill in the Senate. Why the disparity? Well, it all goes back to that dreadful year of 1913. That was the year that the Federal Income Tax (16th Amendment) and the Federal Reserve were created, and the 17th Amendment adopted (maybe). The Founding Fathers had it right when they set up the House (People's House) and the Senate (State's House). Representatives were elected by the people and Senators were elected/appointed by state legislatures. Senators represented the wishes of their state and were a check on any wild ideas that may come out of the House. The 17th Amendment took the power of appointing Senators away from the states and allowed them to be voted on by the people. That Amendment created the perfect storm for corruption. Now Senators are really "super Representatives" with 4.35x more voting clout than Representatives (100 vs 435), and they are around for 6 years rather than 2. So if you have big bucks and have an agenda, where are you going to get more bang for your buck than by buying a Senator? That is exactly what has happened. Senator Durbin (D-IL) confirmed it a few months ago when he publicly stated that "The banks own the Senate"! And it is not just the banks. It is also the military-industrial complex, big pharma, corporate agriculture and the big buck list goes on and on.
So, in my few short years in following this stuff closely (thanks to RP and the DP), I have not seen such a great disconnect between what the people (House) want and what big money/corruption (Senate) wants. We need this example to go viral and wake the sheep up. We need to Repeal the 17th Amendment. Then we can tackle the Federal Income Tax and the Federal Reserve, hopefully before it is too late for America, which I personally fear it may be.

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

One more bump

for those who missed it.

interesting

I did miss this over the weekend because I had only been on the site for a couple of brief checks ( my daily news source). Glad to see it coming back around. This makes a lot of sense. This will be a good talking point for Thanksgiving get togethers. Something I would think wouldn't divide or get into conspiracy accusations.

chinkadaro

BUMP... Completely agree!

Debra Medina for Texas Governor 2010!

Rand Paul for US Senate in Kentucky!

Ron Paul 2012, Join or Die!

DONT TREAD ON ME

AN APPEAL TO HEAVEN - WASHINGTON'S CRUISERS

Ron Paul / Rand Paul ...The Taxpayers' Best Friends!
RESTORE AMERICA NOW

AN APPEAL TO HEAVEN - Washington's Cruisers
http://www3.villanova.edu/centennial/js1g.htm

Leave Us Alone and Bring the Troops Home

For those who missed it this past weekend,

a bump.

This is spot-on. While I think 10th Amendment resolutions are

good, I believe the repeal of the 17th Amendment is more important. The 10th amendment resolutions are not law. They do not protect the states from the encroachment of the federal government, but the Senate would, if the senators represented their states as the Founders intended. It is part of the check-and-balance system that is now unbalanced.

Debbie

Hmmm, do we need some sort

of plan for action to keep things moving forward.

Prepare & Share the Message of Freedom through Positive-Peaceful-Activism.

There are some small groups around

if you search the Internet. What is really needed is a high profile spokesman promoting the idea from an organization. Zell Miller, former Senator from GA recommended Repeal of the !7th Amendment as he left office several years ago.He still has good name recognition and would be a good choice. Perhaps, if Peter Schiff gets elected he might be a spokesman for such a movement. I am going to paraphrase my post and send it to the Seattle Times as a Letter to the Editor and I encourage anyone else to do the same for their local papers. We need the populace to begin thinking for themselves about this because we are not going to get one iota of help from the MSM.