Where Does Your Allegiance Lie: With the Constitution, or the Bible?
This is an extension of the other, similarly-titled thread.
It's a very serious question, not meant to incite any harsh feelings.
I want to know where your allegiance lies, ultimately. Would you defend the Constitution even if it meant violating Biblical law or otherwise betraying your faith, or would you ultimately choose to defend the Bible, even if it meant watching the Constitution be shredded before your eyes.
Please, don't posit your own hypothetical retort. For example, please don't suggest that such a scenario would never occur, because the two are inextricably linked. I don't want to get sidetracked on that argument. I understand some people believe that America is a Christian nation. I disagree vehemently, but let's agree to disagree there. Please just play along with my hypothetical and pretend that a situation arose where you were forced to choose one or the other.
So which is it? The Bible, or the Constitution? Do you truly believe in the Bible to such an extent that you would see your country turned upside down and ultimately destroyed, or would you defend the Constitution that holds together the reality that we all share, regardless of our religious views? Would you be willing to see the Bible, and the religion it defines, snuffed out in order to save the Constitution and the country it defines?
Since some people have a hard time with hypotheticals, here are a few alternate rephrasings:
--Which matters more to you, the Bible or the Constitution?
--Which would you rather see destroyed, America or Christianity?
--If forced to choose between a world where America existed but Christianity did not, or vice versa, which would you prefer?
Again, please try as hard as you can to play along without posting comments full of equivocation. I understand this is a painful game; this is intentional.
Thanks for your replies.





















Bump
Bump
www.reverbnation.com/docholladaymusic
Truth is treason in an empire of lies.
The Constitution, of course.
I don't have any particular use for the bible. I view its relationship with law as something akin to pre-Copernican astronomy's influence on modern science. Others are free to feel differently, of course.
Sam Marsh
Musician
http://www.myspace.com/screwthebastards
Sam Marsh
Musician
http://www.myspace.com/screwthebastards
If you are a strict
If you are a strict constructionist of the Constitution, instead of a social-issues liberal, there's no conflict between the Constitution and the Bible.
I'm not saying "this is a Christian nation"--I'm saying "this is a nation with Freedom of Worship". You have a right to free exercise of your religion (whatever it is), and that includes on 'government property' as long as it doesn't involve establishment of a national Church.
SUPPORT OUR FOUNDERS' AMERICA
Support the Constitution of the United States
SUPPORT OUR FOUNDERS' AMERICA
Support the Constitution of the United States
With Myself
For I am the problem and the solution in my world.
And Jesus was my savior.
And Mohammed was a prophet from God.
Genuflect to Samuel/God to be judged and lament, but not to a Pharaoh, Pope, King or President.
I am unsure, but understanding of the Baba/Bau.
I believe Baha'u'llah/Bahai knows god's true name and Marko Rodin brought it to fame.
Gilgamesh is a mystery to me, but Sumer bloodlines are not.
I am a patriot, not a prostitute. I don't live my life to be remembered. I live it to be forgot.
And let live that live. But be nobody's fool. Subscribe to Choson Ninja on YouTube. A Revolution of Ninja's would be way cool! But those who would be evil, those who would oppose good. Via Cults of personality, televisions, or friends in the hood. If they were to try to harm me in any way. I'd hope hope to not kill them. So I can play them in chess with their nose someday.
"Walls are stronger than the men that defend them."
Ghengis Khan
"Walls are stronger than the men that defend them."
Ghengis Khan
I will remember you until I forget.
___________
Lisa C.
“Elections are short term efforts; revolutions are long term projects.”
--Ron Paul
Join the rEVOLution here: www.campaignforliberty.com
Ron Paul "Sign Wave Across the USA" -- November 5th!
First off
Why would you ask such a question If not to cause dissent amongst us who love liberty. Your question is divisive. For me, however I would choose the constitution. I cannot expect for you to understand my religious beliefs nor do I wish to try and convince you otherwise. You are an atheist and it is your right to believe in what ever the hell you wish to believe in. I believe in liberty above all else. It is the perfect law. I believe in liberty so much, if you wanted to hang yourself I would ask you how much rope you wanted. It is your life do with it what you will, just don't screw with mine. Don't prick my heel or pick my pocket. I'm tired of seeing these religious threads on here trying to divide us, it is really quite sad. Instead of being a ignorant ass atheist maybe you should try and become an educated atheist and read the bible for what it is. And read it in the light of liberty especially the New Testament. I'm not against you, I'm with you, don't make me choose sides dam it, why can't you believe in liberty! Every Christian on this board believes as you, don't undermine our united spirit by your petty arguments on religion. WE KNOW WHAT LIBERTY MEANS, DO YOU! We must not become that which we are fighting. We were meant to be free. Take your personal agenda and move on, this is about liberty for you, for me, for all of us. Take your stupid ass game and shove it were the sun doesn't shine. This ain't no game.
If I went to a court of law
and sat on the witness stand. They would instruct me to put my hand on the Bible and raise my other hand and swear to tell the truth. The courts are an arm of the Federal government, the Judicial System. The Judicial System decides if the bills that are passed by Congress are Constitutional.
Not sure what you are asking. There are a lot of faiths out there with lots of different biblical laws. Maybe, you need to come with an example where there would be a conflict.
Why can't Christianity and the Constitution co- exist, they have from the beginning?
I have no feeling on this one way or the other. You seem to feel that Christianity is tearing the country apart or upside down. Do I read this correctly? There are people who CALL themselves Christian but I think the real question is. ARE they? Ron Paul is a Christian. He practices his faith. There are people who talk the talk but their are few will walk the talk. Peace
Prepare & Share the Message of Freedom through Positive-Peaceful-Activism.
excellent post
well thought out
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Penndel Borough needs to step up and eliminate the crime they've created by not paving and maintaining Robbins Avenue
http://will86aber.wordpress.com/2008/07/19/penndel-borough-a...
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
You can request another holy book or, if not religious, an
affirmation.
You point is well taken quiltingsando.
Ron definitely walks the walk. Someone posted a link to a radio interview with Ron and a Christian radio jock. I was so impressed with Ron. He kept his composure while the "good" Christian berated Ron and his tolerance of all Americans. The Dr. is impressive.
___________
Lisa C.
“Elections are short term efforts; revolutions are long term projects.”
--Ron Paul
Join the rEVOLution here: http://www.campaignforliberty.com/
Ron Paul "Sign Wave Across the USA" -- November 5th!
Good Question
First a personal observation: Once when visiting the Jefferson Memorial in D.C. at sunrise on a peaceful, beautiful, Saturday morning in spring, I was struck by the eternal and spiritual quality of the quotes inscribed on the interior walls of the dome. I concluded that the words had to be inspired by an eternal being... whom I believe to be God. I get the same sense when I read the Constitution.
Second, my life before including God and after are like two very different people. Before God I was always looking for the awesome thing or experience in life. After God, everyday - without fail - brings some awesome experience. An endless flow of grace, mercy, love, miracles, liberty, adventure, personal growth and prosperity.
To me the Bible and The Constitution are inseperable. If I deny either I deny both. But as important and seminal as they both are they are just 'things'. Their value, wisdom, power and 'life' come from God.
If they were both banned or taken from the earth I would be sustained by my relationship to God which cannot be destroyed because it's spiritual and transends all things - even death.
Just like the Bible, I believe, the Constitution was an inspired work. So I also believe they are written on the hearts of men who hunger for their principles.
To answer the question: My allegiance lies with God, the creator of both. And as such, the Bible and the Constitution are instructions and designs to be obeyed.
"PunJab! Bring me my checkbook!"
"GINO" = Government In Name Only
Thank you
for this response. If I didnt belive in a creator your post would make me re-think my position.
rn
Liberty = Responsibility
Liberty = Responsibility
Daddy, why can't I express
Daddy,
why can't I express myself like you! I FEEL THE EXACT SAME! GREAT POST!
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
“A prudent man foreseeth the evil, and hideth himself: but the simple pass on, and are punished.” (Prov. 22:3; 27:12 KJV)
Hey McCain-----┌П┐(◣_◢)┌П┐
A post like this only causes a whole lot of disarray.
I suggest you stop trying to stir things up for the wrong reasons. If you like mindless debates, go to MySpace.
--Cliff, Sioux City, Iowa
Facebook Profile
Facebook Political Group
Wrong on citizen,
the word citizen was not in the constitution until the fourteenth amendment.
But the word Citizen was. You need to pay attention to this detail.
Citizen written with a capital "C" "Citizen" has a completely different legal definition than "citizen" written with the lower case "c".
This is very basic but very important. Because if you describe yourself as a citizen with a lower case "c" you have just given up your rights under the first ten amendments to the constitution.
What will it take for people to realize the devil is in the details.
The fourteenth amendment though never ratified but illegally adapted by the congress created a new type of citizen. A citizen with a lower case "c" with limited priviligis and subject to the whim and wishes of congress.
When you make a statement of what you are, you are in fact declaring yourself to be a legal definition which the powers that be will take as fact and hold you to. So if you say you are a citizen you come under a different legal jurisdiction then if you declare yourself to be a Citizen.
Tell that to Judge Judy -- I dare you.
___________
Lisa C.
“Elections are short term efforts; revolutions are long term projects.”
--Ron Paul
Join the rEVOLution here: http://www.campaignforliberty.com/
Ron Paul "Sign Wave Across the USA" -- November 5th!
Our Constitution was written
Our Constitution was written by men who revered the Bible. They wrote it for people who revered and followed the Bible. They even warned us that the Constitution was written for God fearing, Bible believing, basically moral citizens, and that the whole experiment would fail otherwise. (When you look around today I guess they were right about that) So my answer would be to follow one is to follow the other. The Constitution was written based upon Biblical priciples and I see no conflict there. The question is moot.
------------------
Turn off the TV Propaganda.
Find out what's really going on!
You iether beleive in the God of the Bible or you don't
Don't go away mad or even go away at all, your dull sword makes our swords sharper.
If you want to deny God's existence that's your right, but when eternity comes you must let God have His right to deny your existence.
Good luck in the end you'll need it.
JonQ.Publik
JonQ.Publik
Resistance is not futile, what's futile is non-resistance.
Live Free or Die! Because if you are not free you’re dead already!
do you believe it is Ok to kill your child if your child is
disobedient? According to God you must.
According to God you are allowed to keep slaves as long as you get them from a different nation. Do you think that is OK too?
Or how about selling you daughter in to slavery, how about that, does that one get you excited. Because this is what God of the Bible has declared.
Do you still believe every word in the bible?
I don't think you believe what the Bible says. I don't believe you ever read it.
How about Jesus, do you believe what Jesus said? Do you believe that Jesus said: "be ye perfect even as your father in heaven is perfect". well he said it.
Do you believe now that you should be perfect? No, you say, you can't be.
Then why did he say that then? You say only Jesus can be perfect because you are a sinner. Then why did Jesus say: "all these things I have can ye can do". Jesus did not say "TRY" to be perfect he said "BE PERFECT".
But you don't believe that because you say that Jesus was God.
But Jesus said that we are Gods. Oh yes he did!
"I said ye are Gods" Jesus in John 10:34. You see Jesus was being accused of blasphemy because he said that he was a god.
For saying that he was a God they were going to stone him so he answered them saying; "does it not say in the old law, I said ye are Gods?" Here Jesus is talking about Psalms 82:6 where the universal spirit God says that we are Gods.
Now you will say that it does not mean what it says.
You will say that "be" means "try" etc...
Yes you will not believe what Jesus said because if you did you would have to take responsibility for you actions and walk as he did.
But you are too lazy to build the self discipline it takes so you will deny the truth of what Jesus said.
As a Baptist, Catholic, Atheist, Good Hearted Individual I say
Freedom is not FREE!!
Religon is an Individual thing.No one should have anything to say about someone elses beliefs. No matter what you believe it is the destiny of mankind to move FORWARD! This said I do not believe that anyone would have to choose, for the Constitution gives each of us to think and believe as we wish. There would never be a circumstance for choosing, because LIBERTY is what each is about.
Individuals must look within themselves to see what is right. A preacher, athesist, or whoremonger is wrong or right. Where we must each look is within and see what WE as individuals can do to help our fellow man. Not government! PEOPLE!!!
Churches serve a good purpose for the enlightenment of certain individuals. So does Gone with the Wind. So does a random act of kindness. Religon is a individual thing. I personally do not want your religion shoved down my throat. I would like YOU to think of the good I have in my heart for mankind and our COUNTRY.
I was raised Baptist with the Hellfire and Brimstone but came of age and realized that whatever you believe, It is all about LOVE our humankind is lost.
Just my $0.02.
Jim
And FREEDOM IS NOT FREE!!!
Freedom is not FREE!!
Christianity as it is presently practiced and portrayed
I would be content to see die. Vive la Constitution! The real thing, however, would not make me choose between the Constitution and it. The Bible itself commands me to uphold the law of the land as long as it does not force me to violate my conscience-so this question is really a counterfactual hypothetical.
BTW- I like you and your way of contrasting ideas.
Libera me, let the truth break, what my fears make--Leslie Phillips
But that man should play the tyrant over God, and find Him a better man than himself, is astonishing drama indeed!~~D. Sayers
There is no difference between an authoritarian government from the right or the left...F. A.Schaeffer
do not be conformed to the world, did not jesus say that.
HUM
I think the reason we were
I think the reason we were put on this planet is to develop into an advanced, sustainable, prosperous, and peaceful society.
The only way to get there is through self reliance and liberty.
Our constitution will allow us to do just that.
---------------------------------------
The pursuit of liberty is addictive... Let's make it contagious.
The Bible. I want to be able
The Bible. I want to be able to stone my wife and kids to death if they disobey me.
www.paulforronpaul.com
Then you had better prepare to have your ....
prayers seriously hindered - I Peter 3:7 (btw the word translated in the KJV as obey would be better translated defer to) Ephesians 5:25-6:4 You had also better be sure that you are with out sin before you attempt this- John 8:1-11
Libera me, let the truth break, what my fears make--Leslie Phillips
But that man should play the tyrant over God, and find Him a better man than himself, is astonishing drama indeed!~~D. Sayers
There is no difference between an authoritarian government from the right or the left...F. A.Schaeffer
Obviously the word "sarcasm"
Obviously the word "sarcasm" isn't in the Bible....LOL (still laughing...)
www.reverbnation.com/docholladaymusic
Truth is treason in an empire of lies.
Its a private matter, lets let this thrread drop.
We are all in this together
gigione
why?
Hey Phoobaar,
I'm making this post in an effort to get you (and all your atheist friends) to stay here at the dp.
Unfortunately, I have to start by saying I disagree with you about being persecuted and censored and what not. You all are just too sensitive. If you can't deal with the level of religiosity that appears here, quoting bible verses, etc., you need to just go away, suck your thumb in a corner for a while, and grow up.
Having said that, I would be happy to see Nystrom delete many a religious thread (or religious post) because it detracts from the mission of the site (not at all because I'm offended---in fact, maybe because *you* might be offended). It's a delicate line to determine and Nystrom has limited time for such nonsense. But it's clear that many of the religious threads (including your atheist ones) are not tending in any useful direction.
And this is the point. I'd like to see you stay, but if you can't get it through your head that the number of Christians who are actually going to persecute you in any significant way (beyond quoting bible verses and telling you they think you're wrong, when they think you are) is so small that they can almost be completely ignored in general---and certainly can be ignored here on the dp, then you're not really interested in the mission of this site, and I won't miss you if you leave, or lurk, or pout or whatever. Likewise, the Christians who are delusional to the point that they think their religion is going to effect any positive change in this country without the help of those who think it's a bunch of crap probably don't have much to contribute here. I'd like them to get off the evangelistic bandwagon and sensitivity wagons too.
Again, I'm not saying there are not Christians who want to convert or kill all atheists. There are relatively few of them, however. Likewise, I'm sure there are a few atheists who want to convert or kill all Christians. They're not about to take over either.
Secondly, if you're going to post, try to make useful posts. People like you have been repeatedly encouraged by others here with responses stroking your egos and telling you how clever you are and so forth AND that you should turn your energies toward some useful end. Why can't you produce any posts that that are useful to the mission of the site? What is the point of this silly thread for example? As several people have pointed out below, you just have your atheist agenda, and nothing else. How about what is more important to you atheism or liberty? If you were given the choice between giving up your atheism or your liberty, which would it be. To which do you have more allegiance. No doubt you think that is a stupid question. If so, maybe you can see how the other side views your question. Maybe you can grow up and work constructively toward freedom in this country.
You atheists don't need to convert all the Christians in the movement. You Christians don't need to convert all the atheists in the movement. I *shouldn't* need to convince everyone in the movement to become non-religious. If we need to do such things, then there is no hope.
It's a game..........
He wants to point fingers at people...."So he could say( look!) he or she is not a True American because they choose the Bible over the Consitution"....."Sorry but my allegiance is first with my God and then my Country"., But I will sure fight for the Consitution to protect my rights and the rights of others.
"Observe the masses,and do the opposite."
"Observe the masses,and do the opposite."
Easy choice
My allegiance is to the teachings of the Bible. The freedom which concerns the US Constitution is about freedom from an overbearing central government. The freedom which concerns the Bible is freedom from the eternal consequences of my sin--forgiveness. It is also freedom to overcome my sin, resulting in loving my neighbor, loving my enemy. If everyone loved his neighbor as Jesus taught and commanded, we probably would not need any constitution.
Ruling by prayer
Acts 5:29 says it for me...
"Then Peter and the other apostles answered and said, We ought to obey God rather than men." Acts 5:29
That NOT only applies to the government but to "Pastors" as well
In Christ,
Dave
www.lionandlambministry.com
www.lionandlambtv.com
Grace be to you, and peace, from God our Father, and from the Lord Jesus Christ.
In The LORD Jesus Christ;
Dave
"where the Spirit of the LORD is, there is liberty." 2 Cor. 3:17
http://www.lionandlambministry.com