Comment: His place of birth ...

(See in situ)

In reply to comment: So what (see in situ)

His place of birth ...

... due to the 14th Amendment.

If he had been born in 1850 to Cuban parents, he would not have been a US citizen. After the 14th Amendment, anyone born on US soil is a US citizen.

However, he is still not a natural-born citizen due to the status of his parents.