0 votes

Creation/Evolution Debate

Before Mike Huckabee dropped out of the race, there were people here mocking his view on creation (perhaps the only thing I agreed with him about).

The official Government/media story is that 4.6 trillion years ago, nothing exploded into the entire universe.

Somehow the moon is older than the earth, and should have had many feet of moondust on it when people walked on it in the 60's, instead of a few inches.

I want people to post their biggest reason to support one side of the issue, and their biggest problem with the other side of the

One significant issue in support of biblical creationism:

It is well established that the Bible was old 2000 years ago. There are many issues of Science which people didn't know back then.

1. Isaiah 40:22 He sits enthroned above the circle of the earth, (people didn't know the earth was round until relatively recently)

2. Leviticus- laws about quarantining, etc. people weren't that smart until the 1700's. Do you really believe this was written by mere men?

3. The flood: many ancient traditions from around the world claim that there was a major flood a long time ago, and a few people survived, in a big boat, and that the people on that boat were the ancestors of the tribe.

One significant issue in opposition to evolution.

Symbiotic relationships can't have evolved.
1. lichens are actually two interdependant organisms, growing together. one organism is a fungus, and the other is a plant (usually algae). Their reproduction occurs together, so if one had evolved prior to the other, it would have died off before the other had time to evolve.

2. Another example of mutual symbiosis is the relationship between Ocellaris clownfish that dwell among the tentacles of Ritteri sea anemones. The territorial fish protects the anemone from anemone-eating fish, and in turn the stinging tentacles of the anemone protect the clownfish from its predators (a special mucus on the clownfish protects it from the stinging tentacles).

Can anyone show how these could have evolved? I doubt it. The theory of Macroevolution assumes there was lots of time wherein the evolution could have occured. For Symbiotic relationships, you'd need the massively improbable event (which I believe is impossible) of a specific evolution to occur at the same time as another massively improbable event (which I believe is impossible) of a specific evolution to occur at exactly the same place (massively improbable) at a very near time (within hours)

Let the debate begin!

(edit on 7/8/08- This thread has created much more strife than I would have liked. I have realized that I'm not as good at creation debating as I thought. I think this whole thread should show us that less government intervention would be better, particularly on the federal level.)




Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Some where in their

Some where in their evolution theory they skipped over something unexplainable. Where did the human race receive its musical theory course? Only man can think in musical terms. Many humans can hum a melody or count out a complex beat without any instructions. Music for those who do not "feel" it must learn all the mathematical equations that make up rhythms and musical notes.
Many of us can hear a perfect octave of a note... which is math. How?
Often music is played before it is transcribed. If we hear someone singing off key we know it .. How? Where does a "hook" come from? A series of notes in a precise rhythm, that makes the human mind respond. Think of mikey D's five note theme.
None of the animal kingdom share this remarkable power. We will never see a chimp play a piano or beat a drum. What part of the brain does this come from? Why do songwriters hear melodies in their heads that have to be written down?
Until someone explains to me the miracle of music I will stick with my Creator.
Besides, He gives me my rights
Peace

Religion and Gov't Subsidized Science, are both Wrong

They are both collectivist organizations and thus stymie individualism for the sake of conformity.

Science is easier to figure out -- it is a law "that's" what they are saying is "truth" -- Everything else is hypothesis or theory. Now theory is stronger than hypothesis -- it's been peer reviewed but as of yet there's no way to "prove" it 100% of the time (meaning there's some dissent).

Hypothesis is basically an educated guess -- more like a request for people to check it out; so it can then move into "theory"

The fact that Science is 99% based on Gov't Welfare or Private Contracts (using some or all gov't welfare dollars) and is devoid of free-market competitive drivers there is no impetus or properly assessed consumer demand.

Religion relies on peer concensus -- that's why there's a 100 denominations -- because they can't agree over how to "go about worship" or "interpretations" or where to place importance (relevance). So, within each group -- there is concensus of believe (socialism).

Religion does not seek consumer demand -- it is the only place in the world where consumer-desire is subjugated or suppressed. Their product is primarily comfort and meaning.

Now Jesus and all other "Masters" came here to teach individualism -- every single one over-through the dogma of their day -- the primary religion of their provence or locality or country.

The first thing to throw out if you subjugate a people is "individualism" -- that they need no intermediary. The opposite of what every master or entrepreneur or free-market tell's you.

Science puts Gov't between you and the entrepreneur.

Religion puts the Church between you and God.

Therefore I trust neither to provide me with either good ("Law" and "Meaning") -- now that's self-rule / liberty.

Octobox

Great Logic Here

To anyone halfway paying attention, we(regular smoes, the same ones that get f***** over w/ great regularity throughout history) are on the verge of totally losing any hope of stopping the reg smoe final solution-that being a PTB making a final drive for total victory on multiple fronts.

Apparently, some conclude-"Oh, good time to debate a topic that is powerfully divisive and achieves ABSOLUTELY NOTHING of MEANINGFUL SUBSTANCE related to the pressing matters at hand.

Freaking Brilliant.

Keep fiddling Neros

Closing on a positive note:

Consider this concept, please-What do supporters of Ron Paul(and everything he stands for) think about evolution/creation? We stand for and believe in Individual FREEDOM, as such, we believe that all are free to hold whatever view they wish on any matter and that it is a small price to pay for each persons Individual FREEDOM to tolerate how others exercise their Freedom as they tolerate ours.

AND/OR RP supporters are rational people that realize no one will ever have a definitive answer to that question and it has next to no relevance to public policy, which makes it a stupid question. Don't ask us stupid questions.

"You are a den of vipers and thieves."

I mean to rout you out!

-Just because you are among us, does not make you with us

-The door is wide open, anything can slither in

It appears

We may have really came from a rock.

DNA Agrees With All the Other Science: Darwin Was Right

http://discovermagazine.com/2009/mar/19-dna-agrees-with-all-...

"Study the past if you would define the future."
Confucius

"They used to come get you and lock you up because you were insane, Now they come get you and lock you up because you are sane"

Missing link between fruit fly and humans!

Amazing photo shows proof:

http://i36.photobucket.com/albums/e30/libertybelle_photos/Re...

"I think we are living in a world of lies: lies that don't even know they are lies, because they are the children and grandchildren of lies." ~ Chris Floyd

"I think we are living in a world of lies: lies that don't even know they are lies, because they are the children and grandchildren of lies." ~ Chris Floyd

lol.... is... is that... no

lol.... is... is that... no it couldn't be..... BUGMAN!

“Defiance of God’s Law will eventually bring havoc to a society.” - Dr. Ron Paul

LOL

I was looking for a picture of a minator when you put this on!

"Study the past if you would define the future."
Confucius

"They used to come get you and lock you up because you were insane, Now they come get you and lock you up because you are sane"

Try this...

If a person is here on DP participating in the recovery of the Republic, how could they ignore the presence of an intelligent being -- a creator -- who inspired the idea -- a free country -- only the second one in the recorded history of mankind -- that was founded without a king -- and still believe that evolution alone is the cause of our existence?

How?

"Creator is a judicial creator. It was a man who gave away his liberty. So it had to be a man who would legally take that liberty and authority back. So Creator created another man (let's call him second man) who did exactly that." D.W.B.

✰VIDEO! 2012 Is About Abolishing Economic Slavery In America ✰ http://www.dailypaul.com/209377/2012-is-about-abolishing-eco...

i.e.

"The revolutionary forces have to take civil society before they take the state, and therefore have to build a coalition of oppositional groups united under a hegemonic banner which usurps the dominant or prevailing hegemony." -Strinati, Dominic.

"We must re-take the Republican Party"-Ron Paul. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NlqXq8YxQFQ

billions and billion of years ago We came from a rock? not me

Or 6000 years ago the supreme being created time matter and space
how are the creationist so off base ,enough to be attacked?
Do you know everything there is to know macro evolutionists?
I do think micro evolution olny is likley ,but not cosmic or the others cant be observed or proven.
The biggest dino in the world only had nostrils the size of a horse, how did it get enough oxygen?
Oldest desert is 4000 years along with the barrier reef
There is nothing before 6000 years apx.
Is it possible you have been tricked to believe the devils story , or DO YOU KNOW EVERYTHING ? HOW CAN PEOPLE WHO PROFESS TO BELIEVE IN God NOT BELIEVE HIS WORD???
Jesus said Adam was the first ,not the rock to fish to ape to caveman to you??? There is not a geologic column ,carbon dating is a scam ,go find out for yourself
Last where did the rocks or the matter come from ???

Wow. I usually leave this stuff alone, but wow.

Where do you get your information? I'm guessing some religous book because there's no way on earth you've ever even considered the possibility that maybe you are the one who's been scammed. I don't want to argue about it with you, but come on. Besides, what makes you think God goes by our calender years? Maybe for God, a year is 10,0000 earth years. You don't know and neither do I. See, I think God has the capacity to create a world that evolves but many don't think he could possibly be THAT smart. Of course they also think God influences the Grammy awards and that he put old looking around to trick us all. At least the king put together a book and called it God's word. Everyone knows kings have no interest in keeping people one step from braindead.

I would love to explain it all to you ,but my time is too

limited. I am not a christian nor do I subscribe to any "religion" I AM a follower of Our Lord and Savior Jesus the Christ .
I read the majority text bibles(KJV,Geneva) ,I have all 9 Blacks law dictionaries books ,I have Statutes at large books from 1800's to 1900's
These books are my best books ,KJV above all.
There are many more things I dont know than I do , I admit that !
I am far from ignorant I have served Three apprenticeships in the mechanical feild - Plumbing , Sheetmetal , HVAC and Welding just for fun
I built my own house on a mountain in Alaska OUT OF POCKET BY MYSELF FROM START TO FINISH (except the well driller) .I have known about the bankers since I was a kid,have you ? do you have a slave note with 20 years interest on it paid to the bank that has zero collateral??? I have a great wife and kids(healthy).I have No debt.I lawfully pay zero in federal income taxes this year. My kids are home schooled , unvaccinated I even have 1 w/o a legal fiction and thus is
not liable to this corporation, I have not watched TELL-LIE-VISION since 07. If you knew the other side of the story then maybe you would see things more clearly ? Like i said i am not that smart , but I believe EVERY WORD IN THE BIBLE AS THE EXACT WORDS God divnely inspired to the t !!! , except the punctuation the 5 books of moses were one long run on sentence as it was IN THE BEGINNING GOD CREATED THE HEAVEN AND THE EARTH = TIME\MATTER/SPACE= UNI-VERSE=SINGLE SPOKEN SENTENCE. MIKE I WILL PRAY FOR YOU ! I WISH I COULD LOVE YOU AS MUCH AS JESUS DOES !

you are exactly where I

you are exactly where I stand..

“Defiance of God’s Law will eventually bring havoc to a society.” - Dr. Ron Paul

I'm not saying you're stupid or incapable

Or a strawman. I'm saying that evolution is a beautiful process that glorifies God with it's brilliance. You're not going to find much science in bibles or law dictionaries.

No dictionaries are just for what words were being used at the

time . Before the most recent plan for a new world order was able to defile all of our history books ,I have a screen shot in time of the vernacular used in the 1800's . No word dinosaurs in that book ,they were still around ( look up the ICA stones) ,some may be still here today. So let me get this straight scientist tell you billions and billions of years ago ,God says about 6000 years and you believe the a couple of hundred of humans that did good regurgitating info and got pushed into jobs that pay great, but only if you say hundreds and hundreds of thousands then they say million now they say billions and billions of years ,Talk about a moving goal post ,more holes then swiss cheese in the THEORY OF EVILution !

Bible = social science

I was a witness once to the fatality of a boy, ot was an accident, it was resolved by the court in NV as "An act of God".

WE ARE GOING TO WIN!

What if both views are correct?

I believe the mystery of life allows for all possibilities

Like comparing apples and oranges

Evolution explains diversity. It doesn't even begin to explain the development of complex organisms, which require extremely complex
interaction of simpler organisms. Should even one of those complex interactions fail, extinction occurs.

Evolution is used by atheists as simple-minded excuse to deny God.
Maybe the real answer is that God is neither perfect, nor even particularly good. Maybe time is an endless loop and we simply invented ourselves.

Y'all just can't leave it alone!

Had to go pull up a year and half old post?!

*****
"I think we are living in a world of lies: lies that don't even know they are lies, because they are the children and grandchildren of lies." ~ Chris Floyd

"I think we are living in a world of lies: lies that don't even know they are lies, because they are the children and grandchildren of lies." ~ Chris Floyd

Apparently

Someone by the name of "dlind" resurrected this one on Dec 13th and then again on Dec.14th.

lol my apologies. Didn't notice the dates.

I'll let sleeping dogs lie.

What you people dont understand is

the reason we are in such trouble as a nation is because the nwo has successfully DE-CHRISTIANIZED americans. This is one of the more important aspects of what we're fighting against...right up there with the fed, undeclared wars, patriot act... freakin fema camps, and global depopulation.

What is so devisive with talking about religion, even debating it? The bible played a major role in the making our country and the written of our constitution.

"All inhabitants of the earth will worship the beast--all whose names have not been written in the book of life belonging to the Lamb that was slain from the creation of the world"

If you think this is all bs... just take a look around.

http://www.jbs.org/
Semper Fortis

http://www.jbs.org/
Semper Fortis

Oh for Fu@#'s Sake!!! Stop already.

Haven't we realized this devisive stuff is poison yet?

Flying Spaghetti Monster - blessed be his noodly appendages.

"In the beginning of a change the patriot is a scarce man, and brave, and hated and scorned. When his cause succeeds, the timid join him, for then it costs nothing to be a patriot."--Mark Twain

We the people

We the people CREATED a government to protect our liberty. That government has EVOLVED into a tyrannical monster.

That's about all I know about creation vs.evolution, God and governance.

If we do not come to terms with our immediate problem, namely a fascist system bent on depriving us of every shred of liberty we have, it will matter not what I believe, it will only matter what the rulers believe.

Miamisburg, Montgomery County, Ohio

I try to refrain from posting on these topics any more.

I am a bible guy but I understand people will believe what they want.
.
Our world view starts at the core of exsistane. If a bible believer and an athiest can start from vastly different fondations and end up at the freedom message we should rejoice. We should repect eachothers beliefs.
.
Clearly we have learned that the experts are not outside the relm of bias. Many "facts" can be twisted to try to fit a particular objective. If a person wants to believe the interpretation of the evidence by experts from either side so be it. The are FREE to do so.
.
Let's just not teach theory as fact. If we ever gain power we can debate all this then. Let's focus on the task at hand. Freedom for all.
.
I do have a firm position in this pony show but I could set it aside knowing that here is not the place. When people are ready for God then I can share what I have found true.
,
if people wish to leave faith then you can share and they will listen. Positions are pretty well entrenched and a compromise seems in order.

So you really belive that everything came from nothing? Wow now that takes faith!

Patriot News
http://redpillpost.com
*
Stand up For your Civil Rights
http://SueBadCops.com

This is a six month old

This is a six month old thread. Let it die again.

dalesvp's picture

Why EITHER OR?

from my DP post 3/20/09 - When will this inane debate ever evolve into something akin to common sense?

Do you remember how the "debates" were manipulated and orchestrated so as to make a fool of Dr. Paul or eliminate Dr. Paul's superb truths or to ostracize him altogether? That framing of the debate has been going on since day one with "evolution vs creationism". Does anyone really believe the answer to Life is EITHER evolution OR creation? To get to a more realistic comprehension of LIFE (in its totality) one would by common sense have to broaden the debate frame. Personally I prefer no frame or rule set whatsoever but most people are afraid of free or critical thinking. They become uncomfortable with out-of-their-box thinking. IMHO until and unless the debate frame and/or rule set on this issue is expanded or eliminated this is a STUPID debate maintained by those in control to control what people think and how they think it
- begin new post -
as also support for their particular belief system instead of opening up to what might be considered a Greater Truth based in science or wisdom instead of belief or opinion.

In this universe there is no such thing as "nothing". There is however "no thing" meaning instead energy of some sort or as SVP likes to say "dispersed matter" as in the non-empty vacuum of Outer Space. The physical universe is constructed of Idea or "mind substance". Hence God THOUGHT the physical universe into being and its substance is centralized and individuated condensations of positive and negative flows of Mind Stuff - quantized force and energy - that expand and contract. Hence these initial constructs EVOLVED into more complex structures. The debate is not EITHER OR but a more complex intermingling of the two forces plus many others. If you really are interested in this topic from a scientific view that also includes the spiritual aspects please visit the SVPwiki where new things and concepts like "mind substance" and "God" are more precisely defined:

http://pondscienceinstitute.on-rev.com/svpwiki/tiki-index.php

You have every right to

You have every right to believe what you believe. But as a person who was a raised a roman catholic and who went to church every week for 20 years, I just don't believe in organized religion. My problem is that they start you when you are so young and defenseless, that no matter what you parents say you have to believe it.

You have every right to

You have every right to believe what you believe. But as a person who was a raised a roman catholic and who went to church every week for 20 years, I just don't believe in organized religion. My problem is that they start you when you are so young and defenseless, that no matter what you parents say you have to believe it.

And yet ...

you don't.

What makes you so special that you have been able to release yourself from such brainwashing?

WAHOR!!
http://www.dailypaul.com/node/48994