Do You Feel a Draft?
May 21, 2008
Military.com Article
Sen. Daniel Inouye (D-Hawaii), chairman of the Senate Appropriations defense subcommittee, asked Gates and Mullen the question he said no one wants to ask: "Is the cost of maintaining an all-volunteer force becoming unsustainable and, secondly, do we need to consider reinstituting the draft."
This marks the first time a senior member of Congress has seriously discussed reinstituting the draft in almost two years.
Inouye cited the ever-increasing pay and benefits paid to active and reserve service members, noting that it now costs an estimated $126,000 per service member.
Gates and Mullen both said they thought the current volunteer force was the finest the U.S. has ever fielded. Gates said he "personally" believes that "it is worth the cost."
Mullen was not quite as sanguine.
"A future that argues for, or results in, continuous escalation of those costs does not bode well for a military of this size," he said, adding it the rising costs will eventually force the US to shrink the military, spend less on new weapons or to "curtail operations." The question of pay and benefits for the U.S. military "is the top issue we need to come to terms with," Mullen said.
This marks the first time a senior member of Congress has seriously discussed reinstituting the draft in almost two years. Rep. Charlie Rangel (D-NY), chairman of the powerful House Ways and Means Committee, called for reinstituting the draft in November 2006.
Tuesday's discussion occurred during debate over the pending $70 billion emergency supplemental spending bill. Senate Majority Leader Sen. Harry Reid (D-Nev.) said Tuesday that the bill was unlikely to move before Labor Day, requiring a one month extension of war spending.
In related news, Gates was asked by Republican Sen. Thad Cochran of Mississippi during the appropriations hearing what would happen if the 2009 defense spending bill were not passed, requiring what is known as continuing resolution to provide the Defense Department with money.
Gates, clearly prepared for the question, said the department would face enormous losses should Congress rely on a resolution, losing nearly $8.7 billion dollars for increasing the size of the Army and Marine Corps, and see $246 million for the new Africa Command vanish along with $1.8 billion for base closure and realignment. A continuing resolution effectively funds a department at the levels it received the year before.
- goldenequity's blog
- Login or register to post comments






















I will not serve and I will
I will not serve and I will run to the hills if the paper comes in the mail. I will not kill poor people so rich people can get richer. You get the picture? You know Paul had it right when he asked the churches why they were honoring rich people. He said isn't it rich people that take you're sons and daughters for war?
Will all the illegals go first ...
then all the criminals ... and all of our wonderful celebrities and how about all of the senators and congressmens children and grandchildren ... they can kiss my butt.
Not defending the people who actually work as civilians BUT
If you didnt have those Civies there, which approximatly makes up about 30 percent or more (CANT REMEMBER), there would surely BE A DRAFT....
A volunteer (ALTHOUGH WELL PAID) is better than the political tourmoil at home if there was a draft.... Comprende....\
I am DEF not defending the corporations who are excessively war profiteering...
By the way, I have been in Afghanistan as a Civilian, and my job actually saved lives and tons of money, and I did not even have a gun.... Not condoning it, but its a fact.... Besides, I used the inflationary money that the Gov payed me, and found my freedom....
It funded my departure from the United States...
Interesting approach. My
Interesting approach. My wife's health will not allow me to do likewise.
I must admit, I like the last line. If you don't mind my asking, and it will not get you into any trouble, where did you go and how does one make a living after departing?
I've always wondered about this last. Any advice would be appreciated.
Feel A Draft Do You?
In God We Trust!
Feel a draft? Shut the door!
Rep. Rangle (D-NY) has reintroduced a bill to institute a
draft for men and women between the ages of 18 and 42. It's been shoved aside before, but he keeps bringing it back.
militia?`
Are there any options by joining a state militia? Can a person claim sanctuary as a militia soldier? Jyst a thougght... I once heard that a person can.
The Union Draft
That would be interesting now that UK, Canadian & US & Carribean trade unions have just agreed to join forces. (News just in btw).
'I always think of all you canvassors and precinct leaders and delegates at the front line and caucuses.
Good luck out there &Thank you. You're a gift.
I HOPE THEY DO HAVE A DRAFT...
If they do have a draft, that might be just what we need to wake the mass of sheep up and get them thinking about their rights. I know if they do, most of the people drafted won't go is what I think. I know I sure as hell won't go,...and it has nothing to do with "being afraid to fight" or scared or any of that bullshit,...it is simply that the government doesn't own my life and never will.
Draft Would Force Education and Debate
In his book, 'Don't Start The Revolution Without Me', Jesse Ventura mentions the draft. In the book, his good friend, Bill Walton of basketball fame, mentions that he thinks that they should bring back the draft because the perils of a all paid professional army insulate the population from the realities of war. Jesse seems surprised by the comment and concludes it food-for-thought. Furthermore, in his book, Nemesis,Chalmers Johnson points out, in reference to the professional Roman army, the notion of over-stretch and how it eventually contributed to the demise of empire.
Don't Start the Revolution Without Me:
http://www.amazon.com/Don...
Nemesis:
http://www.amazon.com/Nem...
I'm remembering the Vietnam War today
I'm especially thinking of the veterans of the Vietnam War today. I remember how so many were drafted, sent to Vietnam - and so many came home in body bags. For what exactly? Vietnam is another example of a war we should have never got involved in.
I know several Vietnam veterans. A guy I went to school with died in that war, as did the brother of a friend of mine. My heart goes out to those families just as it does for those who have died in the war in Iraq.
For those who lost a friend or family member in the war, there is a website I just found out about where you can go to leave a personal message about the person you knew. It is a way of honoring the person who died in the war. If you are interested in doing so, here is the site address:
http://www.footnote.com
Start contacting your
Start contacting your representitives and voice your opposition to any draft or manditory service. I did.
We will not submit to it.
that d from hi was the same guy ixnaing the fema camp olly north
thing?There are none so blind as those who will not see!
Draft the immigrants if they wanted Ron Paul for President?
Whether or not it’s the euro, the dollar, the pharma or the oil ya . . . or who’s “party”. Our problem with society is endemic everywhere in the world. It’s the direction the “machine is going”. There is a lack of compassion for all living things and creatures. . . the bees, the bats, the orchards, the herbs, the cows and the pigs, and people to name a few. We are being lied to and manipulated as mere atoms to be shoved around at a Las Vegas crap table.
My passion is the sustainability of the planet and quality of life for everyone. Quality of life is being able to sit down and have healthy meal in peace and not being intimidated by gangs either. Everyone needs shelter. My life is not religion or politic or yours (equally confusing and manipulative). What troubles me is that all living creatures and things are being pushed into extinction or poisoned. Local access to organic, living foods are being stripped away or modified with wonton abandon.
Would you join an army if it declared martial law on Congress and the Senate? Or stood in front of Monsanto? Would you draft and arm the immigrants if they too wanted Ron Paul for President? Would you fund an “ecological” army with directives “to respect all living things and creatures, not to be sacrificed at the alter of any government or ideology”.
Really? You want a better world? Then start with your local terrorist. They are called city planners and blind developers; they are called doctors who shove pharmaceuticals down your throat. They are your fellow citizens with their heads in the sand. They are called local elected officials that take bribes and sneak in ‘last minute” agendas. Get serious. They need to be replaced with persons of a greater aspirations of vision. Enforce your growth caps. You are the army! Do it. Do it now. The war is on.
And a word for you self proclaimed gods of the world, get over it. And don’t laugh at me for hugging a tree. And before you make any choice, the first question is, how does it impact local accessabiltiy to quality foods. You know, like for every oil well, drill a water well for the people. For every suburb, bring back the local truck farms as you paved paradise. This will automatically control excessive population growth. The following paragraph is you’re greatest weapon and you can do it now.
Choose to eat a plant-centered diet. Eat more organic, locally grown vegetables and grains, less meat, less dairy. Eat as close to vegetarian as you are comfortable with. Make the proper food and exercise choices and you wont be so sick, and can think more clearly and have more energy for this global movement.
And never forget, “Humans, despite our artistic pretensions, our sophistication and many accomplishments, owe the fact of our existence to a six-inch layer of topsoil and the fact that it rains.”
So, what's you're army fighting for?
This is a main talking point for the democrats
"MANDATORY SERVICE"
If you saw the MTV debates both democratic candidates brought up this term as a veiled threat of draft. Barack and Hillary have talked about it in other debates, but this debate with its focus on young people was especially striking. Hillary is a known close friend of Rangels (the subhuman who proposed HR393-Mandatory Service).
I hope the service people in Iraq can have the courage to lay down their weapons in protest of this war.
I wanted to also add
I wanted to also add something about the cost per service member being too high.
These days much of the work in the military which used to be done by soldiers is now being done by businesses, at great profit. Big business builds the bases, feeds the solders, takes care of utilities, etc, etc.
The Sundance Channel ran a documentary back in the fall about the gross excess spending by the government on various Iraq related jobs.
They interviewed one solder who said he liked to wash his own clothes because they turned out better than the laundromat. He was forced, ordered by his commanding officer, to have the laundromat do his clothes. The laundromat (at least on that base) was paid $99 per load of laundry. $99!!!!!!!!!
Then they showed video of a parking lot full of Cadillac Escalades which were provided to civilian office workers to drive from their quarters to their office (nothing off base). Sundance (or whoever made the documentary) reported that the military paid $50,000 per year for 5 years to GM for EACH Cadillac Escalade. $250,000 total for SUVs which should only cost maybe $55k or so.
I also recall something about computer lab technicians/monitors getting paid low six figures to basically sit and watch soldiers sign-in to use a computer. Civilian employees earning crazy amounts yet again when the military could easily train soldiers to do these jobs for significantly less cost.
Retired members of the special forces hired through companies at somewhere around 5x the cost of the average soldier...
It costs the military $126,000 per soldier on average because they waste so much money, not because soldiers are actually that expensive.
Senator Charles Rangel is
Senator Charles Rangel is the one who has been trying to get forced national service for all people aged 18 through 42 for years. Last vote on his bill, hr 393, was 2 for and 402 against. Rangel has stated that he sponsored the bill in order to make a point about the war, but I do not trust that notion.
HR 393 is waiting in the wings of congress for when they need to use it.
Personally, I would voluntarily join to defend our nation if we were under attack. But I would never serve, draft or no draft, for an unconstitutional war. This is pretty much why "involuntary servitude" is specified in the 13th amendment. The founders knew that government would not have to force people to defend their homeland. Regarding drafts, technically (and as far as I understand it) it is not forced service as the joining stage of the draft is a voluntary action (when the ask all people who are joining the Army to take one step forward; that was a voluntary step forward). Anyhow...
Raise pay
Not enough volunteers? Raise combat pay until there are.
Contractors for firms like Blackwater in Iraq start at about $150K annually, and many make several times that. That tells me that there is a price at which more servicemen and women will come on board, and it is higher than what we're now paying them.
Still not enough volunteers? Close some bases and transfer staff.
Still not enough? How about just ending the war?
Hey, why not?
Hey, why not? Slaves are always cheaper than employees. And as a side bonus, they can rid the USA of a fair number of those traitorous "Constitutionalists" at the same time, and kill two pro-liberty birds with one neocon stone!
Constitution-Hugger
"Constitutionalists"
The newspeak terminology for that expression is "Constitution-Hugger." :-)
"If we want to live in a free society, we need to break free from these artificial limitations on free debate and start asking serious questions once again." -Ron Paul, The Revolution: A Manifesto
LOL
I like that.
----------------------------------------------------------
http://www.youtube.com/wa...
----------------------------------------------------------
We can all say what needs to be done, but who here led by example today?
What are they going to do
What are they going to do break in to people's houses that really don't want to go and kidnap people? Who are they going to get to do the kidnappings? And they really want kidnapped people fighting for them? They do that and there will be a lot more friendly fire.
Yup
And try put them in the fema camps for helping terrorists by not serving there great nation.
If the wars were justified defensive measures
I would gladly sign up. I am not getting shot at so some assholes behind the scenes can take over the world with their we want to spread democracy and freedom which is a bunch of crap, they want to civilize the world so they can control us all. I was in the Marine Corps and was ready to die for my country, I wouldn't sweat a drop of sweat for George Bush or Dickhead Cheney. Ron Paul, I would take a bullet for because he is the true definition of a leader and I would have faith in his judgement for war. I wouldn't be second guessing what I was fighting for if Ron Paul were the commander in chief. I would let my son go to war if it was justified also, but we cannot trust these politician scumbags. If my son were to get drafted, I would snatch him up and get the hell out of here. Like I said, if it were justified, I would accept that he had to go, not by say from this current government or the up and coming one, No Way. I respect the military and the job that they do, I feel bad for them that they have such an idiot as a leader.
H.R 393 National Service Act
Stalled in commitee waiting for a new pearl harbor like events! oh wait that already happened! WORLD WAR THREE HERE WE COME There are none so blind as those who will not see!
Disgusting
I am currently active duty, USN. Been in for 8 years, and I can say confidently that I don't want anyone who is forced into the service to be working on nuclear reactors along side me. We get enough people who are volunteers who already hate being in. I could only imagine what morale would be if the draft was instituted.
Not only that, but to hear our "representatives" talking about living, breathing youth (and even middle-aged folks) like tools or bullet-points on a brief is disgusting.
I don't even know what else to say, other than I am extremely disappointed at the nerve of these clowns to believe this is acceptable.
Bubble - Head :-P
Where did you go to Nuke school? It used 2 be in Orlando... Make sure ya got your cover on when ya step outside and your gig line straight. I salute you Patriot, from one squid 2 another, may your tour(s) be rewarding. Maybe they'll increase your re-up bonus :-) Thanks for your service.
[ USN TMT 80' -84'] Mk-48 "Green Death" / Tomahawk.
I got written up once
in Orland due to a gig line. It was during boot camp and trust me my line was on. I was supposed to receive my Nuke training there but in the seventies the Navy was in a crisis situation due to their not being able to staff enough machinist mates on tin cans. I was curious about being sent to Great Lakes after boot but became really concerned about being sent to a destroyer tender, the Shenandoah, immediately afterwards. This ship was welded to the pier and every individual in the engineering department was a nuke supposedly waiting for their school to open. A day after I arrived a Warrant Officer showed up and proceeded to present me with papers that he insisted I sign releasing the Navy from its obligation to send me to Nuke school. Naturally I declined and was immediately handed an air driven paint chipper and placed down in the bilges with knee deep greasy water and made to spend three days till I finally walked off. My hearing has never recovered from the noise made by these contraptions. I dealt with my mast and the Navy in it's infinite wisdom decided that the most discrete way to handle me was to make me disappear from all the others in my position and give me an Honorable discharge.
Nuke school in S. Carolina,
Nuke school in S. Carolina, Didn't get the joy of the Orlando area. Never said I as a bubblehead though.... but I am. What gave it away? Thanks for the appriciation! Keep fightin' for freedom, on what ever front is presented to you.
Most Nukes I knew...
Most Nukes I knew had dolphins, then again I built torpedoes :-) They closed that dive tower in Groton, get a chance at that? Big Nuke school in Orlando, my TM A & C school was on the other side of the base near the RTC. Though I heard its closed up? Allot of waves back then :-) I finished up in Naval Weapons Station, Goosecreek, short drive from Charlestown :-P May you not have to stand watch often and enjoy that good chow you guys get :-P
Top Contributors too Ron Paul "Great Work"
http://www.opensecrets.or...
US Army $72,386
Google Inc $55,301
US Air Force $54,267
US Navy $51,052
Microsoft Corp $48,477
US Postal Service $27,118
Lockheed Martin $23,012
Boeing Co $21,884
Cisco Systems $19,439
Verizon Communications $19,345
Hewlett-Packard $18,517
AT&T Inc $18,063
General Dynamics $17,853
Northrop Grumman $16,707
Apple Inc $15,603
IBM Corp $15,403
Intel Corp $15,146
Raytheon Co $15,129
General Electric $14,098
US Dept of Defense $13,221
Many people who voluntarily
Many people who voluntarily join the military do so because they have few or no other options. Those are probably the people who hate being in. They are in it for the guaranteed paycheck, free house on base and various other perks - not to serve their country. A significant number join because if they do not they would end up homeless.
Forced service might actually bring in some very highly skilled workers who would otherwise never join because they make great livings in the civilian world.
I agree that a draft is a bad idea, though.
It is not like you john,
Your comment and opinion on this, makes me step back. :-(
Added >> What does this remark tell us? "Forced service might actually bring in some very highly skilled workers who would otherwise never join because they make great livings in the civilian world."
Yeah, I knew this was coming.
You watch, after the election, there will be a lot more talk about the draft, and if Obama or McCain wins, they will be starting it up again.
Beau is right; morale definitely suffers when there's a draft.
LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL!!!! can
LOOOOOOOOOOOOOOL!!!! can anyone say insurrection of epic proportions????
Insurrection of epic
Insurrection of epic proportions!
*grabs gun*
I thought all along
Ron Paul should have been driving this home during the heat of the campaign.
This effects everyone! All men and women, between the ages of 18 to 42. Those not able to serve in the military would be utilized (and relocated) by homeland security.
consider alternative reasons
i think he believed in what he said, but he truly did not understand how the federal reserve controlled the "free" economy or the very power of the warfare state. largely, i think reagan was an unintentional puppet. remember, Grimwald was his counselor, whispering in his ear all the while, plotting his NWO takeover with his crony neocons. Got it just solid enough to pass onto sonny bwoy.
Well, that's one way to lose all the incumbents.
Anyone who votes for the draft would be bounced out of their cushy jobs at the voters' next opportunity.
-jcr
DIGG IT PLEASE
http://digg.com/politics/...
DIGG IT!
"If we want to live in a free society, we need to break free from these artificial limitations on free debate and start asking serious questions once again." -Ron Paul, The Revolution: A Manifesto
Dugg!
Dugg!
Dugg.
.
Just around the corner...
In the term of ~Manditory National Service~.
All the popular candidates have used the term... we are told that our children will not only be grateful for serving our country, they'll get college money for it.
So instead of Hitler youth we'll have Obama youth... blah
Next year, probably.
My 17 year old sister got
My 17 year old sister got tired of hearing me talk about Ron Paul. "Why should I care?" I told her she'd care when she gets drafted.
Don't know what my dad will do if the draft is instituted. He wouldn't sit back and let the military take his daughters (eligible ones 19 & 17).
I found an armed services manual online and discovered that I am ineligible to serve because of my kidney transplant. Used that piece of info on a Marine recruiter - shortest phone call from the armed forces!
This would be a travesty
if a draft were reinstated. We are fighting UNJUST wars. It just goes on and on and on. The powers that are behind the wars care NOTHING about the military men and women. Proof of that can be seen in the substandard care of those who have been wounded so badly that they will not be returning to duty. Don't get me wrong......I stand behind every single patriot who is out there fighting and who will be fighting in the future. I pray that God will protect our troops. That said, I also pray that God will protect all of the innocent civilians who are caught up on the chessboard of the silly game that our government (CFR, Bilderberg, etc.) has entered into for their own twisted reasons. I just wish that more of our military personnel would read the part of the constitution that says "foreign AND domestic". They could serve us well here in our own country!!!!!
Never
As a veteran of the first Gulf war, I am saddened by the current abuse of our military.
I will never surrender my children to the state. Never.
-LF
Me neither
Never!
In a free society, we
In a free society, we should have no problem getting enough volunteers. (Only if we change to a more constitutional foreign policy and live within our means.) If freedom is lost, the volunteers will disappear, because there will be nothing left to fight for.
moral abomination
To quote Ronald Reagan:
What can I say? On this, I agree with Reagan. Never thought I'd say that.
"If we want to live in a free society, we need to break free from these artificial limitations on free debate and start asking serious questions once again." -Ron Paul, The Revolution: A Manifesto
Reagan let us down.
During his campaign against Carter, he said that peacetime draft registration was unconscionable. However, once he was in office, he did nothing at all to end it.
-jcr
Thanks for your view
Thanks for your view on the subject. But Reagan's words still have value.
"If we want to live in a free society, we need to break free from these artificial limitations on free debate and start asking serious questions once again." -Ron Paul, The Revolution: A Manifesto