Nevada man paying in gold: IRS Helpless
Ran across this article, it may have been posted before, But its a decent read. but what got me was the very last paragraph.
I would like to open it up for a bit of discussion for everyone, what do you all think :)
Edit:
Link to a more in depth story....Very nice read :)
http://www.liberty-watch....
Cyric
output




















bump
Bump for the sunday crowd this is fun to read stuff :p
I love it~!
I love it! Wow this is huge, we already have competing currencies. We need to spread the word on this
-----
Is life so dear, or peace so sweet, as to be purchased at the price of chains and slavery? Forbid it, Almighty God! I know not what course others may take; but as for me, give me liberty, or give me death. Patrick Henry
One possible hazard..
If you pay your employees in gold coin as the article describes, they might be able to hose you on the minimum wage.
If you give an employee a $50 gold piece (worth several hundred bucks), is the face value of the coin, or the number of fiat dollars it's worth the basis for determining if you're in compliance with the minimum wage?
-jcr
You're right, but there are work-arounds
The employee could be given a salary instead of an hourly wage. Or wages could be made in a combination of FRNs and gold coin, the total adding up to the legal minimum wage. Or the worker might be able to "quit" and then return to work as an independent contractor,
The IRS
just came out with a MEMO not a law that if you pay in gold or silver that it should reflect market value on your taxes, Screw them
Link?
What memo? What's your source? Is it more recent than March 8, 2008? Did you check out the link in my comment, immediately below this one?
Another article, and a few more ideas
A much more recent decision, and even better news: http://www.restoretherepu...
This article contains a letter opinion from the IRS that using gold and silver coins at face value is legal! You ARE legally required to report a capital gain when you exchange your gold/silver coins for FRNs, but note that you don't have to pay Social Security or Medicare or any other payroll tax on capital gains, so even if your first move after receiving your gold wages was to sell the coins for FRNs, you would save an enormous amount of taxes. But it gets even better if you DON'T exchange your coins for FRNs, but instead spend them buying goods and services from other people who, like you, would like to minimize their taxable income. Buy a $5000 used car for $250 face-value gold coins that you received from your employer, and you've shielded yourself from ever having to pay tax on what would have been a $4750 capital gain -- and you've given the used car dealer a huge tax loss (supposing that he bought the used car himself for $3000 (FRN), if he sells it for $250 (Eagle coins), he can claim a LOSS of $2750, until such time as he trades his coins for FRNs. Which he will be reluctant to do, so HE has an incentive to keep the ball rolling, perhaps starting to pay his own employees in gold ... see how this could grow?
More interesting thoughts:
Want to donate more than $2300 to Ron Paul? Send him gold coins. I am profoundly sorry that I didn't hear about this until after I'd already maxed out my contributions.
Want to escape the $10,000 per year limitation on tax-free gifts to your children? Give them gold coins.
It's actually a WIN-WIN situation
Think about it!
Let's say your salary is 48,000/year or 4,000/month.
Let's say 20% goes to the federal income tax. That's equal to 800/month.
Split the difference with your employer to provide an incentive:
Now tell you're employer, instead of paying me 4,000/month, please pay me only 3,600/month (so the employer is saving 400/month on you!!), but the catch is I would like to be paid in $50 gold coins! So, the employer gives you 3 gold coins (each at $1000) plus an extra one every other month (roughly speaking).
So, now according to the IRS, you're really making $180/month. Based on this meagre salary, you don't have to file any paperwork with the IRS since you're below their minimum requirements.
Therefore, you don't have to fork out 20% of your salary to them! Which means you're ahead $400/month and your employer is ahead $400/month!
How come more people are not doing this????
Instead of paying the extra
Instead of paying the extra one every other month, the employer could pay in lesser denominations such as the $25 (1/2 oz), $10 (1/4 oz), $5 (1/10 oz) Gold Eagles (or possibly the 1 oz $1 Silver Eagles).
Neat!
.
Very clever! Thank you for
Very clever! Thank you for describing it so clearly - definitely something to think about!!
One thing that we need to
One thing that we need to look at in capitalism is "wage oppression" anyone heard of that?
i think it is true..to a degree...but if we had a free market it would adjust better for everyone.
As being self employed
I have been thinking about asking to be paid in gold and silver.
How about diamonds?
They are easier to carry.
How about like the Rainbow
How about like the Rainbow Gathering, sticky greenbud?
Certainly much easier to divide into smaller amounts, and you will be able to find MANY MORE people who understand the weight/FRN conversion, rather than folks who play with those little rocks.
THE MORE I LEARN ABOUT GOVERNMENT
THE MORE I LOVE MY GUNS
FourWindsTradingPost
divisibilty
Irrespective of blood stains, diamonds lack the major characteristics of money that lead one inevitably to gold and silver. They are not divisible, and they are not fungible. Proper and useful money needs to be both. If you split a single ten thousand dollar stone you do not get two five thousand dollar stones. Part of a gem's value is based on its weight (plus color, clarity, flawlessness et cetera.)
If you melt down an ounce of gold and silver you still have an ounce of metal. One ounce of silver is pretty much interchangeable with any other ounce (numismatic concerns aside.)
The best money is recognizable with a minimum of training, easily divisible, and completely interchangeable.
Viva Agora!
Professor Bernardo de la Paz
www.citizenduquesne.org
Not to mention rarity.
The other reason that diamonds are a poor choice for a currency, is that they're really only semi-precious stones. DeBeers has been able to throttle the supply for a very long time, but there are two companies synthesizing diamonds in vapor-deposition chambers right now.
-jcr
Perfect post
thanks for that one... it is a wonderful summation.
diamonds are bloody.. Watch
diamonds are bloody..
Watch the movie "blood diamond"
Unless you have a clean source I would not want those on my hands..
By the way..., Ron Paul was
By the way...,
Ron Paul was actually instrumental in making the government start to produce Gold Eagles in the 80s! More kudos to him!
Freedom Rules!
Add that to the list of all
Add that to the list of all great things Ron Paul :-)
Kudos
Kudos go to RP :)
A Question
Where or how do you get the $50 gold coins for only $50?
Everyone, including the US mint sells them for the price of gold..so how do you buy the coins for only $50?
You don't. You must exchange
You don't. You must exchange your phony debtor notes for the gold coins at the market rate, which currently runs about $1000. HOWEVER...since the coins are actually genuine money, you can use them to pay employees and for any other use for money at its face value.
www.paulforronpaul.com
Other taxes
I wonder what other taxes they could apply, such as when you sold it for paper currency.? or some other way...
You would be required to pay capital gains tax.
But that's all. No Social Security or other payroll taxes apply when you sell a coin for FRNs. See my post above. But you can avoid even the capital gains tax by persuading someone else to accept payment from you in gold.
Minimum Wage
I love the idea, but I wonder if he's meeting the minimum wage requirements? Perhaps paying in silver would work better.
You can avoid minimum wage laws
By using independant contractors. You can do this so it's 100% legal.
Maybe not
The IRS has a long history of harassing employers who turn their employees into "independent contractors." Better to turn them into salaried workers. You'll have to figure a way to keep them off a time clock, or you WOULD fall afoul of the minimum wage laws. Highly-compensated hourly employees could receive a combination of gold and FRNs. If minimum wage is $7 per hour, you need to keep total hourly compensation above that level. So you pay the first $7 of hourly wages in FRNs. But anything above $7, pay in gold or silver. For example, an employee that you want to pay $20 per hour would receive a paycheck for about $7.60 --$7 per hour in FRNs and .60 per hour in silver or gold.
Heeyyy,
If that "super model" can demand to be paid in Euro's, why couldn't we all go to our "employers" and demand to be paid in GOLD? I know, stupid huh? Some employers might agree.....What do you guys think?
HAHA!
I love it! These employees only have to pay income tax on the face value of the $50 coin which (@$1000 per once) is actually worth $50,000. If every employer started doing this, the dollar would be worthless. This is what Ron Paul is talking about with going to the gold and silver monetary standard. Competing currencies allow people to have a choice whether they want "real money" or fiat (fake) money. If the dollar was backed by gold and silver then the prices of gold and silver would stablize and stay consistant. Will the government allow this? NO
I love the inovation of the businessman that is doing it but I'm sure that the IRS will come up with some new rule that says that these employees will be taxed at the value of the gold. When gold and silver are not considered as as "legal" money then we fall into a bartering system which does fall under IRS rules. I hope the payments of gold and silver excelerates by businesses and then it can become a lawsuit that should go all the way to the US Supreme Court. This lawsuit would win because our own Constitution states that "Only gold and silver can be used as legal tender" and as far as I know, no one has changed this portion of the Constitution.
There's always a way to get around government corruption and this employer may have found the way. Kudo's to him!!
Well, no
Your math is wrong. A $50 gold piece is worth $1000FRN, not 50,000. And the IRS seems to have CAVED on the gold money-FRN issue, and issued a letter opinion allowing gold coins to be accounted at face value until they are exchanged for FRNs, at which time capital gains tax will be due. See my post above.
Great
Great site - Thanks oh and great idea.
NP
No prob love the place :)
We haven't pay any taxes
in years. We just don't make enough.
We reorganized. Paid off our debt. Live in a little cabin. Work part-time.
In fact, IRS pays us now. Life is good.
I'm looking into the gold thing..... I'll be back.
Me to
This is exactly what i am working toward with my life, but where i live we also have property and land taxes also :( so that sucks to :(
property and land taxes based on value?
Sell the property to your buddy for whatever the going price is -- don't try to fudge the price. Then buy it back from him for gold. A $100,000 property (FRNs) should be worth around $5000 in gold eagles. If you acquired the property for $5000, your property taxes should be based on that figure. I haven't worked out the details really carefully, but it looks to me like your buddy should be able to claim a $95,000 capital loss on the sale, so everybody ends up happy. Oh, except the IRS. Pity.
Great Idea !
I wonder if the guy that works for my husband would be opposed to getting paid in $50 gold coins. It is a brilliant idea !!