The Daily Paul has been archived. Please see the continuation of the Daily Paul at Popular

Thank you for a great ride, and for 8 years of support!
22 votes

Former Israeli Minister: "Anti-semitic - It's a Trick. We Always Use it."

Amy Goodman interviews a former Israeli minister and she helps expose this trick used against dissidents, the defamation tactic of calling people “anti-Semitic.”

Trending on the Web

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.


Here is more info on Israeli geneticist researcher Eran Elhaik - who claims to prove that:

Majority of Israeli population (and in fact majority of worldwide Jewish population including in USA/Europe) which are dominated by Ashkenazi are NOT exclusively Semitic at all!! According to his research claims they're significantly Caucasian!

Immoral funding of Military Industrial Complex by Federal Reserve and US taxation system must stop!!!! End illegal/unconstitutional wars! Preserve US currency!

That would not marry up with

That would not marry up with the archaeological and historical evidence.

They are not Caucasian. That would imply they crossed the Caucus mountains with Israelite tribes that migrated eastwards into Europe.

Luke 3:38
Isaiah 43:3-5


But wait, your post is confusing me. The link in your post exactly addresses this point. It seems to agree with my post & contradict your statement "not marry up with the archaeological and historical evidence".

It is talking about this same researcher Eran Elhaik, whom the Zionists hate. Excerpt from link you posted:

===== begin quote ======

Most prominent among those scientists Elhaik believes to be dishonest is Harry Ostrer is a professor of pathology and genetics at Yeshiva University’s Albert Einstein College of Medicine and the author of “Legacy: A Genetic History of the Jewish People,” which was published last year.

But Ostrer and other geneticists refused to talk on the record about Elhaik or his study, and none of them responded in peer reviewed academic journals where letters and brief comments are published without having to go through the time-consuming peer review process.

====== end quote =======

What exactly do you mean by "crossed the Caucus mountains with Israelite tribes that migrated eastwards into Europe"? Are you referring to the propaganda explanation of migration of "Ashkenaz Germanic Jews" to Eastern Europe OR Khazarian migration?

If it's the latter:

Poland, Hungary, Germany, Czech Republic are all to the WEST of Caucus mountains. [Azerbaijan, Georgia, Armenia, Dagestan, Chechnya etc.] That's the general region in Caucus mountains where old Khazar republic is supposed to have existed. Any crossing of Caucus mountains and migration into Europe is presumed to be Westwards, not Eastwards.

As said before, please clarify exactly what you mean. Thanks for posting that link BTW, it corroborates my earlier 2 posts.

Immoral funding of Military Industrial Complex by Federal Reserve and US taxation system must stop!!!! End illegal/unconstitutional wars! Preserve US currency!


Apologies for the D'oh moment. Should have have read westwards.

Problem lies with most people thinking Jews are of Israel, the descendants of Jacob. Which they are not.

Luke 3:38
Isaiah 43:3-5


Huge basis of US Foreign policy, extracting taxes out of American population like leeches to fund Zionist lies and murders are based on this hypothesis of "Semitic people of Holy Land". Largest percent of Israeli Jewish diaspora are Ashkenazi. NOT Sephardic. Definitely NOT Mizrahis who are genetically and linguistically proven to be Semites. The Yiddish language spoken by Ashkenaz for hundreds of years only has "borrow words" from Hebrew. It is in no way a Semitic language. It is an Indo-European language of Germanic origin, and intermixed with few Slavic, Magyar and very small amounts of Turkic language aspects.

The hypothesis of "Semitic people of Holy Land" is used to spawn abominations like Christian Zionism, using twisted variations of Scofield Bible. And it is used to tell sickening Christian Zionist lies by political opportunistic "historians" like Newt Gingrich that Palestinians are "invented" people.

An Israeli genetic scientist Eran Elhaik just published (few months ago in Dec. 2012) this research paper investigating this whole "Semitic" racial connotation.

The Missing Link of Jewish European Ancestry: Contrasting the Rhineland and the Khazarian Hypotheses

The question of Jewish ancestry has been the subject of controversy for over two centuries and has yet to be resolved. The “Rhineland hypothesis” depicts Eastern European Jews as a “population isolate” that emerged from a small group of German Jews who migrated eastward and expanded rapidly. Alternatively, the “Khazarian hypothesis” suggests that Eastern European Jews descended from the Khazars, an amalgam of Turkic clans that settled the Caucasus in the early centuries CE and converted to Judaism in the 8th century. Mesopotamian and Greco–Roman Jews continuously reinforced the Judaized empire until the 13th century. Following the collapse of their empire, the Judeo–Khazars fled to Eastern Europe. The rise of European Jewry is therefore explained by the contribution of the Judeo–Khazars. Thus far, however, the Khazars’ contribution has been estimated only empirically, as the absence of genome-wide data from Caucasus populations precluded testing the Khazarian hypothesis. Recent sequencing of modern Caucasus populations prompted us to revisit the Khazarian hypothesis and compare it with the Rhineland hypothesis. We applied a wide range of population genetic analyses to compare these two hypotheses. Our findings support the Khazarian hypothesis and portray the European Jewish genome as a mosaic of Near Eastern-Caucasus, European, and Semitic ancestries, thereby consolidating previous contradictory reports of Jewish ancestry. We further describe a major difference among Caucasus populations explained by the early presence of Judeans in the Southern and Central Caucasus. Our results have important implications for the demographic forces that shaped the genetic diversity in the Caucasus and for medical studies.

Immoral funding of Military Industrial Complex by Federal Reserve and US taxation system must stop!!!! End illegal/unconstitutional wars! Preserve US currency!

Cyril's picture

Yeah, the good old trick

Yeah, likewise, I have often heard from crass ignorant silver spoon-fed pseudo-intellectuals calling me racist because I'd call b.s. their lessoning on the monopoly of past martyrdom by black people or jews or whatever... to pseudo-justify their forceful theories of better organizing society... the socialist way, of course, liberty OUT.

Never mind my father is black and the most racist people I've seen or heard from through their actions and attitudes - which always speak louder than words - in the early struggling years of my parents, were precisely more often than not of the liberal or socialist camps.

HYPOCRITES, losers, freaking LIARS.

Truth is there's no scale or ranking of martyrdom. Martyrs have only been so because of the plunder by the power hungry statists, for whatever form that unjust, brutal, inhumane "state" can take in its status quo, economically, legally, and politically.

The modern plunder and status quo of our time is all about those who spend more time voting for and taking from the state, to justify always more stealing from the shrinking working people.

But hey, the race card is still oh so convenient to be played with these days for more smoke and mirrors, isn't it?

They call you anti-semitic because you dare to question the Nanny, protective US for the preferred "state of Israhell" instead of caring for its own American people's liberty, justice, and peace?

Call them : LOSERS.

"Cyril" pronounced "see real". I code stuff.


"To study and not think is a waste. To think and not study is dangerous." -- Confucius

The context seems very clear to me...

This was one question out of an entire interview which has since been scrubbed by the owner PBS. Someone considered this question important enough to have made a clip out of it. They posted it. The context - the entire interview - would be interesting to see but wouldn't possibly be that difficult to guess at.

Chris Indeedski!

Daily Paul cured my abibliophobia.

Cyril's picture



"Cyril" pronounced "see real". I code stuff.


"To study and not think is a waste. To think and not study is dangerous." -- Confucius

Who needs someone to tell them these things?

Anti Semite is just like any race card. When you want special attention then us the race card. The gender card is used in the same way. Those who can't cut it usually have a card to play.


True, but since the kingmakers are disproportionately "Semitic," exposing the "anti-Semite" trick is one of the most important things one can do for liberty.


Name names

see video

in OP. I don't remember her name.
Granger, what is the deal on this? Is there anything anyone can say to make you stop defending "all things Israel" and look at them WITHOUT religious bias? Most "Jews" are NOT Semites, the banksters are descended from people who have taken the mantle of "Jew" to play on the religious sensibilities of the Christians. They got to you. How many people at the DP do you think are downvoting you to be mean? You get downvoted because you are wrong on this one.
The sad truth is ironic: If you support Israel, you are anti-Semitic. The POLITICAL ENTITY known as "Israel" has made a practice of genocide against the Semitic Palestinian tribes. You know, Jesus' family.

Love or fear? Choose again with every breath.

I did see video

Why would anyone want to stop me from expressing my belief? I don't try to stop you. I may not agree with you, but I am not going to try to stop you. Why would you try to stop me? Why wouldn't you open your mind and try to see it my way instead of putting up a stop sign?

Most Palestinians are not Semite.. they are GREEK descent, not Semite. Why would anyone defend Palestine tyrannical government? Do you know? Have you read the laws of Palestine? Why are people running to Israel and not Palestine if Palestine is so great.. and that goes for Syria too... Israel and USA are bad,, Palestine and Syria are good? You've got to be kidding me. I wish you were.

Israel is a religious state, not by design of the Jews, but by design of the nations who wanted to dump Jews. Why won't Germany allow anyone to question the Holocast? People blame Israel.. Israel is the victim.. I hear the term Zionist bankers.. because they are Jewsish. They may be Jewish descent, but the pray to Money, not God. Jews who never go to Temple and pray to Money are not Zionists, they are NWO operatives who dispise religion, arm both sides, and hope both sides wipe each other out. They profit off ALL victims.. and they would LOVE it if we were all Palestinians.. no rights, just bad laws, tyranny,.. but it's all covered up, instead thy focus on BAD ISRAEL, BAD USA.. and you think it's Jews.

They don't got me.. I got Jesus.

I didn't think anyone of DP was down voting me to be mean. Is that why you downvote people? I think people genuinly disagree with me, as I would have dissagereed with me for decades before Ron Paul woke me up by saying, ISRAEL SHOULD BE OUR BEST FRIEND. Those who down vote me here, admit, they do NOT agree with Ron Paul on this.. and many have never agreed with Rand because of it. Has nothing to do with being mean,, it has everything to do with genuinely not agreeing with me. Some will end their friendships with me. Thay have the choice and I will respect that choice.

The POLITICAL ENITY ISRAEL, is a Democracy, and has the right to defend the state they were dumped onto. While there may be some Semetic Palestinians.. Palestine is GREEK descent.

People here really should start studying. Ron Paul is a smart man, who is not afraid to stand up against IGNORANCE and misplaced passion. I'm with Ron and many here are not.

"Why would anyone want to stop me from expressing my belief"

You're off and running on the wrong track, granger. No one wants to stop you from expressing beliefs, we want you to learn the truth. What would a friend do? If you showed up here telling us how what a great guy Dick Cheney is, would you expect everyone to let you "express your belief" without trying to get you to examine the facts again?
You are welcome to express beliefs, but you gain more support when you express facts.
For you to close with this
"and you think it's Jews" shows how closed your mind has become on this. I go to great effort to point out the the Jews suffer the most from the Zionist political agenda, it falls on a lot of deaf Christian ears.

Love or fear? Choose again with every breath.

Who says?

I'm sorry (((((fishy)))) I don't recall asking you to mind my track. Would you mind not minding my track? Thanks.

I want YOU to learn the TRUTH.

What would a friend do? Love you anyways.

I can say good things about Cheney. I don't agree with his policies, but that does not mean I can't see good things about Cheney.

I expect nothing from anyone. I would hope for a good debate. I have watched every vid, read every clip everyone who has responded to me so generously offered, and my sources have been CIA worldfact book and wiki.. pretty general stuff.

I am planning my trip to the Mid East, and maybe I will change my mind when I get there. I hope to spend time volunteering on several different programs.. Building houses for Palestinians, digging at an archological site, and with the IDF. I want to see for myself. Meet a wide variety of people.. tour the holy land from a Catholic, Protestant, Jewish, and Muslim perspective.. that is my plan.. and maybe I will change my mind about Israel being our best friend.

But what is being said here by the majority I've said myself for decades. I was wrong, and that is not to say that I am 100%, but I feel no hatred, no anger.. just love and hope for BOTH Israel and Palestine.

I believe that hope comes from the USA, the UN, and other nations staying out of Israel's business.

I'm asking.. "AND YOU THINK IT'S JEWS?" Why no answer, but instead accusing me of having a closed mind? Worry about your own mind, and if I believe I need you to look after mine, you'll be the first to know.

The Jews suffer because of the NWO which uprooted the Zionist agenda long ago and employ that as a decoy for those who would prefer to dwell on what was rather than what is.

Israel and the USA suffer the most from the NWO agenda, because Americans and Isralis appreciate freedom, something most never knew.

Take for example Syria Girl who tells us government is freedom. Government is good. She's correct about the NWO, and why Israel likes Assad, though many here want to say otherwise, no one has ever offered even an Alex Jones link to back up their words, and that includes you.

Link me up to your truth (((((fishy)))) I'll debate you.

Not doing your work for you.


I would not give you the opportunity to work for me

I may give you the opportunity to work WITH me. I did not ask you to do MY work. I asked you to name names to back your post. You failed.


How will the Granger handle the cognitive dissonance? Will she attack the messenger? Will she confront the truth head on or will she simply up the ante and demand more evidence be provided for her on a silver platter by others willing to snuff out the truth where ever politically incorrect realms it takes them.

Not all Jews are for Israel

Not all Jews appreciate freedom. Some think a NWO is a better plan.

Thanks for the list> And that second link says it's for:


Is that where you're at?

Listening to the vid.. I'm shaking me head.. the guy is wearing a Palestinian pin.. no different than Bush or Obama wearing a USA pin.

Definately this is a NWO propegandist.

so, "attack / disqualify the messenge" it is.

I called it.

You know I used to think 2 Plus 2 equaled 4. But then I heard a guy who was wearing a Palestinian pin say it. So I don't think that anymore.

what does


mean to you?

Some people can't back there arguments.

They just repeat what they have heard and then can't back it up without referring you to someone else.

That's right; it is a "trick"

'Anti-semitism' does not mean Anti-Jew:

The overwhelming majority of 'Jewish' people originally came out of Sumer, and the Sumerians were not Semetic, which refers to people of a particular language group. Therefore, to refer to 'anti-Semitism', with regard to jewish people is thoroughly inaccurate, as the Rothschilds and their circle well know.

Minister of Education

Since when is a former Minister of Education a Prime Minister?

Why not post the entire interview from PRIME BULL ShITT (PBS)?

Why just take what is easily taken out of reference?

If you want the TRUTH, publish the entire interview.

ecorob's picture

"and this justifies what we do to the palestinians..."

I don't see how you can sugarcoat that statement OR the one that said, "its a trick, we do it all the time" OR "Israel, my country, right or wrong"...

I've heard enough and you or anybody else that seeks to minimizer these statements is NO FRIEND to REAL LIBERTY in this country

please continue to expose yourself, granger (I supported romnie because it was in the "pact"...HA)

you, granger, are a are like a broken clock, you will be right about rand but very darn few other things!

its 'cos I owe ya, my young friend...
Rockin' the FREE world in Tennessee since 1957!
9/11 Truth.

WE?????? Not WE

The sentance is taken out of context, PBS removed the film, so it is impossible to put the sentence in context.. but out of context it works well for those who DECEIVE with DECEPTION.

Take it up with Ron Paul if YOU think Israel is no friend.

I will continue to be myself, and I am not seeking your approval.

Granger to the rescue again!!

Since when did anyone say "Prime Minister?" And what difference would it make who says it? The TRUTH is independent of WHO says it. It's everyone's burden to investigate claims made. Get off your butt, and find this "context" you need. It's out there. If you did, you'd learn there is evidence flooding the internet of logical arguments being shut down in a flash with the "anti-semite" card. That's what you call, "a trick."

Prove that this was taken out of context.

When someone eliminated the entire title

One of the ways people lie, is they don't tell THE WHOLE TRUTH.. MINISTER OF EDUCATION, probably wouldn't get much attention like, ISRAELI MINISTER..

What difference does it make who says it? SOURCE.

I'm still investigating.

So is that why the anti-semiteic card is being flashed here on DP? Is this an attempt to get the DP shut down?

I'm not calling anything a trick, the MINISTER OF EDUCATION of Israel from back in the 70s did.

Have a great posting day!

I'm sorry. I just saw this on Twitter...

posted on .

Could you link the full video, please?

Chris Indeedski!

Daily Paul cured my abibliophobia.