Anna Schwartz in WSJ: Bernanke Fighting Last War
The Wall Street Journal | October 18/19 2008
On Aug. 9, 2007, central banks around the world first intervened to stanch what has become a massive credit crunch.
Since then, the Federal Reserve and the Treasury have taken a series of increasingly drastic emergency actions to get lending flowing again. The central bank has lent out hundreds of billions of dollars, accepted collateral that in the past it would never have touched, and opened direct lending to institutions that have never had that privilege. The Treasury has deployed billions more. And yet, "Nothing," Anna Schwartz says, "seems to have quieted the fears of either the investors in the securities markets or the lenders and would-be borrowers in the credit market."
The credit markets remain frozen, the stock market continues to get hammered, and deep recession now seems a certainty -- if not a reality already.
Most people now living have never seen a credit crunch like the one we are currently enduring. Ms. Schwartz, 92 years old, is one of the exceptions. She's not only old enough to remember the period from 1929 to 1933, she may know more about monetary history and banking than anyone alive. She co-authored, with Milton Friedman, "A Monetary History of the United States" (1963). It's the definitive account of how misguided monetary policy turned the stock-market crash of 1929 into the Great Depression.
Since 1941, Ms. Schwartz has reported for work at the National Bureau of Economic Research in New York, where we met Thursday morning for an interview.





















She does seem to be naive about what is really going on.
She does not seem to suspect any foul play, or be willing to say.
This is my favorite passage:
"Everything works much better when wrong decisions are punished and good decisions make you rich." The trouble is, "that's not the way the world has been going in recent years."
Ron Paul's Convention Speech
Ron Paul's Convention Speech
Joe Six-Pack agrees
Joe Six-Pack supports Ron Paul, and realizes the problem in the financial system (caused by derivatives especially). Do not under-estimate Joe Six-Pack.
www.JoeSixPack.me
www.JoeSixPack.me
My youtube channel
Take a look at my videos from the campaign trail at:
http://www.youtube.com/user/johnu78
Enjoy,
John
http://www.voteubele.com
john@voteubele.com
http://www.voteubele.com
john@voteubele.com
Ron Paul Cola is still available!
Marilyn in Lake Jackson
Off Subject, but don't forget, we can still order Ron Paul Cola!! This campaign will continue long after this year's election:
campaigncola.com
MarilynInLakeJackson
Ms. Schwartz incorrectly assumes this has been a mistake
*************
The financial crisis is not a mistake or bad judgment, it is a planned consolidation of money and power. The circle is complete - the federal reserve openly controls the treasury, the treasury controls the private banking sector and the people are out of the loop.
Oppressive taxation through inflation and without representation.
END the FED before it ENDS US
Right on the money!
Only wish our plans worked out as well.
Yes
Yes
"Tyrants fear nothing more than insubordination"
"It's just one big club... and WE ain't in it!"
When the Free Market is no longer a Free Market
It has become a rigged game. Trying to manipulate the principals of Free Market economics can only lead to disaster in the long run; elementary.
Easy to read and understand
Thanks for posting this. It was very easy to follow and shows that economics can be boiled down to common sense.
LivingTheDream
To fail or not to fail, that is the question.
Either way this is going to get fugly.
"Lead, follow, or get out of the way."
-- Thomas Paine
A Republic, If You Can Keep It
Would someone wake up to the facts ??
MAYBE just MAYBE ,the EXPERTS will get to the problem of this crisis ...There is NO credit freeze....There is only; NO demand for credit as people have a responsible attitude or we are satisfied...The DEMAND is NOT there ..Either because of lost wages or too heavily taxed ....There is NO DEMAND for DEBT or CREDIT ...THEY just stole what was left of any money flow from this end ....NOW they want us to borrow???LIQUIDITY is NOT the problem CAPITOL is the problem & that is the problem NATIONAL DEBT has created.....Maybe if the experts identified the problem correctly we could get out of this mess......BECOME responsible CONGRESS,YOU DEN OF VIPERS...NOW you expect to throw healthcare at us ,on top.....BUST for sure,SOCIALISTS traitors..
ANY ONE placeing the U.S. CONSTITUTION into such jeopardy is a TRAITOR ..SIMPLE ..first commandment rule..
weee
The Federal Reserve ain't
The Federal Reserve ain't stupid. I am. I believed what they said. Now I’m eating beans and they are eating steak I bought for them.
oxen
oh well
who's fault is that???
Read the beginning, skimmed the rest
Does Ms. Schwartz state anywhere that the Fed is the problem--not by their stupid decisions and actions, but that having a Fed at all is the problem?
My excellent debate video!
Take a look at this:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LW0PNaltukc
It's awesome!
-John
http://www.voteubele.com
john@voteubele.com
http://www.voteubele.com
john@voteubele.com
There's no doubt in my mind
There's no doubt in my mind that these central bankers are in over their heads... They've been riding the gravy train since 1913 and I'm sure it got to the point that they think they have absolute god-like power.
I have a strong feeling that they're not sleeping at night, because they know that their power is about to end. They'll try to institute a new global monetary system and mark my words, it will fail. They won't get far with it.
The era of FIAT currency is over and the era of central banks is over. People won't have any confidence in any system they introduce let alone a single one-world currency...
Our time has come. We will have our revolution... A peaceful revolution.
I hope that some Daily Paul members read this and decide to run for office... Any office. Like Ron Paul said "we have a moral obligation to do something with the knowledge we have"... We have the truth. We have the answers.
We could definitely win this thing by just getting politically involved and spreading the message to as many people as we can.
---------------------------------------
Do you know someone who cares a lot about Israel? Send them this link that explains why Ron Paul's message is better for Israel, America, and the world. www.AmericansForIsrael.com
These New World Order
These New World Order bankers must be totally nuts. What good is credit if all the jobs are outsourced and people can't find a job to pay back the loan?
-------------------------------------------------------------------
Get a cool Campaign For Liberty bumper sticker or decal for your windshield.
Support Ron Paul's Campaign For Liberty project. Go to --- www.CampaignForLibertyStuff.com
------------------
Turn off the TV Propaganda.
Find out what's really going on!
Maybe so they can get most
Maybe so they can get most of us on the hook without a viable way of paying it off?
...
Marilyn in Lake Jackson This
Marilyn in Lake Jackson
This 92-year-old lady is sharp as a tack! I wonder what she thinks of Dr. Paul? Very interesting article.
MarilynInLakeJackson
So who's listening to her ? Noone evidently !
~Mikael / Peace, love, Light and unity ~
~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Stop the NWO....It's just illumi..Naughty !
What a wonderful article!
How eloquent and concise a communicator Ms. Schwartz is! She lays it out so simply and forthrightly... it's a shame nobody asked for her expertise somewhere along the way, considering how senior and knowledgeable she is. Her perspective would have been invaluable, I think.
It's always amazing to me that generals have historically often tended to fight the "last" war. I never thought economists did, too, but it makes sense. Bureaucracy never promotes thinking outside the box, and when under pressure, we revert to what we know. Bernanke knows (or thinks he knows) the depression of 1929, so that's the fight he's fighting.
Too damn bad his fight will have the exact same outcome and the People get to pay the price...again.
"Dependence begets subservience and venality, suffocates the germ of virtue, and prepares fit tools for the designs of ambition." -- Thomas Jefferson
Excellent
Thank you too Michael
And this too
It takes real guts to let a large, powerful institution go down. But the alternative -- the current credit freeze -- is worse, Ms. Schwartz argues.
Mike
"Fire Team for Freedom" and "Revolutionary Business"
visit www.mikeandjake.com
Mike
"Fire Team for Freedom"
visit www.mikeandjake.com
This is one of the parts that puts it very simply
Ms. Schwartz won't say so, but this is the dirty little secret that led Secretary Paulson to shift from buying bank assets to recapitalizing them directly, as the Treasury did this week. But in doing so, he's shifted from trying to save the banking system to trying to save banks. These are not, Ms. Schwartz argues, the same thing. In fact, by keeping otherwise insolvent banks afloat, the Federal Reserve and the Treasury have actually prolonged the crisis. "They should not be recapitalizing firms that should be shut down."
Rather, "firms that made wrong decisions should fail," she says bluntly. "You shouldn't rescue them. And once that's established as a principle, I think the market recognizes that it makes sense. Everything works much better when wrong decisions are punished and good decisions make you rich." The trouble is, "that's not the way the world has been going in recent years."
Instead, we've been hearing for most of the past year about "systemic risk" -- the notion that allowing one firm to fail will cause a cascade that will take down otherwise healthy companies in its wake.
Mike
"Fire Team for Freedom" and "Revolutionary Business"
visit www.mikeandjake.com
Mike
"Fire Team for Freedom"
visit www.mikeandjake.com
It's hard to believe
that Bernanke and those guys are really as stupid as it appears. Until I'm proven wrong, I'll go on believing there is something much more sinister at work.
"Tyrants fear nothing more than insubordination"
"It's just one big club... and WE ain't in it!"
They are just as stupid as
They are just as stupid as the FED and the government was during the 20s and 30s, all you have to do is read what most of the "experts" were saying then to see that they have placed their entire faith in a system that is inherently flawed.
http://www.1776solution.blogspot.com
http://militantjeffersonian.com
"Men do not willingly read unpalatable truths of themselves. The People like those best who fool them most, by pandering to their vices and flattering their foibles" Raphael Semmes
Well, GEE..it worked in
Well, GEE..it worked in Sweden.....
Ah yes, the Swedish
Ah yes, the Swedish Model.....have you ever read what really happened in Sweden?
http://www.1776solution.blogspot.com
http://militantjeffersonian.com
"Men do not willingly read unpalatable truths of themselves. The People like those best who fool them most, by pandering to their vices and flattering their foibles" Raphael Semmes
Swedish Model
September Time Article
www.time.com/time/business/article/0,8599,1843659,00.html
..."One of the attractions of this Swedish model is that it reduces so-called "moral hazard" — effectively rewarding poor or reckless risk assessment — by forcing financial institutions that took the highest risks to pay towards their own rescue. And it allows the state to recoup the money that it expends to buy up the bad debt at the core of the problem.
Paulson's current plan exacts no such a price from the financial institutions it proposes to bail out"
Very Smart Lady
and a good read. I hope it gets lots of attention and can only wonder what she thinks of Dr Paul.