HAVING PROBLEMS VIEWING THE SITE? GET FIREFOX! | A NOTE ON ADVERTISING

   

Are You Required by law To fill out Census survey?

I was sent a "american community survey" from the u.s. census. It says my response is required by law but what's their recourse?
Its asking really specific questions with regards to who's living at my house their names and incomes. My main fear is that I'll foul up one number on the income statement or earned interest and then I'll get audited for tax evasion, Can I just ignore this?
\

btw: wheres the anything goes forum that I keep hearing about
all I see is General/ books/ march forums?

output

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Article I, Section 2 of the

Article I, Section 2 of the US Constitution gives Congress the right to ENUMERATE the number of citizens in order to apportion members of congress: "The actual Enumeration shall be made within three years after the first meeting of the Congress of the United States, and within every subsequent term of ten years, in such manner as they shall by law direct."

Enumerate means "to count, or determine the number of". Congress can COUNT the number of citizens- but it can't demand to know what race we are, how much we earn, how many big screen TVs we own, or how many times we masturbate each day.

So when I get the census forms, I fill out the first question (the one asking how many people live at my home), then paste a copy of Article 1, Section 2 of the Constitution right below that, along with a statement that I have fulfilled my duty as a citizen by helping them enumerate, and I'm not required to answer any more questions.

Never heard a peep from the Census bureau for doing this.

BTW, make sure you stick a RON PAUL FOR PRESIDENT slim jim in the mailer when you send it back to them...

www.ronpaul2008.com

Is it required?

If Americans are afraid to to not submit a form given to them by the ones who call themselves masters, what will Americans do when they are faced with Tyranny's soldiers? Practice giving Tyranny the finger. Let them become afraid of those who will not submit to their "requirements". Trash the form and forget about it. What/who goes on in my home is protected information.

If you submit the form out of fear, may your chains rest lightly upon you.

Throw it out and say you never got it, if asked.

If they send you another, repeat above.

___________

Lisa C.

http://www.women4ronpaul....

water sprinkler

if/when they come to your door do you have to give your name?, show id? or just say the number 1234 and shut the door... and turn on the water sprinkler.
------------------------------------------------
"RON PAUL SUPPORTER SINCE 1997"
RON PAUL 2008 / RE-ELECT 2012

We refuesed the ACS eight(?) months ago...

so far we haven't heard anything else about it. The questions were VERY personal! They wanted to know income, cost of rent/home, what time you leave for work, how many miles you drive, etc, etc, etc. It is a forty minute survey if I remember right. Basically they harass you for 90 days then eventually move on. I was grateful when I found these sites (and the first post on survivalarts includes a Ron Paul quote on the ACS!). Good luck!

http://www.survivalarts.c... and https://www.checkpointusa...

------------------------------------
The lesser of two evils is still evil!

THANK YOU

"the first post on survivalarts includes a Ron Paul quote on the ACS!"
here's part of it....

"None of Your Business!": the American Community Survey

Texas congressman Ron Paul, in today's "Texas Straight Talk", reports on an incredibly intrusive expansion of the American census, the "American Community Survey":

You may not have heard of the American Community Survey, but you will. The national census, which historically is taken every ten years, has expanded to quench the federal bureaucracy’s ever-growing thirst to govern every aspect of American life. The new survey, unlike the traditional census, is taken each and every year at a cost of hundreds of millions of dollars. And it’s not brief. It contains 24 pages of intrusive questions concerning matters that simply are none of the government’s business, including your job, your income, your physical and emotional heath, your family status, your dwelling, and your intimate personal habits.

The questions are both ludicrous and insulting. The survey asks, for instance, how many bathrooms you have in your house, how many miles you drive to work, how many days you were sick last year, and whether you have trouble getting up stairs. It goes on and on, mixing inane questions with highly detailed inquiries about your financial affairs. One can only imagine the countless malevolent ways our federal bureaucrats could use this information. At the very least the survey will be used to dole out pork, which is reason enough to oppose it.

Keep in mind the survey is not voluntary, nor is the Census Bureau asking politely. Americans are legally obligated to answer, and can be fined up to $1,000 per question if they refuse!

------------------------------------------------
"RON PAUL SUPPORTER SINCE 1997"
RON PAUL 2008 / RE-ELECT 2012

Are illegal aliens also

Are illegal aliens also legally obligated to answer?

Or do they get a free ride?

great question

illegals WOULD BENEFIT THE NAU, so i would guess free ride. take it easy
------------------------------------------------
"RON PAUL SUPPORTER SINCE 1997"
RON PAUL 2008 / RE-ELECT 2012

Uh!

Just wanted to quote this part:

"Keep in mind the survey is not voluntary, nor is the Census Bureau asking politely. Americans are legally obligated to answer, and can be fined up to $1,000 per question if they refuse!"

So how many questions are on a 24 pages?

Lets say 12 questions x 24 pages = 288 x $1000 = $288,000

Just about enough to take your house away.

:)

Illegal Aliens Count

Did you know that illegal aliens and foreign citizens are counted/estimated in the census? All people in the US are counted regardless of citizenship.

But here's the problem, guess what the census is used for?

It's used to determine the number of representatives and delegates.

So, the more illegals that can come across the border in California, New Mexico, Arizona, and Texas, the more representatives those states can get - they probably look at illegals as important population growth and maybe that's one reason McCain supports Amnesty.

The "anything goes" Thread

http://www.dailypaul.com/...

You will notice that people start to keep a single topic thread going.

The Iranian Bourse was one, the Liberty Harvest/gardening thread (deleted twice already??), etc.

Today, people have tried to get single threads for Barr and for Baldwin.

People have also requested the same be done for FLDS discussions.

That way formal admin actions to create separate forums isn't necessary, but you can find/follow the single thread for weeks.

great question

I'm glad you did not put this in the anything goes THREAD, i would have never found it in there.

------------------------------------------------
"RON PAUL SUPPORTER SINCE 1997"
RON PAUL 2008 / RE-ELECT 2012

Don't rock the boat unless it means something

Fill out the form to the extent you're legally required...which is the total number of people residing in your home and return the rest blank. There's nothing else they have the right to know.

Don't throw it away or ignore it...it's a damn good way to ensure the government will annoy you further. Beaurocrats don't like being ignored, and not only will you probably get a follow up visit from the Census Nazi's, but those slimes probably have the IRS, ATF, CPS, etc. on their speed dial.

Picture this...a lot of agencies are more than within their rights to begin a file on you...begin to harrass you. Don't give them a reason to.

I know it may offend your sense of freedom, but know this about beaurocrats...they may not make much money, may not have much power, but one power they certainly have is to really annoy you and make your life a living hell.

Pick your battles wisely.

if ALL of us just ignored

if ALL of us just ignored them what could they do?? the constitution says a census every 10 years.. only to count the number of people... not incomes or personal information,,, SCREW EM!

as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD

I don't think we should

I think the feds should be able to count the number of people living in this country...it helps with districting, and is entirely necessary to determine the number of Representatives each state gets in congress. It's an invaluable tool if we are to live in a Republic. I don't think the census should be ignored. I will give them how many people and ages who live in my house.

It is none of their business, however, the names, incomes, race, or anything else who lives in my house. I'll happily tell them 2 adults and 1 child live here...but that's all they need to know. If you think it's meaningless data, please research "Japanese internment camp".

Don't ignore the census, give them the data they actually need.

Ignoring them completely is better than...

...sending incomplete information. Whether the Census Nazi's follow up or not is entirely dependent upon whether your particular Census Nazi is either too bored or too motivated. Receiving "incomplete" information seems more likely to trigger motivation, than receiving nothing at all. Such most likely being the case, "ignore 'em" still seems like very sound advice. Sleeping dogs come to mind.....

http://groups.yahoo.com/g...

Very good point

Yes...someone who knows their rights is a thorn in the side...but knowing these folks...you will get 1-2 follow up letters if you ignore the first one, and if you ignore those, you will have a beaurocrat on your porch. They are persistant people.

Yeah, but that's months later (if ever).

And if they ever DO manage to get up off their overpaid bureaucratic asses and actually show up "on your porch", all you should do is give them the one number for which they're Constitutionally-authorized to ask - and NOTHING else. Persistence works both ways......

http://groups.yahoo.com/g...

water sprinkler

if/when they come to your door do you have to give your name?, show id? or just say the number 1234 and shut the door... and turn on the water sprinkler.
------------------------------------------------
"RON PAUL SUPPORTER SINCE 1997"
RON PAUL 2008 / RE-ELECT 2012

Unless they send the form

by registered mail,how can they
prove you even got it?

Maybe you can ask this question as well

If the IRS didn't have any witnesses that you got paid X amount of dollars in 2005, how can they prove you worked?

Answer is the same...they don't have to prove it.

Required by which law?

If the relevant statute is not given so you can look it up for yourself then it's just a way to scare you. Otherwise I would just toss it. The IRS used to send me letters saying they were updating their files and requested that I sign under penalty of perjury that my address was correct. I figured that since it was delivered to my place of residence, their files don't need updating. I threw it out every time. If they really wanted to verify my address they could come and knock on my door. It hasn't happened.

still lol

"I figured that since it was delivered to my place of residence, their files don't need updating."

now thats funny!
------------------------------------------------
"RON PAUL SUPPORTER SINCE 1997"
RON PAUL 2008 / RE-ELECT 2012

You may want to consider following the procedure that I

have used since 1980. Under Title 5, Sec. 552a, a citizen of the U.S. is authorized by federal law to conduct an investigation into any inquiry regarding information being sought from that citizen. You can find the questionaire at:

http://www.patriotnetwork...

You might also consider asking the public servant if he or she:

1. Has any children
2. What are their names and ages?
3. Where do they go to school?

Wait till you see the chilling effect that has on the census taker.

Every time I've ever used it, the census taker goes off for a few hours and then comes back and says that they only need to know how many people are living in my house.......which is their only constitutional obligation. I give them a number, they thank me and they leave. Yes, I get the long form every time. No, I do not fill it out. The Census folks tell you that there has never been an "unauthorized" release of census information. What does that tell you? They do conduct "authorized" releases of census information.

"The individual may stand upon his constitutional rights as a citizen. He is entitled to carry on his private business in his own way. His power to contract is unlimited. He owes no duty to the state or to his neighbors to divulge his business, or to open his doors to an investigation, so far as it may tend to criminate him. He owes no such duty to the state, since he receives nothing therefrom, beyond the protection of his life and property. His rights are such as existed by the law of the land long antecedent to the organization of the state, and can only be taken from him by due process of law, and in accordance with the Constitution. Among his rights are a refusal to incriminate himself, and the immunity of himself and his property from arrest or seizure except under a warrant of the law. He owes nothing to the public so long as he does not trespass upon their rights. " Hale :vs: Henkel 201 U.S. 43 (1906)

Do right and fear not.

excellent! thank you! i

excellent! thank you! i ignored the business survey, and the farm or ranch one.. it would take me hours to fill out and its none of their business.. I pay ALL my taxes and thje IRS knows me better than my wife! if they want the info the IRS has it so SCREW EM! now with this questionaire i hope they do show up lol!

as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD

great info, thank you

------------------------------------------------
"RON PAUL SUPPORTER SINCE 1997"
RON PAUL 2008 / RE-ELECT 2012

I told my wife about this

I told my wife about this and she seems to think that King Herod must be looking for Baby Jesus.

How odd but so appropriate a thought.

Things are only impossible until they are not.
-- Jean Luc Picard

Ignore it.

And if they ever come to your door to follow up, simply tell them the number of people living there and THAT'S ALL. The Constitution gives them the authority to ask that ONE question - nothing more. And even if you refuse to answer that ONE question, there's almost zero chance that they'd try to prosecute you. See: http://tinyurl.com/33x9xa

http://groups.yahoo.com/g...

The Law is Irrelevant

The Senseless Bureau is only Constitutionally authorized to enquire after the number of living humans in your household. All other questions are void. Write down the appropriate number (during decennial census years only) and leave the rest of it unmarked.

Sic Semper Tyrannis!
Professor Bernardo de la Paz

I know people who managed to

I know people who managed to dodge it. Might be a bit risky though.

I made

a comment futher down. Forgot to mention I never got a form myself in 1990. My address was'nt even on the map. Correcting and adding new addresses to the maps is one of the phases of the cencus.(Idid'nt do that part in my area 1990) My whole area was messed up and my house was built late 60s early 70s lol. back then you hade a map that looked like it was drawn from an airplane flying over on a grocery bag you had to peice together and a name about every 10 homes. I live in a rural area and had to get a 78 yr old man who grew up out here to go with me to make any sense of it.

what about a return to

what about a return to sender stamp on it?
I fear I could easily foul something up and instantly get accused of lying or attempting to commit fraud?

I worked for the Census

They are not supposed to have anything to do with the IRS. Some of the questions are voluntary. There are legitimate reasons for many of the questions. Income is for the government to figure out what kind of services and programs are needed in a given community.I've worked in many aspects of the field operations area of the census. I'ts just a temporary job once every 10 yrs.(they start earlier with the sort of thing you recieved. (kind of like testing the waters to see how deep) In the past I really did'nt see anything harmful that could come of answering the questions. But in light or things these days I'm not so sure. Everyone used to wonder why they wanted to know about spanish heritage. Seemed like every other question was about it.But remember they were considering making spanish a required course in school? Or maybe they were trying to keep up with immigration. The money questions kind of make sense too if you think about community assistance programs.How far you drive to work and such, Traffic control?? If you really think about it there are many reasons this information could be important in a free society to help all of us.I just think it should be kept on a community or state level except for the head count. Just remember when someone knocks on your door it is probably someone just like me. trying to make a little extra money ,with a temporary job. Not a government spy or new world order police. Most of the people who work for the cencus could care less. They are regular folks. Just trying to do their job for one of the most poorly run. unorganized, inaccurate mess.All you have to do to get the higher paid positions is show up first and act like you know something. Oh, and if you get in early bring a good book because the government is so slow in training people and getting the materials in to get started you will need something to do. I worked in the office some. I reccomend feild work. Nothing worse than working with a bunch of morons who have no idea what they are doing trying to act like they do. I did it in 1990 and 2000 and I think I was the only one that had a clue in 2000 So when I tried to assist some egos got bruised. I begged for a job in the field. I never met so many screwed up people in one building in my life. I guess what I'm trying to say is do'nt be too paranoid about the cencus. if you think a question is too personal tell them so. If you get it in the mail leave that question blank.(they may send someone to follow up but it depends on the question. I've never known anyone to go to jail or be fined for not cooperating. in the past if we could'nt find someone home after a few tries we'd try to ask a neighbor a few question(how accurate is that?) Remember they even took a cencus in the biblical times.But who knows these days there my be something in the patriot act or hls which makes it a crime punishable by death . I know people used to lie to us when we asked them the questions but we had to write down what they said. There would be a whole family with blonde hair and blue eyes that would say they were all mexican. lol Oh, when I was a crew leader for feild operations on of my cencus takers had someone pull a gun on him. he quit and I think the higher ups sent someone else out with the police. If I remember correctly (do'nt me to it) all they did was ask him nicely how many people lived there and told him that the young man was a census taker not a trespasser. I do'nt believe there were any charges filed. I'm not sure but the man with the gun was within his rights was'nt he? Anyway just somthing to chew on. it was'nt that big a deal back then but I have not seen the form this go around. I did however get an agriculture census form. Ignored it. Threw about 3 away. Then they kept calling so I answered the questions vaguely.

I don't know, maybe you just

I don't know, maybe you just didn't get it. You know how bad the P.O. is :)

lol

it happens all the time....

http://www.dailypaul.com/...

------------------------------------------------
"RON PAUL SUPPORTER SINCE 1997"
RON PAUL 2008 / RE-ELECT 2012

Interesting

Thanks for the link.