0 votes

How Do We Do This: Change the Supreme Court Majority Ruling from a 5 to 4 Majority to a 6 to 3 Majority

Currently, the Supreme Court of the U.S. can make law with a majority vote of just one, meaning that with a tie of 4 to 4, one single judge can decide whether to allow or disallow any decision by the court.

I would like to submit a petition to the now-popular white house petition site to change this to a 6-3 majority.

Input please?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Interesting

I can't find anything that specifically defines what constitutes a majority in judicial cases. It may well just be the result of courts moving from individual judges making their opinions to judges either agreeing or disagreeing with the chief justice's opinion. Article III of the Constitution is the section that defines the judicial branch of the government. Since that Article doesn't define what constitutes a majority opinion, a majority opinion should be able to be defined by Congress without running afoul of the Constitution.

Justices are appointed by the President with approval by the Senate. I suspect that when you have a Democrat President and a Democrat majority in the Senate, they are going to want to preserve simple majority opinions when the court is staffed by left-leaning judges. If the court was filled with right-leaning judges, the current Senate and Executive would probably want to hamstring those judges and might be more apt to support such a change. So, to do what you are proposing, you would have to pretty much have a majority of judges that leaned opposite of the entire Legislative and Executive branches. I think only then would an acting body of Congress be willing to restrict the Judicial branch.

________________________________________

I think it's a great exercize

Why not write a resolution and shop it to your GOP committees see if you can get a conresscritter or Rand to bite.

Petition?

???

Don't feed the pandas. Ever.