30 Seconds and a baseball bat to fix America
Submitted by Jdayh on Sat, 01/10/2009 - 00:50
Imagine this hypothetical scenario:
******CONTENT DELETED*******
Guideline violations:
1. Inciting or encouraging violent or illegal acts;
2. Posting material that would reflect poorly on Dr. Paul or his organizations.
#2 Reference: "Even though this site is not in any official way affiliated with Dr. Paul or any of his multiple organizations, by participating in this site you are still representing Dr. Paul in the eyes of the public. Please do not write anything that Dr. Paul himself would not say or would not approve of, or that would reflect poorly on Dr. Paul or his organizations. Dr. Paul is a compassionate, humble, honest, fair and kindhearted human. Follow Dr. Paul’s lead." -Michael Nystrom.
»





















Great thread
Despite the original content being deleted, which I did not read but have a pretty good understanding of what it contained, there is some good discussion here. There are many valid points made, on all sides of the issue.
I believe that the intention of the "unseen hand" is to create a situation where violent conflict will be the dominant culture of the "unwashed masses". It is my hope that their intention will not be manifested, however I have no expectations and am hopefully prepared for the worst.
As time marches on, the question will arise with each day: "Is this life better than being dead?" That question has been made a part of the discussion below in appropriate context. Personally, I try to focus every day on the parts of my life that inspire gratitude, and I like to use the full moon as a reminder to be grateful (just in case I get to feeling sorry for myself and forget).
I trust that, when the time and conditions are right, and the critical mass of consciousness has been reached, we will know on a gut level what actions to take and where to appropriately direct our energies.
My sincere gratitude to all who participated in this thread. And to rhino: dude, you need to quit your incessant whining. It would be the end of the DP for me if you are ever granted any status other than particpating forum member, just like the rest of us. Get over yourself already.
great comment
classic...one of the best ever.
http://www.votenader.org/blog/2008/09/10/statement-to-ron-pa...
http://www.flickr.com/photos/57925480@N00/2660779139/sizes/l/
Website:
http://www.libertypoet.com/
Twitter:
http://twitter.com/LibertyPoet
"How can we justify to the unemployed and underemployed in the United States the incredible cost of maintaining a global empire?" - Dr. Ron Paul
What a man!!! Thanks Gil you
What a man!!! Thanks Gil you little heart warmer... I love your post
Way to go Michael
Your guidelines are excellent. Thank you for catching this post.
As Ron Paul supporters we have a responsibility to show the world that the Ron Paul revolution is a revolution of IDEAS.
Ideas
Ideas didn't win us the Revolutionary war nor did they serve us in the Civil War. Ideas are merely the premise to action. Great change, whose time has come, though non-violent means are preferable, is always preceeded by violent action. Let History bear witness.
"There can be only one permanent revolution - a moral one: The regeneration of the inner man."
—Tolstoy
"The body is but a vessel for the soul,
A puppet which bends to the soul's tyranny.
And lo, the body is not eternal,
For it must feed on the flesh of others,
Lest it return to the dust whence it came.
Therefore the soul deceives and despises."
Ideas are NOTHING without action...
...be it violent or non violent.
__________________________________________
"Life's tough......It's even tougher if you're stupid."
-John Wayne
http://www.ronpaulbrochure.com/
http://www.dailypaul.com/donate
sorry, this is incorrect
Violence strengthens the opposing side, either with sentiment, or with counter violence. There was a liberal revolution of ignorance last year, and no shots were fired.
The keyboard is becoming mightier than the sword.
"I don't endorse anything they say"
~Ron Paul On the 911 Truth movement.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hGyhlNY0y1k
there are billions of people
there are billions of people murdered throughout history who disagree with you! ask the 20 million Ukrainians that Stalin starved to death! I gaurantee you if they could have taken up arms against that prick they would have!
"When governments fear the people there is liberty. When the people fear the government there is tyranny."
-Thomas Jefferson
I am more concerned about the return of my money than the return on my money. --Mark Twain
“A prudent man foreseeth the evil, and hideth himself: but the simple pass on, and are punished.” (Prov. 22:3; 27:12 KJV)
Hey McCain-----┌П┐(◣_◢)┌П┐
Not sure I follow you.
It is incorrect that ideas are nothing without action?
The keyboard may be mightier in educating, But I can't see the change it is bringing,yet anyways.
__________________________________________
"Life's tough......It's even tougher if you're stupid."
-John Wayne
http://www.ronpaulbrochure.com/
http://www.dailypaul.com/donate
The sad/funny part is: All you violent "revolutionaries"
wouldn't know which way to point your guns anyway. Seriously, who will you fight with? To what end? Why did no one move after WACO? Ruby Ridge? 9-11? Iraq? Bailouts? World Economic Summits?
I used to believe a violent revolution was what's needed, until I realized that it is exactly what "they" want and that it would boil down to the poor killing the poor
Explore Orthodox Christianity
I'm glad you came around.
I remember when you used to post the inciting-violence stuff. Your recent posts have really changed in tone.
I think there IS a time for violence, and that time is "when the enemy attacks you first". I'm not talking B.S. about Waco or Ruby Ridge or 911--I'm talking about when they come to YOU to take away your guns, imprison you, or shoot you. That is when you fight. We're nowhere near that position, and if we act intelligently, we may never be in that position.
The Armchair Commandoes seem to forget that the "American (Secessionist) Revolution" did not begin until the British attempted to disarm them at Concord and the Boston Massacre has taken place. I am guessing the Armchair Commandoes shoot from the hip when they reference the Founders because they are not very knowledgeable about the historical facts of the war for independence.
The Founders tried for years to negotiate an alternative to fighting. They were not wild-eyed idiots searching for a cause to incite violence. They fought against the British as a last resort.
SUPPORT OUR FOUNDERS' AMERICA
Support the Constitution of the United States
SUPPORT OUR FOUNDERS' AMERICA
Support the Constitution of the United States
That's why you gotta
Point out the men behind the curtain. Bring them into the light..
Find out if you have a local militia - http://www.uaff.us/
Real Patriots for 9/11 truth -- http://patriotsquestion911.com/
Well said....
The people need a target to focus on, so that they don't focus on each other.
__________________________________________
"Life's tough......It's even tougher if you're stupid."
-John Wayne
http://www.ronpaulbrochure.com/
http://www.dailypaul.com/donate
I wouldn't say "all"
Some of us know where to cut the cancer out.
You may be right in the sense of them getting the population to fight with each other, but some people are paying attention to who is doing the instigating.
__________________________________________
"Life's tough......It's even tougher if you're stupid."
-John Wayne
http://www.ronpaulbrochure.com/
http://www.dailypaul.com/donate
Content deleted before I read it, but I can imagine.
I am not personally a violent revolutionary. I am too old, though I do know how to quite accurately point a gun, so I am just an observer.
My view is that we are, in all probability, headed to a violent end of the US. I think that economics will be the motivating factor, and I am not talking just about the current debt panic, but rather the end of the industrial age for want of energy to fuel it. It was really increasing cost of energy that shook the house of cards monetary system that gave rise to the current panic, and energy constraints will keep the economic pie shrinking as far into the future as can be seen.
Of course nobody grabbed their gun as a result of the incidents you list, because the pain of doing so would have been greater than the pain of going along to get along. The long term reality in the US has been an expanding economic pie, and even though the economy has been progressively rigged by government in favor of the few at the expense of the many, the many still have generally seen an improvement in their living conditions. Pass out a pittance to the peons and rebellion is quelled.
The revolution point is when the pain of revolution is less than the pain from going along to get along. Even today, if you believe government statistics, the unemployment rate is somewhere around 7% or 8% (of course the real rate might be double that). Imagine when the rate is closer to 50% and people suffer the extreme effects of poverty, like hunger, cold, homelessness, and disease without medical care.
If you look at a long term chart of human population, the growth rate was fairly flat until we started to exploit non-renewable energy sources about 300 or 400 years ago, and then the growth rate exploded. The curves for population growth and energy use correlate. Before we began to exploit non-renewable energy sources, human population was constrained by available renewable energy sources. We were dependent on those limited resources, but they renewed, so population more or less kept in balance with the ability of earth to sustain us. The sustainable population was roughly 1/2 billion. Our numbers are now over 6.5 billion, and the excess over the sustainable 1/2 billion is hopelessly dependent on non-renewable energy to remain in existence.
So here we are, at the end of the industrial age, having squandered our inheritance of fossil fuels, with a bankrupt government ruthlessly managing an empire and an economy to benefit themselves and the privileged few. Political repression is increasing and economic pain is here with much more on the horizon. Oil production could easily be 1/2 of what it is today in 20 years or less, so imagine what the economy will become. All the government seems to care about is staying in power and looting what wealth the general population still possesses.
Politics may not motivate people to violence, but desperation will. We are entering a new era.
"The deepest sin against the human mind is to believe things without evidence." Thomas H. Huxley
My point Henry is not accurate aim. It's WHO do you aim at?
I agree that desperation may lead people to violence, but it will more than likely be misdirected. The trouble as I see it is there is no clearly defined enemy against which violence could be directed so people just get angy but have no real idea who to direct it toward.
Explore Orthodox Christianity
Sorry Mike...
I have to disagree with you here. The target(s) are not in question. I am not angry, but I know the target(s).
In my view, that is not the problem. The problem is that too few people are interested in assailing those targets. Any action would be short lived and futile. There is an almost insignificant number of people who understand and are interested in freedom and the constitution. The latter has been ignored so long that its meaning has passed out of memory.
I apologize, but since I'm reading Royce at the moment you get quotes from him:
If you will not fight for right when you can easily win without bloodshed; if you will not fight when your victory will be sure and not too costly; you may come to the moment when you will have to fight for survival. There may be even a worse case. You may have to fight when there is no hope of victory, because it is better to perish than to live as slaves.
----Winston Churchill
Royce feels that "We're probably already at the "worse case. ...We've only ourselves to blame.
"We should have strung up Congress for handing monetary control to a private consortium of bankers and then dragging us into WWI in 1917. We should have resisted in the 1930s during FDR's atrocious "social" programs and the confiscation of our gold. We should have shouted down the 1945 U.N. We should have pushed through the righteous tax revolt of the late 1970s instead of accepting the sop presidency of Ronald Reagan. We should have hounded out the Clintonistas after the murder of the Branch Davidians. Etc. Etc. Etc.
"The only times when we stood up to the Government were in 1794 (Whiskey Rebellion) and 1860 (the secession of the South over economic autonomy---not slavery). Other than that, we have chickened out on a dozen crucial opportunities to rein in Washington. Evil has triumphed because good men have done nothing. We've become a paper tiger and Congress is not longer afraid of us. The servant now scoffs at his master, and the servant's bulldog routinely sinks its teeth in our legs.
"If there's one constant to bullies it's that they're bluff. Knock their teeth in suddenly and they crumple every time. It's only difficult and scary the first time. All they need is some long-overdue fear and they'll run.
...
"Jefferson spoke of occasional mild rebessions for America's health. Rebellions are sort of like vomiting. The prospect is very unpleasant, but you feel so much better afterwards. We've been so queasy with political poisoning for so long, but we won't hug a toilet and stick a finger down our national throat. We're so afraid of vomiting that we'd rather stay queasy. Well, if we wait to vomit on the poison's timetable, we will be too weak and ill to recover by then.
-----------------------------
"Democrats are not the problem. Republicans and Libertarians are the problem. Republicans without the intellectual stamina to become Libertarians, and Libertarians without the physical courage to become Riflemen.
----------------------------
And I don't advocate violence at this time, but it's not because we do not know the targets, it is not because violence has no part is securing liberty, it is because we have no hope for success. I do not see that this means we will never have hope for success. There are at least some relatively young people like me who didn't know much about what was going on and had never thought seriously about the constitution until recently.
I hope you don't get pissed at me Mike or K"oln (and maybe delete my post), but I gotta get to the range.
http://www.fredsm14stocks.com/articles.asp
see especially http://www.fredsm14stocks.com/article.asp?ITEM=39
http://www.fredsm14stocks.com/columns.asp
For the sake of discussion, let's say congress is violently
what, overthrown? Held as prisoners? killed?
Then what?
I guess what I'm asking is what is the second level? Besides, they're not even the real enemy. That's my original point.
Explore Orthodox Christianity
The second one...
That's an excellent question. The second one.
The answer, I'm afraid, is the same: We have a lack of personell.
What we would have left is basically one national level politician, who is apparently perfect in every way except for his continued assertion that "freedom works" and his trust in the governmental model of the founders and his blindness to the hard raw fact that their model failed. We had freedom (for a very short time), and it was lost. Freedom didn't work.
So, just like there can be no useful rebellion at the present time, there can also be no successful and desirable second level. But it is not for any obvious fundamental reason that we can never have both. I see no reason that we cannot have both in the future.
As to the real enemy, I think the Congress is close enough. Were they removed, then, if there are some other real enemies, they would either have to make themselves known or be forced to recede into a further obscured position, and hopefully into obscurity altogether. But I don't see any mistake in asserting that the members of Congress, the Senate, the Presidential cabinet are at least among the main enemies of freedom in this country.
The real barriers are 1. The personell to do the job (which honestly is not really a problem).
2. A widespread will to see the job done, so that at least the standing army stands aside. (That is the first real problem.)
3. Something worthwhile to replace the present tyrrany. (Another real problem, which you have brought up.)
We do need in place an awakened assembly of patriots to assemble a new federal government...and as far as I can see, we just don't have it.
I have to agree with you
I have to agree with you Mike. People call for violent action, but against whom, exactly. If we had SS Troops marching the streets, accosting people and enforcing curfews, there would be an obvious target. Sadly, that day may come and if it does, I am absolutely supportive of a violent approach. Here and now, who would you target? A local deputy? He is just a guy, and probably a decent one, raising a family, investigating local crime and ticketing speeders.
While I do not deny that a handful of snipers with 535 bullets could change the world, but what would they change it to? Clearly the people of our country are not yet ready for a revolution, not one at the ballot box or in the streets. Until they are truly ready for a change back to freedom, jumping the gun could lead to a worse dictatorship than we have now. Action for now includes educating others, supporting those trying to protect our borders, supporting the Continental Congress '09, working to take our local political parties, both Democrat and Republican, and working hard to get the publicity we need about what is happening. With a lot of work and a little luck, maybe we can pull off a complete overthrow of our current politicians the old fashioned way: By getting them voted out! We just have to hope they don't back us into a corner.
Pat
BOHICA!!
Pat
BOHICA!!
They won't go. You can't
They won't go. You can't vote them out. The game is rigged. They INVENTED the game. These people won't back down. They like the lifestyle. They're hoping for a seat at the table of the NWO. They will keep on passing laws that keep us in chains, and they will speed up the process when they KNOW we are about to do something. So, it looks like it will be violent whether you want it or not.
I am not opposed to violence
I am not opposed to violence as a last resort. There are still a couple of peaceful avenues to try, but if they try to take our guns or otherwise back us into a corner, the fight will be on. From my forum readings the last couple of days, it looks like getting a freedom-minded county sheriff with a backbone could make a huge difference when the feds decide to collect our guns. To me, that and RealID are the lines in the sand. When they force RealID, it's time to stop getting driver's licenses.
Pat
BOHICA!!
Pat
BOHICA!!
Look at 1776 and 1861.
People took sides in the American Revolution and in the Civil War. There was organized violence in the form of traditional battles, and there was personal, random violence, neighbor against neighbor based on which side you were on.
The predominant feature of the next great outburst of civil violence will be survival rather than political disagreement. Natures invisible hand will command us to reduce our numbers, so the whole point of the violent squabble over the scarce necessities of life will be to eliminate competitors (kill one another).
When I moved to a rural area more than 30 years ago, one of the things I was surprised to find that types of snakes had territories, and that in you found areas where there were mostly only one kind of snake. The locals knew which hill or hollow had an abundance of copperheads. Seems that some places are more hospitable to certain snakes, but also that one type of snake will drive out other types, sometimes by eating them, but they don't eat their own kind. I understand that most species have a mechanism to keep members from killing one another except under unusual circumstances.
So I think that in the coming struggle to literally survive, that those humans we see as most different from ourselves will be the easiest to squabble with. We are much more likely to share what we have with our family members than to kill one another, but it will be easier to kill a stranger over who gets the last apple. I think that on a national level that ethnicity will play a major role in who fights whom. Perhaps it will develop something like described in "Civil War Two" where the author sees the US breaking up into three countries, Hispanic southwest, Black south and White north. And within those nations ethnic cleansing will occur, as well as struggles between urban liberal areas, and rural conservative areas. A reaction against those formerly in power, similar to the execution of aristocrats during the French Revolution is a possible feature of what is coming, as revenge seems to be something people crave in such times.
I think the end result will be a significant reduction in population from starvation, disease, and violence and more local political control. The old US will no longer exist.
I don't think we will get past 2020 without civil disorder erupting. Its going to be a play it by ear situation as nobody know all the little twists and turns history will take. Ten years before the American Revolution or ten years before the Civil War, most did not see them coming. I think I smell the smoke from the as yet unseen next conflagration.
"The deepest sin against the human mind is to believe things without evidence." Thomas H. Huxley
intense civil disorder is
intense civil disorder is going to erupt in the usa before the end of 2010.
martial law will be the norm. the cities will be locked down.
I agree with you 100%, violence will occur
But will it be guided toward the real enemy? I doubt it. You cited two perfect examples of the poor killing the poor while the system marched on. The bottom line is, until the people who exactly they are mad at, they will direct violence towards the wrong people and the same forces that have quietly driven the wars of the past will drive another.
Explore Orthodox Christianity
Good point, Mike
Fellowship of the White Rose
Ron Paul was right
LOL
I just noticed the Google generated ads next to this thread for baseball bats, and a swing practice machine. Gotta love Google.
__________________________________________
"Life's tough......It's even tougher if you're stupid."
-John Wayne
http://www.ronpaulbrochure.com/
http://www.dailypaul.com/donate
Generally I love a good controversy, but...
By our newly reposted guidelines:
"1) Even though this site is not in any official way affiliated with Dr. Paul or any of his multiple organizations, by participating in this site you are still representing Dr. Paul in the eyes of the public. Please do not write anything that Dr. Paul himself would not say or would not approve of, or that would reflect poorly on Dr. Paul or his organizations."
Don't ever talk about building our numbers when you post crap like this thread. If you have a conscience at all, you'll remove it.
--------
You can't spell Revolution without evolution!
'Cause there's a monster on the loose
Moderated by yours truly.
Jdayh, if you wish to complain to Michael, feel free.
SUPPORT OUR FOUNDERS' AMERICA
Support the Constitution of the United States
SUPPORT OUR FOUNDERS' AMERICA
Support the Constitution of the United States
if you are a moderator here...
we're all screwed!
time for me to go underground...
O Captain, My Captain, rise up and hear the bells!
its 'cos I owe ya, my young friend...
Rockin' the FREE world in Tennessee since 1957!