Comment: But have you...

(See in situ)


But have you...

...you had experience with person or mind or love in your life? Forget deities or ghosts or leprechauns.

Of course, you have. The question at the heart of things is whether these things are transcendent or derivative. How you answer that question is at the heart of the whole idea of 'only nature' vs 'something more'.

If you're saying that atheism proposes no answer to this central question, then it's not a compelling worldview to hold from my perspective.