Comment: Or

(See in situ)

In reply to comment: Maybe Judge Roberts (see in situ)


The Supreme Court (the Judicial branch) cannot change the law (of the legislative branch) in order to rule it constitutional, that's unconstitutional.

The correct procedure is to rule the law unconstitutional, return it to the congress, have congress change "a penalty to a tax" and then have the Supreme Court rule on its constitutionality.