I don't like the sound of motor vehicles while I'm stuck in line at the DMV. Arrest all the drivers.
Golden Rule is not law, it's a moral suggestion. What IS Law, is the 1st Amendment. As long as you're not committing fraud or violence or impeding on someone else's rights, you are not committing a crime.
And "annoying non-believers" isn't fraud or violence. NO one has the right to "not be offended" or annoyed.