Comment: So, are you saying...

(See in situ)

So, are you saying...

to vote "up" for "yes"...he IS crazy?
and vote "down" for "no", he isn't??

That's what your directions seem to indicate.

Since it is not clear, I will state that "no", I do not think he is crazy. But, the use of "crazy" is a strange word to pick. Why not just ask if people agree that his argument has merit, or not?