Comment: not quite

(See in situ)


not quite

For such a requirement to work, it would need to be coupled with another clause expressly stating that SCOTUS had no power of Judicial Review.
http://constitutionality.us/SupremeCourt.html

Because of claims made by its Preamble, Constitutionality should be determined by The People.

Which leads me to the glaringly Greatest Error concering the Constitution, something Patrick Henry so astutely recognized at the Virginia Convention. The Preamble, "We, the People..." eradicated the Confederacy, a compact between sovereign States, and created a national government whose people would be bound to despots and oligarchs. After that, the so-called 'geniuses' writing the Constitution included sections ensuring this newly created central govt 'supremecy' over not just States, but the people.

On June 5, 1788 Henry spoke again in the Virginia Convention on this subject: "I rose yesterday to ask a question, which arose in my mind. When I asked that question, I thought the meaning of my interrogation was obvious: the fate of this question and of America may depend on this. Have they said, We, the states? Have they made a proposal of a compact between states? If they had, this would be a confederation: it is otherwise most clearly a consolidated government.

The question turns, sir, on the expression, We, the People, instead of, the States of America. I need not take much pains to show that the principles of this system are extremely pernicious, impolitic and dangerous. Is this a monarchy, like England - a compact between prince and people: with checks on the former to secure the liberty of the latter? Is this a confederacy, like Holland - an association of a number of independent States, each of which retains its individual sovereignty?

Had these principles been adhered to, we should not have been brought to this alarming transition, from a confederacy to a consolidated government. We have no detail of those great considerations which, in my opinion, ought to have abounded before we should recur to a government of this kind. Here is a revolution as radical as that which separated us from Great Britain..."

The entire article is worth reading as more of Henry's thoughts are expressed.
http://rense.com/general79/patri.htm

If Tyranny and Oppression come to this land, it will be in the guise of fighting a foreign enemy.
James Madison