Comment: I understand

(See in situ)

In reply to comment: you fail to recognize (see in situ)

I understand

the value in them grabbing

Again, I'm NOT against them claiming their is value to them grabbing that domain name, and also wanting to cash in on it.

The problem I have is them reneging. If they had said up front, hey we are web savvy supporters that had the foresight to know to grab the name and although we are supporters we want to make something off it too. Our request is X amount.

Then I would respect that. What I have a problem with is them going back on their word saying they would hand the name over once contacted.