I'm not saying a sentient creator is impossible, but if you really think he didn't use evolution, you have many years ahead of you of trying to understand a system that has no logical cohesion at all.
It'd be best to extricate your morality from your beliefs on how the world came to be. Fundamentalist christianity will be a long and confusing road. you don't have to take every word in your bible literally to be spiritual. in fact it may hamper your spirituality and leave you less open to the magic of the living world.