36 votes

Apple Inc. is Anti-Liberty in Every Way

I was recently downvoted on a post where a video was posted as an iTunes exclusive when I said I refused to download Apple's garbageware to watch the video. I realize many of us at the DP still do not know how anti-liberty Apple really is. I suppose I should elaborate for the Apple protectionists out there. The simple idea of being an 'exclusive' medium for an advertisement sounds exactly like Apple. That is not the only reason I will not support this company, there are MANY that have slowly formed over the years.

1. Apple is a bully to its users, and its developers. I am a developer by trade. Apple has repeatedly used their terms of service to restrict what kinds of apps we are allowed to develop for their platform in order to protect their own stock apps from competition. They have been forced to relent a bit on this but trust me this was not by choice.

2. When Apple files for patents like this one it helps illustrate their corporate personality, and their position on freedom. It allows the government to remotely shut down all iphone cameras within range of a kill signal. This can be used at protests for example: http://www.zdnet.com/apple-patent-could-remotely-disable-pro...

3. Proprietary connectivity for no real reason is immoral and anti-competitive. It is legal, however it certainly isn't 'free' as in freedom. It is another form of a digital cage. Apple forces you to purchase new chargers and accessories from one device to the next. This practice is purely for profit. This is something the rest of the industry has finally stopped doing after standards have become accepted... except of course for Apple.

4. They absolutely abuse the concept of intellectual property (which I personally believe should be completely dissolved - this is like saying you can patent a mathematical equasion). You should ne be able to patent round rectangles for example. Apple is suing dozens of companies at this very moment, all for intellectual property disputes. For more on why I fundimentally disagree with this, watch this short documentary on IP: http://patentabsurdity.com/watch.html

5. Apple bundles lots of extra crap into all of its windows software (hence the garbageware comment). iTunes installed loads of background services which are completely unrelated to iTunes and start every time you tun on your computer. iTunes is a resource hog, it is intentionally crippled to 'lock' you into Apple products / services / multimedia formats. They want all music to be loaded with DRM, and they are happy to completely wipe out your music collection if you aren't careful. Some of it you can remove during installation, some of it you cannot.

6. They use the 'American Company' routine to encourage 'patriotic purchases', but in truth staffing, component purchases, assembly, etc. are primarily outsourced. For example, one of their chief rivals, South Korean Samsung provides more jobs in the US than Apple does. Read more: http://www.rjkoehler.com/2012/08/28/samsung-better-for-ameri...

7. Worker conditions seem to be unimportant to Apple when it comes to foreign employees. It farms out its labor to China where workers are clearly not doing very well. In fact, after a series of worker suicides at the factory the company has installed suicide nets, and imposed strict anti suide policies. How do you get people to stop killing themselves? We all know the answer to that is more rules and restrictions right? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foxconn_suicides

8. Apple conspires with major companies to keep prices artificially high. They did it with music, then movies and tv shows, and even ebooks: http://articles.latimes.com/2012/apr/11/business/la-fi-tn-eb...

9. Hackintoshes being 'illegal' is BS. If I buy their software, and build my own computer... how can it be illegal for me to put that software I purchased on the hardware I purchased??? Well, according to Apple's TOS it is, and if you try it they will sue the iCrap out of you like they did to one local company here in south FL called Psystar a few years back: http://www.techspot.com/news/48604-psystar-loses-latest-appe...

I could literally go on and on listing the disgusting business practices of this company. What I cannot figure out is why most people seem to have no idea (or not care), even a community as well informed as this one. Are there any others out there who understand where I'm coming from here?

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I am not promoting Microsoft

I buy PC computers that I assemble myself, mother boards, RAM, hard-drives, cases, power supplies... I just plug them together, and I have a "Windows" pc, that I can install Windows on, I could put Linux on it, and can even put Hackintosh on it, albeit against their wishes.

What can I do if I buy a Mac? Nothing. If I buy a Windows PC with Microsoft Windows on it, I can reformat it and get it running without Windows and without Microsoft... try doing that with a Mac.

I love the free market; if everyone stopped buying Apple, they would be forced to change the way they do business or go out of business. But just buying from them because it is trendy or their computer has a cool looking shape, instead of researching specifications, does not help the free market.

Phxarcher87's picture

What

is the solution to these problems you write about?

lately i have been trying to not mention a problem or bad idea unless i have a solution...

"Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect" - Mark Twain

My post was about the issue

My post was about the issue of grand misconception regarding Apple. My goal was to help illustrate the fact that there *is* a problem with Apple to begin with. The solution for me was to post information for others to read / verify / consider. As you an see from the comments people tend to get very emotional if you say anything bad about Apple, so, baby steps.

The solution to the problems the post describes is the same as most other big problems:

- don't allow companies to lobby the organizations who regulate them
- get rid of patents on software. Thats what copyright is for just like music and novels.
- enforce property laws - If I buy it, I own it, Apple does not and they should not be allowed to create rules restricting what I do with my property.

There are literally thousands of other manufacturers to purchase computing components from, and a variety of operating systems available from non slimeball companies. It's not hard to do better than apple in that category imho.

- Grow Mushrooms at Home
http://subfarms.com

I agree. It just amazes me

I agree.

It just amazes me when I see people complain about PRIVATE/PUBLIC corporations/businesses. Don't buy from them... or start your own thing..

If you disagree with me on anything you are not a real libertarian...

What's wrong with complaining?

Isn't that part of free market? We all hear the complaints and can decide for ourselves if they are warranted and we should buy from such companies.
If they are asking for government to do something about it in some form of regulation then that's where I see the problem.

Complaining is useless unless

Complaining is useless unless you are going to DO something about it...

If you disagree with me on anything you are not a real libertarian...

TwelveOhOne's picture

Spider Robinson would disagree

"Pain shared is diminished; joy shared, increased."

This thread is an instance of "pain shared". It is diminished in the poster and the populace by our learning about this and spreading the news.

Speaking is also doing.

I love you. I'm sorry. Please forgive me. Thank you.
http://fija.org - Fully Informed Jury Association
http://jsjinc.net - Jin Shin Jyutsu (energy healing)

TwelveOhOne's picture

I upvoted you

But I'll also say, discussing problems/issues with others leads to the Open Source mantra, "many eyes make all bugs shallow."

I love you. I'm sorry. Please forgive me. Thank you.
http://fija.org - Fully Informed Jury Association
http://jsjinc.net - Jin Shin Jyutsu (energy healing)