0 votes

The Lies That Bind: American Myth Obscures Murderous Enterprise

by Chris Floyd

The all-pervasive, ever-hardening myth of American Exceptionalism has a death-grip on the American psyche.

The longevity and universality of this pernicious mindset is in no way a mitigation of it. It does not reduce by one iota the responsibility -- the blood-guilt -- of any society that adheres to such a myth, and uses it to "justify" (indeed, celebrate) horrendous crimes.

It is American Exceptionalism that we must deal with in our time. And although the belief of this particular bunch of bare, fork'd animals that they are special is nothing new, the gargantuan, ravenous military force that backs up this delusion is unprecedented in world history. It is only in its destructiveness, real and potential, that the American system is indeed exceptional.

Silber gives a cogent description of the American myth [and see his original essay for the many important links]:

In the most extreme (and, one could argue, most consistent) version of this [exceptionalist] tale, non-Western parts of the world are less than human -- and they are subhuman by choice. They are immoral, and sometimes even evil. Since we represent the good and they represent the evil, we are surely entitled to improve them, by invasion and bombing if necessary. If they do not threaten us today, they might at some indeterminate time in the future. And while we might kill many innocent civilians in our campaign of civilization, those who survive will be infinitely better off than they would have been otherwise. Besides, how "innocent" can any of them be -- since they are members of inferior, less than fully human civilizations, and since they are so by choice?

Silber then points out the sickening consequences of this nationalist fundamentalism:

With this belief system as the unchallengeable foundation, a vast number of Americans render themselves completely unable to recognize the devastating consequences of the American State's actions abroad. Whenever those consequences threaten to announce themselves in an unavoidable manner, most Americans will explicitly deny or avoid them through an endless variety of stratagems. When all else fails, their ultimate defense will be the cloaked restatement of the myth's message: the lives of those other people are simply not of the same value as our own. ...

A terrifyingly awful example of this phenomenon is the disappearance of the nightmarish tragedy of Iraq from our national conversation. Remember that Iraq never posed a serious threat to the United States, and that our leaders knew that it posed no such threat. Therefore, the U.S. invasion and occupation represent an ongoing series of war crimes. This is not an arguable point in any respect. Since it cannot be argued, it is ignored altogether.

read in full
http://www.chris-floyd.com/

*********
Arthur Silber's Essay that Chris refers to:

We Are Not Special, and There Is No Happy Ending: The Blood-Drenched Darkness of American Exceptionalism
http://powerofnarrative.blogspot.com/2010/07/we-are-not-spec...

*********
related article

Invisible Holocaust: Iraqi Sanction Criminals Seek Reprise in Iran
http://www.dailypaul.com/node/140705




Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Thanks Thomas

I just gave that post a self bump!

DEAD SOULS:The Pentagon Plan To Create Remorseless "Warfighters"

http://www.dailypaul.com/node/131620

and thank you also RPWND for digging this current post out about American Exceptionalism and the other one about the Genocide in Iraq ..I had posted it before with the original title..your title was more controversial and got more attention! Thanks and Kudos! I was tempted after seeing little response to re-title it myself to:

"Vast pestiferous slagheaps of dead children"

original title and post
Invisible Holocaust: Iraqi Sanction Criminals Seek Reprise in Iran
http://www.dailypaul.com/node/140705

Sometimes you need a sensational re-title to get the article and discussion going!

Thank you for your input! I like your passion! ;-)

"I think we are living in a world of lies: lies that don't even know they are lies, because they are the children and grandchildren of lies." ~ Chris Floyd

Hey Liberte,

I originally saw the post on AntiWar.com, and forwarded it to others but did not post it on Dailypaul because I saw you did. Then I saw the amount of comments, and decided to state it like it is. This society does not ever want to state it like it is, so therefore do the opposite, and state it like it is.

Thank you for posting the article. You inspired me to repost it. I did not post it because I knew it would sink to the bottom, but decided to retitle it. When possible, "hit people in the head" with the truth that no one wants to admit. You can do what I did when it comes to titles of threads, which is to speak the TRUTH, come what may.

Thank you Liberte.

"None are more hopelessly enslaved than those who falsely believe they are free." Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

As the Palaces Burn(click below video)
http://www.youtube.com/watchv=wfj2OWBocAc&feature=related

It's All Good...But I am not LibBerte

I am Liberty_Belle..I'm just me.. a fledging imperfict total of MY experiences thus far..and how I process what I see..I am Me and *I* am *I*.

Just sharing my journey here with the most lovable community ever...DP! I have more ..but what I manage to hold back is 'indelicate.'

'LibBerte' is a whole fantastic different person altogether ( I aspire to share his wisdom and qualities).. but he is one of my very favorite friends/teachers. I am sorry if you have missed his wisdom, entertainment and humor. Well.. he is a very wise soul and my very favorite 'teacher'

I cannot let the confusion between screen names stand! I'M NOT WORTHY!!! LOL!!!

"I think we are living in a world of lies: lies that don't even know they are lies, because they are the children and grandchildren of lies." ~ Chris Floyd

Sorry, was typing fast and didn't double check

I knew who I was talking too, just screwed up.

"None are more hopelessly enslaved than those who falsely believe they are free." Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

As the Palaces Burn(click below video)
http://www.youtube.com/watchv=wfj2OWBocAc&feature=related

bump

Thanks as always LB.

Website:
http://www.libertypoet.com/
Twitter:
http://twitter.com/LibertyPoet
“The most important element of a free society, where individual rights are held in the highest esteem, is the rejection of the initiation of violence.” Dr. Ron Paul

WOW, WOW, WOW

This guy always says things so well. I was just talking to family about this very thing! Thanks

Thomas Jefferson: “Indeed, I tremble for my country when I reflect that God is just, that His justice cannot sleep forever."

Viva La Revolucion!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FmaTNf4YhEs

powerful stuff, and . . .

I'm bumping it; thank you, Belle.

it's hard to be awake; it's easier to dream--

I think Floyd

is a little mixed-up in this article, by attempting to equate the imperial exploits of the state, with an "American Exceptionalism" view of the people. I don't see that equation as valid.
I think it is perfectly possible to view ones-self as "exceptional", without having anything to do with gov't, or "self-aggrandizement" or racism or tribalism. It may in fact be quite accurate, based on real accomplishment.
Floyd's equating of these two things is quite a stretch, and in my mind would be a non-sequitur. A feeling of exceptionalism does NOT logically create a desire for world plunder. But an out of control state may very well do it, regardless whether it has a "feeling of exceptionalism" or not. It might do it just because it can, due to military power being solely at the whim of the state.

The state is an entity unto itself. It is not a reflection of the people's wills, in almost all cases.
In the case of the "war" situation, which he focuses on here, the cause was NOT "American Exceptionalism" at all, but was in fact caused by a propaganda exercise by the state, which informed them that "we were under attack", and therefore the public response was created by this propaganda. And because of that, this action was tolerated and even promoted by certain factions of people, because of effects of propaganda making them think as if it were "self-defense".
They were misinformed, by the state, for purposes which the state entity wanted.

Floyd is a talented writer, but he's way too leftist for me.

The Myths That Made an Empire

"Contrary to what Presidents Truman, Eisenhower, and Bush have taught, America’s freedom and prosperity do not depend on democracy taking root in foreign lands"

http://www.amconmag.com/blog/the-myths-that-made-an-empire/

"None are more hopelessly enslaved than those who falsely believe they are free." Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

As the Palaces Burn(click below video)
http://www.youtube.com/watchv=wfj2OWBocAc&feature=related

the state may be choosing to follow *its* own star, but . . .

the 'people' have been VERY successfully propogandized--

very successfully . . .

into believing *they/we* are exceptions and superior.

It's very simple.

it's hard to be awake; it's easier to dream--

Well, Let's agree to disagree

on Floyd and Silber because I think they are both dead on regarding American Exceptionalism/Nationalism!

This 'all or nothing attitude' some have here is a huge stumbling block! Sometimes you find a lot of truth/agreement/ understanding and potential growth in unusal places! I don't think I know ANYONE now that I agree with 100%!!

;-)

"I think we are living in a world of lies: lies that don't even know they are lies, because they are the children and grandchildren of lies." ~ Chris Floyd

Yes I realize that I seem to be

"all or nothing" in alot of cases.

From my experience, forming coalitions with those who seek to put you in chains is not a fruitful effort.

The best that could be said of the "anti-war left" is that they just want to spend that stolen tax money on other things that the gov't controls us with.

And the neocons are nothing more than the "pro-war left".
The left is controlling everything opposing us.
There is very little "right" remaining.

That's the reason why the "left/right paradigm" is a false choice now. It's all left, whichever side you choose, but they use different names. Except for us.

The TRUTH speaks for itself

whether spouted by "left" or "right". The TRUTH is the TRUTH and speaks for itself, no matter the beliefs of those who spouted the TRUTH.

I don't support "lefties" nor do I support "righties", and neither should you. Support the TRUTH.

"None are more hopelessly enslaved than those who falsely believe they are free." Johann Wolfgang von Goethe

As the Palaces Burn(click below video)
http://www.youtube.com/watchv=wfj2OWBocAc&feature=related