Comment: Proof is

(See in situ)

Proof is

evidence sufficient to establish a thing as true, or to produce belief in its truth.

There can be fake proof or real proof and then there is speculation.

What we have is ppl showing evidence that they believe to be proof of what they believe happened based on their speculation. They can be either right or wrong!

What I think the OP wants is the proof to actually be proving their argument/speculation.

I've seen a bunch of post's with evidence that don't prove their arguments, they are just assumptions.