HAVING PROBLEMS VIEWING THE SITE? GET FIREFOX! | A NOTE ON ADVERTISING

   

AZ GOP Convention a farce - Don't you guys care about this?

Well, I went as a delegate to the AZ State GOP convention today. There were a lot of Ron Paul supporters. I was impressed. We were instructed to just keep to ourselves and mingle. We did not create any kind of commotion and no one knew who the Ron Paul people were because we blended in.

We had a slate that everyone knew was our slate. BUT the neocons killed us. How? They had a McCain slate and they pushed it every time they got a chance. I mean every person who got up and spoke (starting with Jon Kyl, our other senator) pushed the McCain slate as the one to vote for. "Those are the true Republicans, blah, blah, blah." This went on when we split up to go to our own congressional delegate rooms. Then, it got worse. When we went back in to vote for delegates and alternates at large, the head of AZ GOP again advertised their slate. He even had another one that was updated and made sure it was handed out. Some people tried to call "Point of Order." These weren't even Ron Paul people but they knew the rules. They were shut down.

So, the vote went on. And guess who got all of the slots? Of course, the McCain slate. The lemmings went right off the cliff following after. I was so disgusted and ashamed. I thought "how can Americans think this is a democratic form of voting?" This was a dictatorship. We were told who to vote for so everyone did. I believe RP got about 40% but that wasn't enough.

So, we will have to fight and become PCs. They are who eventually run the party. In order to do that, you all have to become involved. This is not just a battle, this is a war.

Oh, and one more thing. I was totally disgusted that my senator who is running for president didn't even have the decency to show up at our convention. Jon Kyl had to do it for him. That is pathetic.

output

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

I was an AZ delegate

I was a state delegate.

We were trounced because Ron Paul supporters were outnumbered by far and the Party lined up a roster of delegates who believe that we should get behind McCain because he doesn't suck as much as the Democrats. Without MANY more RP supporters as delegates, there was nothing to be done about it.

Now what?

Is there really a future in the Republican party?

Should I spend my time getting elected as a PC and working within the party to try and change it? Or should I spend that time working on getting myself positioned for the crash, working in the garden, installing water harvesing, going to the gun range, etc?

Or should I join the LP and become a candidate so I can speak at forums and be quoted in the newspapers?

Unfortunately & Fortunately

BOTH Aloha

You are totally echoing the thoughts I have been having lately.

But I have decided to soldier on for now with the Republican Party while I make preparations for the possible future crash and loss of all our liberties. But I have to be honest..if money was no object I would be taking my whole family and leaving the United States and finding me some deserted island.

AZ.

Although I am one who is registered as an Independant voter, I would like to see Ron Paul to be able to get in there somehow. I would give him my vote! I refuse to vote for the cadidates that they are tying to currently throw at us! I won't let that circus sway me neither.

ThunderBirdWoman in AZ.

Some points...

I, like many others, left after casting my ballot for alternate delegates in the at large vote.

1. I heard zero calls for a point of order. Zero.

2. The party leaders made it very clear which slate was the McCain slate. Fair enough.

3. The party leaders made it clear they wanted everyone to vote for the McCain unity slate. Not good.

4. The incognito nature of the consensus slate was lame, and the creation of the red herring Ron Paul slate was lame too.

5. McCain's no-show was indicative of his character, IMHO.

6. The pastor's invocation disturbed me greatly. Paraphrased, he stated that government was a vehicle for achieving religious goals; and government and religion are intertwined. These comments received raucous applause. Anyone who wants their religion to survive, needs some long hard reading in a history book.

Did you volunteer to help prepare for the convention?

?

jg

You seem to be all over this site today. What's the occasion? And I detect a very snide tone to your question. What's up with that? This person showed up at the convention. What's your beef?

Showing up....

...is the minimum requirement.

Delegate

I just got an email from the Juan McCain campaign asking me to be a National Delegate for HIM! Yes, several months back when it looked like it would go to McCain, I signed up on McCain Campaign website, I held my nose to do this. Anyway, my point is WE need to do like THEY do! We need to be our own opposition! Just like there is little difference detween Dems and Reps. and I think they work together to the same ends alot. We need to be the McCain slate! Yes, I now that many on the McCain slate are long time party activists and it is hard to get "in", but AFTER we have the Ron Paul slate filled, go undercover to become the McCain Team!

Also, what if Paul people had produced a slate identical to McCains, purple, same heading, that had our people on it instead, within one hour, maybe with "Revised" in the heading? Could we have handed it out in order to promote choas in the McCain camp? And maybe gotten more votes? Fight fire with fire! Just a thought! This is a game of inches and every inch counts!

Gads...

That has a brilliant ring to it. I would like to think that through. The one main thing that made me so sick was how they had the microphone... It seemed like every other minute someone was up there telling the sheeple which slate to vote for. Confusing them and opening the door to making them thnk a little would have been great. I like your identical slate idea. I would also tie it to another slate that listed those delegates who support pro life...strong economy...medical choice...etc (not to mention Liberty!)
How many State conventions are left?

Be the Miracle!

Totally

DICTATORIAL!

Does my burka make my butt look fatwa?

call

Ron Pauls campaign and keep calling them. We got the doners list here. Also I think you go to http://fundrace.huffingto... and you can get all the doners for your state

The stealth element of this bugged me, a lot

Yesterday morning I was extremely uncomfortable being asked to hand out phony slates as part of a larger "psy-op". This kind of thing is just not for me.

And it would have been nice if the word "CONSENSUS" were spelled correctly.

You were asked

to hand out phony slates? I did not know where those came from. What it did was annoy people even more. The non-RP people I talked to thought it was some way of distracting or dividing people and they didn't like it. They thought it was Ron Paul and he was the bad guy. I don't think it was a good idea, at all!

Healthnut4freedom

"Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding. In all thy ways acknowledge Him, and He shall direct thy paths." Proverbs 3:5,6

Let me clarify

I *thought* they were the phony ones. It turns out they were the real ones. But what did I know? I never really had all the information because people were too scared to tell me all the details before the convention. I thought that maybe something had changed, because something about it seemed wrong - including the fact that it had a bunch of hardcore McCain people listed in my CD.

This supposed "plan" didn't accomplish anything, in fact it probably knocked the effort back a bit. It was a bad idea (in my opinion), but it's water under the bridge at this point. I can only hope that people in other states don't do anything like this at their conventions.

No, the real slate....

had to be handed out early because barely any volunteers showed up on time.

IT should have been handed out when breaking for the CD elections. However, it had to go early because by 8:30 we had a grand total of 3 non-delegate, non-alternate volunteers available to help.

Hence, the party recognized the consensus slate in time to play it down from the podium and play up the McCain one.

In the future, when volunteers are asked to show up by 8 am that means 7:45 am. Further, by 8 all vols should have obtained their guest credentials and been ready to volunteer by 8:01.

It's how we won in NV. Everyone showing up early and prepared.

That is not to say the vol help was not appreciated. It was. But as you aptly point out, it was to no avail.

It still wasn't the "real" slate

It had McCain people listed for all the CD delegate slots, or at least for my district. So apparently it was partially phony. But how was I or anyone supposed to know that? And how could I be expected to "sell" that slate to other non-RP delegates? It was much later that I discovered that there was a separate "real" list of 3 RP-friendly delegates to vote for in my district.

Yes it was.....

Because so few RP people submitted their apps for delegate on time, the best set of people that could be found were put onto the slates. All of the known RP supporters who submitted plus the top anti-mccain people. The rest resembled the McCain slate.

Again, rather than complaining what ACTION did you take?

How many PCs did you personally recruit?

How many state delegates did you get elected?

Did you submit your app for national delegate on time?

THOSE are the measures of success. Not how you "feel".

It would have been nice to know that in advance

Don't give me this bullsh** questioning what I have or haven't done. If you're trying to piss off all the people who have committed to this effort, just go ahead and keep talking like that.

And this thread here? It's not about you. If you don't like what people have to say when they talk to each other, too damn bad.

Thank you

for calling him out. I really wanted to myself, but it was not my place. If he starts any shit with me or any of the other CO delegates after our convention, then it will be my turn.

Facts vs. Emotion

Do you think John McCain and the GOP leadership care about your feelings?

Gil, how many precincts did you walk for Dr. Paul. Just give a number.

You are awfully quick to criticise yet short on delivering results.

The more I read your comments

the less inclined I am to believe anything you say. None of these people got paid a dime. They only gave of themselves. You, on the other hand, are/were a paid RP staffer, no?

Funny....

but the people who were ACTUALLY there in this thread all said it was the numbers.

Do you know something they don't, Gil. Were you there? Or do you just want to complain?

5 new PC's in AZ from me.

I've committed to find and sign up 5 new RP PC's in AZ. (how's that for alphabet soup!)

I have one already. Time is short. Each PC's need 15 sigs, maybe only 10 in some areas, and the need to be in by 6/2/08 to be safe. They don't even have to go to the freekin' meetings most of the time. We can carry their proxy. One guy in my PC had 15 proxy votes at a recent meeting. Now there's power at the ballot box.

If we all got 5 more we'd be half The way to taking over the AZ GOP. Then WE can write the rules and THEY can pony up to OUR bar or take a hike.

"What have you done for Ron Paul today"?

Average Joe = Super RP supporter!

Average Joe knows what it takes to win!

Thanks Average Joe!

You guys are on it!

You guys are on it!

We all care..

We're just ignorant about what to do. This is new to most of us, and we must fight seasoned veterans who know the ropes. Too bad we couldn't get our act together sooner, but who knew.

Your post helps us learn, thanks for yourr time and effort.

--------
We don't know how to mind our own business
'Cause the whole worlds got to be just like us
Now we are fighting a war over there
No matter who's the winner
We can't pay the cost
-Steppenwolf 1969

word

i am 18 years old

they say any people from my age to 23 or so are a huge part of the support but the older pro's so to speak are of more understanding ... there time in this life has been longer than mine but I am determined to bealive in the way things are done here ..... the message and the education of this rEVOLution...

i slept in till 12:20 on that saturday........

i feel like the mass's here in gilbert are very stuuupid and dont have a real state of mind or real refferance about what is going on outside of the mainstream televission/radio/newspaper .... i bealive this campaign has and is opening minds all over the world ....

peace and love

A potisive reality is born from positive thinking...

Nice Sentiment, but....

... it doesn't win conventions.

You could have become a PC and state delegate. We needed you.

I care.

I care.

Food and Coffee and go to national anyway

Food. Has anyone tried food and coffee?

I'm thinking, a booth with free food and coffee and a Ron Paul inspirational video playing all day (outside the hall, if need be), might be helpful.

People who take your food will pretend to listen politely and accidentally learn something.

It also sounds like the McCain stealth plan was to pack the hall. How many of the chosen delegates will actually attend national? If not enough delegates or alternates show up to represent the state, they may be glad to seat another Arizona Republican no matter who they are for. I suggest some of you plan to go to national, anyway.

Usually, it is all about having clout for one's state at national.

IMissLiberty

We got crushed

Bottom line is that they had more people. This is because we didn't go out and get enough PC's this time around.

So, will you complain about it and do nothing, or keep working and get more PC's elected and win in the congressional election cycle in 2 years???

I was a delegate also, to prove it I'll just say CONSENSUS.

I am continuing to get the right people elected. If we had a list of all the donors to RP we would own the next election cycle.

yes, we need more people

You are right. We need more people. I saw so many Ron Paul supporters so I totally believe you. But, when you count how many people are signed up in our meet up groups, the number was pathetic. We need people to get involved and become PCs. That is how you take the party back. Just as you have said here. They are who elect people and make changes.

I am not complaining but reporting the facts. Also, people need to be informed as to what happened and why. I believe too many are in the bleachers when they need to get in the game. That is why I am saying what I am saying.

Healthnut4freedom

"Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding. In all thy ways acknowledge Him, and He shall direct thy paths." Proverbs 3:5,6

I think maybe a couple

I think maybe a couple stealth people would be a good idea in handing out material. Have your top flier titled McCain, then on the backside list all the wonderful things he has said and done; things like bomb Iran, 100 years in Iraq, infidelity, calling his wife a "C" etc... then have your Ron Paul stuff underneath?

on the stealth thing

Fortune Favors the Bold

different situations call for different tactics. Unless you have a specific plan, or doing "reconaissance", stealth is pointless.

how can we harness the ron

how can we harness the ron paul supporters to recall mccain in an election of no confidence??? how many ron paul supporters were there?

Stealth is a stupid

Stealth is a stupid strategy. It goes against everything Ron Paul represents.

I wish we could get more communication from Campaign HQ on what this phase of the race is all about.

SUPPORT OUR FOUNDERS' AMERICA
Support the Constitution of the United States

Here it is....

Become a PC. Recruit 5 others.

You have 2 weeks left to do so.

The campaign has been asking you to do it for 14 months.

Forget stealth have an open

Forget stealth have an open debate in the middle of the convention and speak the truth. People will hear and know you are right.

The more I hear...

...the prouder I am of how we did things in WV. We had a loud group of supporters, and over 100 delegates out and obvious for Dr. Paul. I don't care that we only got 3 RNC delegates out of the deal, because we were certainly not going to overtake Romney or Huckabee in this state with the establishment in several counties the way it was. We worked hard, we did well, and we did it out in the open. I will always have the pride of knowing that when McCain didn't show up here, either, his surrogate was heckled for what was an inappropriate speech. We boo'd. Oh how backwoods! I've seldom been prouder. Calling a spade a spade. We cast our votes, and the Romney people were so angry! The McCain people were huffing and puffing and quite upset. When I left the floor saying "Well Romney can't even be straight forward about his first name... how am I supposed to trust him?" as a joke into a cellphone, people looked dumbfounded.

"Stealth" doesn't always work, folks. Insiders have means of figuring out which of us "don't belong", but people who are new to the process will have trouble picking out their own delegates. You can "stealth" yourself right out of slots at the RNC!

As an aside, I heard directly from several people at the AZ Convention that there were not enough open anti-McCain people (including Paul supporters) to have overturned the process, elected a new chair, etc.. The appraisal was that there were a lot of ancient folks and a lot of "young Republicans who looked like they were more interested in hooking up". The former are generally bussed in, since it's a weekday and there's nothing better to do. The latter are usually the establishment's children, being groomed for future office and looking for their early "credentials" in the Party. These Conventions during the week a long drive from Paul supporters are a killer. The economy's awful and not everyone can toss off a day at work to go vote, no matter how vital it is.

At any rate... please for love of all that's holy... understand that a strategy has to be sound, start to finish. Do what you can now, and I hope it all works out <3

It was on a Saturday

It was not on a weekday. I am not sure what you heard. And the people were not bussed in, they drove. The parking lot was packed. You are correct, it was mostly upper middle age to older white people with a minority of people younger than 40. Very few blacks or Asians. I am not sure I spotted one Hispanic. Certainly not representative of Arizona, for sure! I don't know why they can't see that. Nobody looked like they just wanted to 'hook up.' Maybe I am blind but I didn't really see that.

Anyway, it was on Saturday. There were only two candidates, one woman and one man, on the ballot for national committeeman, so no real vote except going through the motions. If we had caused a stir, I do not believe it would have gotten anywhere. The word has gotten out to all of the states about what has gone on in previous conventions. The NV convention made it loud and clear that, if they knew you were a Ron Paul Republican, they were going to do their best to not vote for you. Also, the comments up front were not specific to Ron Paul but were clear that anyone who wasn't for them was against them. When I did talk to people that were not Ron Paul people, they might not have been for McCain but they were definitely anti-Ron Paul. We have gotten bad press and the only way they are going to know any different is not our yelling louder, but they need better information. If all of the delegates could get his book, that would help.

The convention was on Saturday. There were a lot of Ron Paul supporters. It was expensive to have to drive there but we were there, nonetheless. But approximately 40% is not enough. We need well over 50% to make a difference. Most of our meet up group members are not involved. That is a problem. If you are involved in a meet up, you should be involved in the process but the majority weren't. And there was not enough communication going on from headquarters to the meet ups. I had to tell my meet up head what was going on. Otherwise he would not have had a clue. That is pathetic. The only reason that I knew is that I pursued it aggressively.

Bottom line, this is just the beginning. We are just now learning what we are up against and what we need to do to win the war. We have been too complacent thinking that we didn't have to fight so hard. It really disappoints me to think how many people could have been delegates but wouldn't do the little bit of work involved to make that happen. Those are who are really at fault for this. You can't blame headquarters if you don't show up. If you don't get involved, you can't claim to support Ron Paul and the message. Putting up signs and posting on forums doesn't cut it, if you really want change.

Healthnut4freedom

"Trust in the Lord with all thine heart; and lean not unto thine own understanding. In all thy ways acknowledge Him, and He shall direct thy paths." Proverbs 3:5,6

You are Correct ... read on.

I misspoke and a general sentiment about the primary/Convention process got intermingled with the commentary I was making about AZ in particular. Here in WV we did see some "bus-in"s (which is a general term as well; sometimes it's just a volunteer driving four little old ladies to a Convention, for instance) but not many. In the case of the person I spoke to, he did have to skip out on work to get there.

My bottom line on the subject is that there were still not enough Paul supporters to do any of the things I've heard "should have been" done during the Convention. You and I are in agreement on that. Even 40% is still not enough to cause a Convention-altering stir and get slates changed, and how many Paul-delegates were on those slates/met qualifications to begin with? :(

"It really disappoints me to think how many people could have been delegates but wouldn't do the little bit of work involved to make that happen. Those are who are really at fault for this. You can't blame headquarters if you don't show up." <--- That is the bottom line in all of this. Quoted for Truth.

show up

>>>Some people tried to call "Point of Order." ... They were shut down.
Please put up video/audio recordings. If they break the rules, start your own rump convention!

>>>I believe RP got about 40% but that wasn't enough.
EVERYONE MUST SHOW UP. 50% and we win!

>>>So, we will have to fight and become PCs. They are who eventually run the party.
Yes, yes, yes. Get the local positions and then run the GOP organization locally.

>>>If we had a list of all the donors to RP we would own the next election cycle.
This is available at fec.gov.

>>>Putting up signs and posting on forums doesn't cut it, if you really want change.
In my state, I know a person who is a delegate. Our convention is May 31. He says maybe he will schedule a business trip that conflicts with the convention. This person doesn't talk to others, spends all his time on ron paul forums, and complains about the system. He is so close to being a positive force for change, but he doesn't take a few steps... This is why the neocons maintain control.

Re: Last Point

Depending on your state's rules, please look into seeing if you can be appointed an alternate for him. In our state it took a form that both parties signed, and of course the alternate had to be qualified. This is likely not the case in your state, but please look into it :) Could be that you can pick up the banner where this person has dropped it.

I was a delegate too

I didn't like the stealth idea. I understand why it was thought necessary, but the concept just doesn't seem to fit with the rest of the Constitutional thrust of the r3volution, nor with the passion and enthusiasm of the supporters.
The whole theme of the convention was to 'unify' and vote McCain to beat the democrats. The talk of McCain himself was actually very limited. It's like the entire Republican Party knows McCain sucks, but somehow he got into the lead and now they 'have to' vote for him. (It really is weird how he was dead in the water and suddenly catapults to 'lead'?) anyway,
A couple weeks before the convention I contacted the AZ GOP for lists of the elected delegates with the intent of having a list to hopefully work from to find out who were RP supporters. I was stonewalled. I was getting very frustrated, even had emailed the RP campaign asking for direction and organization help because there didn't seem to be any forthcoming. No answer from the campaign. Except for a couple RP supporters in my LD, I couldn't make contact with other RP supporters -- the last meetup in my area I went to, NO ONE ELSE showed up! and the meetup before that one, only 3 of us showed up! I've been feeling generally isolated as far as RP supporters being organized, but I'll keep working on that. I have had a few people from work come to me about Ron. Finally one gal in my LD emailed me that someone from the Phoenix meetup was putting together a list of RP supportive delegates. I contacted them and they did get the list out at the convention with no time to spare.
What I don't get is, several names on the 'real' RP slate were also the names on the McCain slate. It had been explained to me that Anti-McCain people were joining with RP supporters and that should give us better numbers, maybe that's why.
What I don't get is, how can we grow our r3volution unless we know each other? I met a total of one other RP supporter at the convention, who would even mention his name! I passed out copies of the slate but even if someone appeared to be thinking about acknowledging that they support RP, they just kept moving by, I HATE THE STEALTH CONCEPT. It was like the other guy here said, like a cattle convention. mind-numbing.
Another thing I don't get is, almost everyone who WAS following the McCain slate, had complaints against McCain! The most recent being his meeting with LaRaza. When they'd mention that, I'd offer a copy of "The Constitution Slate", but they'd go back to following the McCain agenda. THERE IS NO REAL LOVE OR ENTHUSIASM FOR THE GUY. The taped McCain message was droning and no one even paid attention. There was no real excitement, no genuine belief in this candidate, speech-givers trying to elicit cheers made unenthused attempts and the applause was weak, no crazy cheering, no yelling, No genuine passion for McCain at all. It's crazy that RP supporters couldn't walk away owning the state.
We should have been there STIRRING IT UP, WAKING IT UP, MAKING IT MEMORABLE, REVOLUTIONIZING.
We should abandon this stealth practice for SLAP IN THE FACE modus operandi. I will not be operating in stealth mode any more.

Who was your LD coordinator?

Did your LD coordinator work with the campaign? Can you find out?

Are you recruiting 5 more PCs in the 2 weeks there are remaining?

Great video

Was undecided until now, but this clinched it...

I think it's time to forget about the stealth crap and just go out there all guns blazing. Unless you are Seriously stealthed up (ie. ON one of these McCain Loyalist Nazi slates) then forget about slipping under the radar. The McCain campaign is well aware that RP suporters are still actively campaigning and Nevada was a wake up call to the fact that we're serious about it.

The fact is that a lot of these people aren't complete idiots, they're just uninformed. Look at Nevada - 10% of the total number of people there (who would otherwise have voted for the party-approved purple paper) switched to Ron Paul because they actually wanted to vote for a real life conservative Republican. Not a crazy, liberal, left wing, spoiled little daddy's-boy piece of crap like the presumptive nominee. So many people just think that Ron Paul is a one policy candidate (the war) and have no idea that he is far and away the best person for the job. Talking about the Nevada swing vote, this poster reckons that RP got about 40% of the vote. What if we'd been actively campaigning the place, winning hearts and minds. Maybe we'd have swung another 10% across and walked away with a full RP slate from McCain's home state. I suspect that even the MSM couldn't have resisted a juicy story like that one.

Missed opportunity there. Very disappointing.

=========================
Live Free or Die - Amen to that

False....

In NV 40% of the state delegation were RP supporters.
In AZ 8% or less of the state delegation were RP supporters.

Were you a state delegate? If not why not?

Are you a PC? IF not why not?

Will you have your PC papers filed in the 2 weeks you have left?

If not why not?

If you are unwilling to do the work yourself, how can you charge other people to do it for you?

Can we get an AMEN

AMEN

Be the Miracle!