Why both sides of the Rand Paul/GMO labeling debate are missing the point
Submitted by annica2 on Mon, 06/25/2012 - 18:42First, I am an organic farmer. I work every day in this country and many others growing organic food and assisting other organic growers and educational organizations. I know the GMO/biotech issue quite well, and I have a long history of attaining knowledge of the intricacies surrounding it.
The recent debate over whether or not Rand Paul was right or wrong in voting against the mandatory GMO labeling amendment is a part of what the over-privileged industry wants from us. We should be questioning why labeling is even the big issue here at all...We all know the business cycle very well from reading plenty of Mises and Hayek, and how many other less divisive pick axes we could have thrown at the FDA/Monsanto powerhouse....an end to subsidies, reigning in monopolistic intellectual property or even reforming crazy litigation practices that doubly victimize farmers.
The group that spearheaded the labeling initiative(The Organic Consumers Association) is a Merck and Rockefeller funded organization that operates in disguise of anti-biotech activism. The organization's president frequently trashes John Mackey, a Ron Paul supporter and CEO of Whole Foods, our largest non-GMO distributor and most well positioned competitor in the grocery market. So, not only does the organization release way too many shallow anti-Whole Foods articles, they also champion divisive issues that stand no chance of galvanizing activists from all intellectual angles.
Sure, labeling may be a small punch to the GMO industry, and sure, it also means another heavy handed government regulatory scheme. But, this shouldn't become a debate over whether the classical liberal or paleo-conservative approach is best. This is a very important issue, so it is important to pay attention and find common ground with all of your anti-establishment friends without being divided and conquered by the interests you're supposedly against.
- Login to post comments





If things remain how they are
regarding subsidies to gmo's and if they don't label something gmo if it is in fact gmo (which really is just more regulations if the govt forced companies to do something, something that the free market can decide,) I can imagine someone suing con-agra or monsanto for some ailment they got from it. I really believe that someone will come along, hire a good lawyer, have scientits / honest doctors testify, and sink the gmo companies, and make "gmo" a bad word. That is one way the free market / honest justice system works. Also, companies (like whole foods) will have a market for people who want to know for 100% fact that they are buying organic food. If the majority of our society started to only purchase organic food w/o gmo's, more organic businesses would open who test the food, garentee it is all natural / organic / gmo free, and certify everything.
“When a well-packaged web of lies has been sold gradually to the masses over generations, the truth will seem utterly preposterous and its speaker a raving lunatic.” – Dresden James
This is a little inaccurate.
Whole Foods is also in support of labeling GMO products. I'm not sure how you overlooked this. They have a very vocal and public stance on this. They are NOT run by Merck or the Rockefellers.
right. i'm also not
right. i'm also not necessarily against labeling. i just find it an odd pick to choose from. you're using a bit of conflation here. i said the organic consumers association is funded by merck and rockefeller.
When I googled it...
This was the first thing I found...
http://www.organicconsumers.org/articles/article_23905.cfm
Which seems to say the opposite of what you are saying.
Thanks for the info!
Can you link to more info on this group?
http://www.dailypaul.com/1780
http://www.dailypaul.com/178036/millions-against-monsanto-ca... .. sure! this has a link that should produce the right domino effect.
It's not going to matter
It's not going to matter whether your community gardening partner is a socialist or capitalist as long as you both know how to pull weeds and water the corn well enough. just pay closer attention.