HAVING PROBLEMS VIEWING THE SITE? GET FIREFOX! | A NOTE ON ADVERTISING

   

GPS Tracking Forced On Dallas Kids

Violating "No Child Left Behind" because you skip classes? That's a GPS trace tagging. Not a request. Judge mandated.

Briefly mentioned in the article is that 300 kids from this one school alone have to go to truancy court each year. It's either go to school (where learning is fun and edyookashunul!) or face the judge, kids. (Is my bias showing?)

Full article is here, but requires registration (NY Times). I'll give you the salient bits:

Quotes FTA:

Jaime used to snooze until 2 p.m. before strolling into school. He fell so far behind that he is failing most of his classes and school officials sent him to truancy court.

Instead of juvenile detention, Jaime was selected by a judge to be enrolled in a pilot program at Bryan Adams in which chronically truant students are monitored electronically. Since Jaime started carrying the Global Positioning System unit April 1, he has had perfect attendance.

“I’m just glad they didn’t take him to jail,” said Jaime’s grandmother Diana Mendez, who raised him. “He’s a good kid. He was just on a crooked path.”

Educators are struggling to meet stricter state and federal mandates, including those of the No Child Left Behind Act, on attendance and graduation rates. The Dallas school system, which, like other large districts, has found it difficult to manage the large numbers of truant students, is among the first in the nation to experiment with the electronic monitoring.

“Ten years ago the issue of truancy just slid by,” said Jay Smink, executive director of the National Dropout Prevention Center. “Now the regulations are forcing them to adhere to the policies.”

(...)

Kyle Ross, who runs the in-school suspension program at Bryan Adams, was skeptical of the electronic monitoring until he saw that it worked. “We’re always yearning for something tangible to use as tools to teach self-efficacy,” Mr. Ross said. “Everyone’s so overwhelmed. We’ll try anything.”

Dallas’s experiments in tracking truancy started three years ago. Last year, case managers used a G.P.S. system to locate a truant student on the verge of overdosing on drugs, and they discovered that a student had skipped school because he was contemplating suicide.

Ricardo Pacheco, 18, who is no relation to Jaime, said electronic monitoring had helped him get on track last year, despite advice from his friends to “just yank it off.”

“It was easier to come to school each day, stay out of the streets and be home every night,” said Mr. Pacheco, a father of two young children and a former gang leader. Now he is about to become the first male from his father’s side of the family to graduate.

(...)

Across the state, in Midland, county justice officials started using electronic ankle monitors last summer to track about 14 of the most chronically truant students. The officials hope to double the number of students monitored next year.

(...)

Dave Leis, a spokesman for NovaTracker, which makes the system used in Dallas, said electronic monitoring did not have to be punitive. “You can paint this thing as either Big Brother, or this is a device that connects you to a buddy who wants to keep you safe and help you graduate.”

output

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Yep, It's All in the Kids' Best Interests

Just like what happened with these kids.

Interesting comments



Good article which raises interesting questions. I choose to take the position of not getting paranoid about it. (Ya gotta pick your battles.) For some kids who need a kick in the butt, this could actually turn them around, keep them out of trouble and be the greatest thing that ever happened to them.

More importantly, I think schools should also work on something that makes classes worth attending and more relevant for kids, instead of just babysitting and memorizing useless bits of information.

My blog: My 'Net Gems

Don't get paranoid about the Government tracking kids?

If that is not something to get paranoid about, I don't know what is. Throughout history, governments with too much power and private info have always ended up using it badly. In order to believe this is not very scary, you would have to believe that our Government is always looking out for our best interest. And if you believe that, then Ron Paul can't be your man.
Also remember that most Government programs always start out small with a promises to not get bigger and more invasive.

Remember they said you will never have to give out your SS# for anything other than the SS program. Now you can't even get a fishing license in Texas without giving it out.

Sounds like some back scratchin going on

Sounds like some tech company lobbied our government to get a deal going for their products.

Doesn't matter if kids privacy and rights are violated as long as the tech company gets their easy piece of the taxpayers pie.
This makes me sick that free enterprise businesses are grovelling at the trough of government subsides to make their companies successful.

Go out and earn your money, like the rest of us. Stop lobbying government you parasites.

Davy C Rockett

Where the spirit of the Lord is, there is LIBERTY! - 2 Cor. 3:17

http://www.thelibertypost...
http://screamfreedom.blog...
http://liberty-central.bl...

Bigger picture: fundamental rights

This really isn't about whether "loser" kids skip class. There are plenty of super-bright, bored-out-of-their-skull kids who skip classes, too, and understandably so.

The issue is: does the State have the right to force GPS tracings on people, even people who are not criminals? Or is it "criminal" to not attend school?

More fundamentally: does the State have the right to force education upon our children, whether in the manner which the State prescribes or otherwise?

The whole concept of public education was created to give America's kids an opportunity to obtain formal schooling without having to pay for it individually (never mind for the moment that this forces other people to pay, via taxes, for the education of strangers' children). Does the fact that this opportunity exists mean that families have to accept that benefit?

There are lots of benefits currently available to Americans who qualify for them. But should we be forced to accept those benefits or face penalty of imprisonment (or worse)?

- Flu shots
- Health care (Hillary wants to force this upon everyone, you know)
- Social security
- etc. etc. etc.

When I was a kid...

Some kids were allowed to be losers. They could skip class without much of a problem...and who cared?

It was nice for the rest of the students who actually cared about going to class and learning (however little).

By allowing loser kids to skip class...the ones who are trying to get an education could do so by some children who had no interest in learning being "left behind". It spared you from having to sit near a giggly stoner, reeking of smoke, snoring in class, and making what i'm sure seemed to be mind boggling observations. Let some kids waste away their youths, are we really kidding ourselves to believe that morons are going to further the cause of humanity....no, the world needs manual laborers and fry cooks too.

Leaving no child behind makes a whole generation dumb down to the lowest common denominator. We should all be as dumb as our dumbest kid.

I completely agree

There are always going to be losers unless we stop having winners. Then we will have a nation of losers who think they are all winners. Instead of No Child Left Behind, it should be called the "Cookie Cutter Program".