Comment: Bob, you failed to understand Zionism

(See in situ)

Bob, you failed to understand Zionism

1) If you are a Libertarian, you should allow people to have freedom to be left alone or for a collective separate themselves from others if they like.

2) The issue at hand is only about the land - group demands. Since "Palestine" was never an independent state in whole human history and Israel got West Bank land as the result of victory in the war with Jordan, the dispute is complicated. Emotions do not solve the issue. But a Libertarian cannot have an ideological opposition to Zionism. Open borders is not the main idea of individual liberty if people are allowed to form a collective and separate themselves from others.