Comment: Car Chase

(See in situ)

In reply to comment: Disagree. I'm with Breyer, (see in situ)

Car Chase

As the concurring opinion said, I don't think it matters if they read your rights or not; it can be used against you. It's similar to a suspect being chased in a car (think OJ case). Are we going to say the car chase is not admissible because it may be perceived as self-incrimination?

At the end of the day having someone describe how you were silent is not the same as being compelled to testify against yourself.

I still maintain it is extremely shady to try and paint a picture with no real evidence but it is constitutional.