SILVER SHORTAGE? You got to be kidding me OR ELSE THERE IS NO HOPE
I highly suspect that the talk of silver shortage is a manipulation by greedy silver longs, or else I don't think there is any hope for honest money by using silver. Think about it. If the silver shortage is real and silver is so scarce, how can silver function as money? If the silver shortage is real, it justifies a money system that is NOT backed by silver and also gold because they are too scarce to function as money, in my opinion. Sure, the silver shortage could be real, but it won't help the argument that money should be backed by gold and silver, in my opinion.
output



















Bullion Direct
Razorwind Studios is an official endorser of Ron Paul, and we will live free or die! 14th alternate to MN state!
--------------------------------------------------
Just got an email today that they shipped my order of 100 x 1oz bars. I ordered last sunday.
Sometimes it's a guessing game.
Whether or not there is a shortage of silver is a guessing game. One way that there could be a shortage would be if mining companies haven't been honest with their reporting of production. One way of doing so is to claim silver findings as actual silver production. Many times companies do exploration and sell prospective silver deposits to banks as a way to raise cash without actually producing the metal. Hard to say???
One thing for sure is that we know that there is no shortage of copper, which is what a current $1 dollar coin is minted with. With anual copper mining at around 6,800.000 tons a year there is plenty of room to mint copper dollars, and with annual silver production claimed to be at around 9000 tons a year makes for a ratio of close to 700 ounces of copper produce to each ounce of silver.
With less demand for copper from new home construction and wireless phone system ect... Copper may be the new standard for government coins. 700 coppers to a silver and 70 silvers to a gold.
Coins by the way do not have to be borrowed by the government for the issuing of FRNs.
FRNs on the other hand we know there is no shortage of paper or ink, but should one occur there are recycling methods which could easily change a $1 dollar bill into a $100 or $1000 dollar bill, seen it happen in Brazil.
Now as for electric currency there is no limit to how many zero's are possilble to add.
grant
There is a shortage...
Just go to your local bullion dealer and ask him to sell you 1000 or even 100 ounces of silver sometime. Many dealers are taking orders and filling them later. Examples are: http:\\www.kitco.com where their website has now posted large RED letters stating delays. Our local dealer cannot keep bulk bullion in stock at all these days. Amark has an 8 week turnaround I am told. A VERY LARGE dealer in California has a 12 week delay for shipping.
Call me, I've got silver...
Silver
Peace Dollars 15
100 oz. JM/ENG spot+1.25 long delay
100 Generic spot+.70
Can Silver Maples spot+1.90
American Silver Eagles NA
1oz. Generic Rounds spot +1.25
Generic 10 oz. Silver Bars spot +1.00
1-800-627-3015
Ext. 2317
Chad Lang
Stanford Coin & Bullion
Once again, it is not a
Once again, it is not a physical shortage of silver, although for the last 12 to 15 years demand has outstripped supply, it is a shortage of refinement, it is just more profitable for refiners to process gold than to process silver. I mean what would you choose, more profits to supply the demand for gold or less profits to supply the demand for silver?
read butler he will show you
read butler he will show you beyond a shadow of a doubt where your wrong...
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
As I have told you, I have
As I have told you, I have read Butler...if you check the other postings I have replied to you about the fact that even Butler is stating there is a retail shortage. Read him again. There has been an ongoing deficit in the supply and demand of silver for the last 12 to 15 years, we always go through the same thing when the price of gold rises because it is much more profitable for refiners to refine gold than it is to refine silver. That is why the markets are not reacting to the shortage in coins, because that is exactly what it is, a shortage of coin refined silver going to mint.
wrong you have not read
wrong you have not read butler... the defecit between consumption and production has been going on much longer then 12-15 years.. don't blow smoke at me.. READ BUTLER NOWHERE DOES HE TALK ABOUT IT BEING MORE PROFITABLE TO REFINE GOLD THEN SILVER.. I am one guy you cannot quote butler and be wrong.. you have not read butler!
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
I beg your pardon, but I
I beg your pardon, but I have read Butler:
The Smoking Gun
Lessons of a Lifetime
The Real Speculators
Shelter from the Storm
The Hidden Silver Default
etc, etc, etc....
"the sad truth is that we are in the midst of the greatest shortfall of a commodity that the world has ever seen and that we will run out of all legitimate world inventories of silver in the time suggested.The world will run out of silver completely in 4 years, while CPM's figures indicate 3 years." TED BUTLER in 1997
Now, go back 8 years, even 10 years ago and read Butler....tell me what he said then and tell me what he is saying now? Strangely, he seems to be saying the same thing over and over again while making tons of money doing it...
Could it be that the price is a leading indicator?
Perhaps, there used to be a shortage at the industry level and perhaps we are now seeing the shortage at the retail level after a certain pipleline delay. Meanwhile, maybe the shortage has corrected at the industry level and perhaps that is why the price is significantly below the recent peak. Of course, these are just my guesses and I really don't know what's going on.
In any case, based on what I saw on the net, it does't seem like coin dealers are willing to pay higher prices to buy silver even if they don't have any to sell. So, this also seems to indicate that they are not expecting the shortage to last for a very long time if there is one.
Another thing that scares me is this chart. It's a chart of gold, but silver is also about the same. It's not that I understand Elliot wave theory, but I see 5 waves starting 2001. This could be bad or could mean nothing.
http://www.the-privateer....
The bottomline to me is that I have no clue what will happen to the price of silver or gold and this is too risky for me unless the price goes down even more.
I wish someone had a good explanation without sounding like a high pressure used car salesman.
In any care, the silver shortage if it exists is a disappointment for me because I was hoping for silver to become an official money again someday, but if it's so scarce, there would be no such hope, in my opinion.
Try this
Call your local coin dealer or visit and try to buy a Silver Eagle. Hope you try it and report back to us!!! Try to buy a Gold Eagle lately?
They why not find out and call for delivery?
Not necessarily, silver can also be based on projected production. For example a mining company discovers a deposit of silver and estimates the load, but doesn't necessarily extract the product. They can use this to sell on the market.
grant
What happened in 1989 to silver??
Silver was a loser from 1989 to 2003 - does anyone have charts longer then 20 years? Silver has only gained (from 1989 value) since 2003, why is this? I was under the impression that monetary metals hold there value, but this chart shows otherwise, except since from 2003 forward, can someone please explain this to me?? Did the price just finally catch up in 2003?? I have recently started buying silver and am looking for answers.
http://www.maoxian.com/im...
(I did post this on another topic but didn't really receive much input so I figured I would try here.
Is this what you are looking for?
http://www.futuresbuzz.co...
This site also has some interesting charts.
http://www.the-privateer....
because the US government
because the US government was dumping there surplus silver on the market thus depressing the price.. in 2003 the us mint had to go on the open market to purchase silver to make the silver eagle.. it was about 2003 when the huge surplus of US silver ran out.. plus the fact that the dollar was losing value/weakning/ the fed printing money!
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
Kitco has charts.
That chart shows the spot price of silver -- that's all. Holding value and the spot price are two different things.
___________
Lisa C.
www.dvds4delegates.com=Ron Paul, the 44th U.S. President
Join us at: www.campaignforliberty.com
Brought to you by: www.women4ronpaul.com
THE EAGLE HAS BEEN GROUNDED..
BUT there is no shortage! that just makes me laugh!
http://stevequayle.com/Ne...
now the panic buying is starting. and this "panic"buying is only by a small fraction of a percent of the US population does that tell you how small the supply is!.. so where is the price going!
WAKE UP FOLKS!
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
The new silver - made with
The new silver - made with paper
By The Mogambo Guru
Things are so weird lately that I nervously put a new layer of aluminum foil on the ceiling and walls of the Fabulous Mogambo Bunker (FMB) in another pathetic attempt to keep what I assume are Government Stupid Rays (GSR) from being beamed into my brain, too, as things are getting Really, Really Weird (RRW) out there.
The weirdest thing of the whole week was that gold and silver suddenly collapsed in price when they should have been zooming to the freaking moon in response to the inflationary and deflationary horrors that are appearing everywhere. And you
should have seen the gold lease rates jerking around on Monday! Weird!
Many other people are likewise perplexed at this bizarre event, so it ISN'T just a change for me, given that many people have noticed that there is almost no silver for sale, and there are plenty of people who want to buy some, and when they do find some for sale, they find that the asking price is way, way, WAY above the spot price of silver! So that's something else weird!
So perhaps it is not just coincidental that Chris Powell of GATA.org posted the headline "US Mint Suspends Gold Coin Sales", by which he means the news that "The US Mint has suspended sales of American Eagle gold coins."
Mr Powell figures that "the suspension is overwhelming evidence that the futures contract price of gold on the commodities exchanges is substantially below the physical market price and that, indeed, the commodities exchanges are being used as GATA long has maintained - as part of a massive scheme of manipulation of the precious metals, currency, and bond markets," which is not really all that much news, as the International Monetary Fund, Bank for International Settlements, US Treasury, European Central Bank and US Federal Reserve officials have all long ago acknowledged that they do, and will do, these kinds of things any time they want.
The result is that "the Western central banks, desperate to prop up a corrupt and tottering financial system, have put gold so much on sale that even the US Mint can't find any now", as nobody is stupid enough to sell their gold, or silver, at these low prices! Wow!
But the question on my trembling lips remains, "Regardless of why silver went down by so much so fast, why did it go down at all?"
Jason Hommel of silverstockreport.com explains, "Many people agree there is a shortage of retail investor silver, but they get confused by the lower price. They think a lower price means more silver must have come into the market."
I naturally leap to my feet and exclaim, "Well, if one looks at the classical supply/demand dynamic, where the supply curve meeting the demand curve determines the price, then, yes; silver supply MUST have come onto the market to swamp demand, making the price go down! That's the way things work! Everybody knows that! Do I look like I am stupid or something? Is that what you are saying? You're saying I'm stupid, like I don't understand supply and demand or something? Is that what you are saying, punk?"
Well, I could see Mr Hommel struggling to contain himself, as bitter experience has shown that everyone is always happy to tell me that, yes, I look stupid, and not only that, but I sound stupid, I act stupid, I am stupid, and I smell funny, which must be the fabled "smell of stupid", which must be (also learned by bitter experience) also something of a babe-repellent, looking back on it all after all these years.
Instead, perhaps taking pity on me and my many, many personal problems in the areas of looking, sounding, being, acting and smelling, he says through gritted teeth, "That is not how our markets work."
Of course, I figure that he is arguing with me! Happily argumentative, I retort, "Wrong-o! That's how ALL markets work; price equilibrates demand and supply so that they equal each other!"
I was feeling pretty smug about this time, because if there is one thing I know for sure, it is that the prices going up and down make demand equal supply. So, thinking that I had finally, at last, bested Mr Hommel in an argument, I sat down with a cruel, sadistic grin on my face, crossed my arms in self-satisfaction, and thought, "Touche!"
My comeuppance was, as usual, not long in coming, and almost instantly I see where he had cleverly maneuvered me into revealing that everybody is right; I really AM stupid! He wasn't taking about silver bullion at all! He was talking about paper promises to deliver silver!
With my face burning in embarrassment at how easily I was duped, I could feel Mr Hommel's eyes burning into me as he said, "Our markets are affected by paper silver futures contracts, and very few people ever attempt to take delivery of that silver; they buy it on leverage, for the investment returns, not for real silver. So, some people can sell 'silver promises' to excess, and never deliver, and if they sell more 'paper silver' than exists, that can manipulate the price."
This is entirely congruent with SeekingAlpha.com blaring the headline "The Disconnect Between Supply and Demand in Gold & Silver Markets". They explain that "western markets are, with the exception of some fabrication and industrial demand, almost 90% paper based", which is making it very easy for the world's bullion banks to affect the price of silver by "managing deliveries of physical gold and silver to artificially reduce the quantities delivered", which they do by restricting credit to buy gold.
Then, out of nowhere, in one of those flashes that sometimes determines the course of history, I instantly decide that Mr Hommel, explaining the business plan of "sell 'silver promises' to excess, and never deliver", was too good a deal to pass up! I immediately went into the silver business!
Within a matter of mere seconds, with a fanfare of trumpets I proudly introduced the new Mogambo Silver Service (MSS) - a trusted, old-line firm, founded by God-fearing Pilgrims when they stepped off the Mayflower onto Plymouth Rock and said, "This looks like a good rock to step on to get off of this damned boat!"
So, from now on, if you ever want to buy some silver, MSS will sell it to you at the lowest price possible; the spot price! All you have to do is just send the money to me, in cash, in a plain brown envelope addressed to "Occupant", and I will gladly send you a piece of paper that says I sold you some silver.
And this is real paper silver, too, made with real paper! With a stamp and everything, but without any fingerprints or DNA anywhere on the paper, the envelope or the stamp, so don't bother looking, as I am waaaAAAAaaay ahead of you and your ill-tempered prosecuting attorneys!
And the ugly lesson is; you thought that the fraud of naked short selling was only for stocks? Hahaha! Wrong! It's every-freaking-where! Hahaha!
And when you have that kind of pandemic, systemic corruption, created by greedy people exploiting inattentive regulators and complicit government, and financed by the damnable Federal Reserve creating all the money and credit to pay for it all, then you are 100% right to be buying silver and gold to protect yourself against the inflation in prices and economic calamity that are sure to follow.
Your only mistake was to not take delivery of the actual silver, but instead taking a flimsy piece of paper.
And even if the "paper promise" to deliver silver is not from Mogambo Silver Service (MSS), then it is almost certainly something of equal value when one considers that more silver has been "sold" in paper promises than the amount of silver that actually exists in the world! Hahahaha!
Richard Daughty is general partner and COO for Smith Consultant Group, serving the financial and medical communities, and the editor of The Mogambo Guru economic newsletter - an avocational exercise to heap disrespect on those who desperately deserve it.
(Republished with permission from The Daily Reckoning
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
When mentioning
the weirdest thing about the whole week he doesn't even mention the close call in Russia which by itself should have seen gold and silver go way, way up. He is right, something is really weird.
and that situation with
and that situation with Russia and Georgia isn't even close to being resolved!
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
Confiscation Prep
Step One: Fake a physical shortage
Step Two: Call in metals (due to "shortage")
Step Three: Profit
I think what we're seeing is an immediate precursor to a confiscation.
Disclaimer: I am not an expert in metals, history or economics. I therefore serve this up with a nice, tasty grain of salt, with recognition that you silver and gold bugs have likely already thought of this, and I'm just slow on the uptake.
That being said...consider:
A physical silver shortage, not a true physical shortage on the planet, but, a manipulated buy-and-hold by powers that be in order to create the illusion of a physical shortage; combined with prices falsely manipulated to remain (and fall) low (and lower), in order to give an impression that silver just really isn't all that valuable
Resulting in:
(a) people selling off the silver they've so far collected in an effort to cut their losses before the price of silver (and therefore their investment) goes down any further, thus releasing physical silver back into the market to be bought back up and held by PTB to further the illusion of scarcity - see above;
and/or
(b) the few people who see the current low price for the bargain that it is, snap up as much of it as they can
Suddenly, a silver and/or gold call-in is made, a la gold in 1933 and silver in 1934. Why for the metals call-in? Why, there's a "shortage" of the physical stuff, Citizen. You're a patriotic American, so turn in your metals to help your country. Or else. All your metals are belong to us. And belong to us means, them that don't turn in the metals will receive visits from agents who will be happy to help you find your metals to turn in.
"Step Three: Profit" -- your metals go to pay off our dear friends and neighbors like China, etc., so they'll still play nice with us. See? No new taxes! We just take what we need or want by decree, and do with it as we please.
According to Ron Paul, the power to confiscate gold is still on the books as the law of the land. We know that with the flick of a pen, silver can and likely will be thrown in with that order (if it's not already on the books). And just because Roosevelt limited the confiscations to non-collectibles does not mean that the same limitations would necessarily apply in a new nationwide theft of the people's metals.
Historically, governments have banned the ownership of gold when their citizens lose confidence in government issued paper money (reference). I suspect our (individual people's) wealth is about to go to pay off legal and not-quite-so-legal agreements those in our government have made with others around the world.
Will we get something in return for our metals? I suspect it will be either the Amero (ha ha) or simply nothing (value: same as Amero).
I think the physical silver shortage may be very real, but NOT because there's a very real physical shortage of silver.
(Did I just spend this whole comment stating the obvious? If so, I apologize.)
Fan, If the government
Fan,
If the government stooped to trying to conficate gold like FDR did... how many people do you think would actually do it.. turn it in.. people are different today then they were in1930's.. why are we here at the DP! WE DON'T TRUST THE GOVERNMENT! they do not have enough agents/time or money to try to confiscate!
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
You're right, folks probably wouldn't voluntarily turn it in
(Although every April 15th...)
I don't know whether they have enough agents/time to confiscate, but there sure are a lot of empty barbed-wired camps just sitting around, too...I'm looking at all the puzzle pieces "holistically" rather than categorizing issues as separate entities. I make no claim for having the answers here!
Don't worry -- I will try again with Ted's book!! ;)
have you read butlers
have you read butlers research on the shortage'
he explains it.. again someone telling there own "theory".. fanofwalt! please read ted butlers ebook.. it is free--- 61 pages it will disprove your theory.. I'm saying this not tell you your "dumb" or don not know what your talking about. just read his book and then dispute the facts.. this shortage is not made up! it is th result of a manipulation in the paper market area of silver that kept the price down for so long, the the surplus of silver once in stock pile has been depleted.. the only way supply and demand comes back into line is with sharply higher prices! when miners can mine profitably again! please read butlers ebook.. look at his track record! your going to miss out if you have not already! www.investmentrarities.co...
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
Thanks, Sierra
To clarify, I am in no way against buying metals!!!! Just trying to piece together all the puzzle parts as best I can.
And please do feel free to tell me that I don't know what I'm talking about in this subject, because it's quite true (see? Dumb, but honest!) While I hope to believe I have an IQ slightly higher than a cucumber, the fact is that I still find discussions re: paper markets and "long" and "short" and all of that rather confusing. I find myself saying "huh?" a lot when I read comments from many DP folks learned in those areas. Still, I try to look through the mists and see if I'm on the right track. From what you say, I guess at least this time, it's "Thank you for playing; here's a nice consolation prize." I take it in good stead, Sierra. :)
I did start reading Ted Butler some time ago -- per your urging! -- but my eyes crossed and a glazed look fell upon my face after a piece...I think I need "Silver Education for Dummies."
Great; now people are gonna whisper, "Poor ol' fanofwalt musta got a lobotomy; this stuff isn't that hard to understand!" Like I said...steep learning curve yet looms.
: Adds Ted's book back into pile of Stuff I Really Gotta Learn, And Quick! :
Fan it took me 5 times of
Fan it took me 5 times of reading butlers book till I understood what he was saying i was in the same boat as you till spring of 03! thats when I got his book and studied it.. do it quickly!
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
I work at Stanford Coin & bullion...
Yes there are many shortages that are starting simply from people buying not only at the tops, but on the bottoms too. Here are the statistics of the United States...
U.S. annual gross domestic product is about $15 trillion
U.S. money supply is also about $15 trillion
Current proposed U.S. federal budget is $3 trillion
U.S. government's maximum legal debt is $9 trillion
U.S. mutual fund companies manage about $12 trillion
World's GDPs for all nations is approximately $50 trillion
Unfunded Social Security and Medicare benefits $50 trillion to $65 trillion
Total value of the world's real estate is estimated at about $75 trillion
Total value of world's stock and bond markets is more than $100 trillion
BIS valuation of world's derivatives back in 2002 was about $100 trillion
BIS 2007 valuation of the world's derivatives is now a whopping $516 trillion
Moreover, the folks at BIS say their estimate of $516 trillion only includes "transactions in which a major private dealer (bank) is involved on at least one side of the transaction," but doesn't include private deals between two "non-reporting entities." They did, however, add that their reporting central banks estimate that the coverage of the survey is around 95% on average.
Now the biggest bubble in the world is the US Dollar. So knowing that where is money going to flow. Something you can't cheat. The marketplace is starting to understand this, and just like any person with money the are protecting themselves. Your greed silver longs is pure ignorance, and you should be talking about greedy politicians that have created this. Also factor in manipulation if you can handle it. Silver and Gold have been long ignored and the supply has not expanded as a result from 1930 levels. What is your other choice if not gold or silver?
carefull kagiman! when you
carefull kagiman! when you speak truth they will attack you! the next thing you will see is that you work for a dealer so your seving your own best interest! great post. but these naysayers will ever get it.. besides its to late to get it... silver has done left the train station and they missed the train!
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
First, think about this,
First, think about this, like gold, silver, while they can be consumed throughout the economy in various forms, the truth of the matter is that both are considered recoverable resources. The massive amount of silver, for instance, is still in coin form, much of which is in private ownership. However, concerning the supposed shortage think about this, back in March of this year the Silver Wheaton Mines reported that their present reserves had increased in one year by 239% to 346.4 Million ounces, then they inferred that these resource increased another 48% making their total known reserves around 416.9 Million ounces.
Pan Silver Mine announced earlier this year that their known reserves were 227.8 million ounces. I could go on an on about the massive amount of silver reserves around the world, even gold known and probable reserves are very high
Now folks, this is just a couple of mines, there are indications that the known reserves from known sources are astronomical. Also, it is important to understand, particularly when referring to gold in our Treasury Reserves, that those ounces are valued under U.S. Code Title 31-5116 and 5117 (statutory rates) as $42.2222 per Fine Troy Ounce of Gold Bullion and at $1.292929292 per Fine Troy Ounce of Silver Bullion.
It is also important to know that at times there is a lot of short covering, particularly f there is a tremendous amount of “leased” silver in the pipeline and the “lessors” are not prepared to take delivery, so in such cases you will see what looks like “shortages” and silver prices should therefore, begin a rapid rise in prices due to the perceived “shortgage”, but that is not happening, if such a “shortgage” was real, then silver would not be trading around $13.00 per ounce, but more like $25 to $50 per ounce. It is always important to interpret such things correctly, particularly if you are trading in silver. Rumor-mongering about either present or future silver shortages are usually the prime “mover’ in such markets, but rarely do such rumors pan out, especially due to the fact that actual known and probable reserves are so high.
So, keep this all in mind when you hear about “shortages” and remember there are a tremedous number of "Texas Hedges" going on in all markets today, but such hedges rarely diminsh risks they only increase them.
In regards to mining
In regards to mining companies reporting on their reserves, any idea what their margin of error is?
Or rather, how accurate are they in predicting the quantity of metal in the ground?
do me a favor.. prove what
do me a favor.. prove what you say.. just don't spout assumptions! I want you to go to the US geolical survey.. see what they say about how many years of mining are left to mine silver... 13 years supply left and you think there is a lot of silver left in the world.. now that is from the US geological survey! the other problem you have is ALL of that silver you are talking about is CONSUMED! IT IS USED.. JUST LIKE A PAPER TOWEL THAT YOU USE AND THROW AWAY! silver is unlike gold in this manner.
the world CONSUMES 1 BILLION OUNCES OF SILVER PER YEAR!
HOW MUCH IS MINED? 600 million ounces in production per year plus recycling of 200 million ounces.. that a 200 million ounce defeciet for the past 3 decades! the silver stock pile was consumed when silver was low in price under 10.00 per ounce it was not worth it to mine because there was no profit in it! the only silver that came to market was byproduct mining from lead, zinc, gold, copper etc! even now at 18.00 per ounce the silver miners are not making money because of inflation the costs of mining have gone up! AGAIN! there is a shortage it is FACT! Butler has been calling for this for 8 years now! it is finally now coming.. If you think your staement above is true! then do this.. go download Butlers free ebook.. at www.investmentrarities.co... it is 61 pages! this will answer your questions much better then I could! if you can disprove what he says I'll buy you a steak dinner!
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
Do you have a link on the US
Do you have a link on the US Geological Survey website that details the info on 13 years of silver left? Their main website is www.usgs.gov - I've been searching a while for the info but could not find it. The best I could drum up is http://www.safehaven.ca/s...
I did come across something very interesting, though, on the USGS website:
Government Stockpile: All of the remaining silver in the National Defense Stockpile was transferred to the U.S. Mint by the Defense Logistics Agency for use in the manufacture of numismatic and bullion coins by yearend 2004. This transfer marked the end of silver requirements for the National Defense Stockpile.
I read that statement in the following document: http://minerals.usgs.gov/...
So, that means the National Defense Stockpile has zero silver? And considering the mint stopping production of silver coins a while back due to supply issues.... Well... maybe the shortage is actually real.
Interesting, john. That's how I read it too.
___________
Lisa C.
www.dvds4delegates.com=Ron Paul, the 44th U.S. President
Join us at: www.campaignforliberty.com
Brought to you by: www.women4ronpaul.com
I have read Butler's
I have read Butler's book....The market is always a tell-tail sign of what is going on in a particular commodity. Thus I have not seen this market act as though it is experiencing or expecting a real shortage. Of course, I do have my "market order" in when silver hits a certain price level over resistance.
Silver is not unlike gold, when it is consumed there is, according to the U.S. Geological Survey that you quoted, a very high amount that is recovered each year.
I haven’t made assumptions, any more than you have. Plus, we need to know the difference between a physical shortage and an economic shortage. Currently there are about 600 million ounces mined in this country each year. I you remember, something very similar happened at the end of last year, I think it was around Septemeber. This is a “paper-short” shortage and doesn’t have a thing to do with a physical shortage otherwise we would be seeing a massive hike in market prices, especially futures prices. There doesn’t seem to be a single shortage of promises of future deliveries in silver therefore, it appears that there is a shortage, but not the type that you are talking about. While there may be physical limitations, at this point, to the mining production of silver in this and other countries, that does no preclude the fact that future improvements on mining techniques will increase known reserves and uncover unknown deposits. Remember, there is a huge difference between known reserves and deposits. There are now over 20 undeveloped major deposits around the world that have enormous supplies of silver, one being the undeveloped Penasquito area in Mexico with estimates of nearly 1 Billion ounces of silver and 14 million ounces of gold. In British Columbia alone deposits are estimated at a couple of billion ounces of silver.
The market responses to shortages in a very particular manner, and you will notice real shortages almost immediately and you will also notice the severity of a shortage. The first stage of a shortage will produce prices, as I said around $25 to $50 per ounce, the next stage of an even more severe shortage will produce prices of between $50 to $75 per ounce, now, if it is a real physical shortage then you should see prices shoot over $100 per once. This does not take into account inflation hedges.
In 2007 over 1200 metric tons of silver were domestically produced, with estimates of over 1600 metric tons of “Consumed” recovered silver, ccording to the U.S. Department of Interior and the U.S. Geological Survey. The U.S. Reserve Base of silver is over 80,000 metric tons of silver and global reserves are approximately 570,000 metric tons of silver. While there has been a deficit in terms of mining production verses consumption, that has not diminished the fact that there are huge amounts of known and probable reserves around the world.
BETTER BUY WHILE YOU CAN!
Silver has Run Out, Now!
(Just try to find some!)
Silver Stock Report
by Jason Hommel, August 20th, 2008
For a long time, people have been asking me, "When will silver run out?". They know that the world uses up more silver each year (about 850 million ounces) than the world mines (about 600 million ounces), and that existing demand can only be met by selling existing inventory (such as recycling 200 million ounces, or goverments selling 50 million ounces), so it's a natural question to ask. The question is not implying that mankind will be unable to mine any more. Rumor is that there remains at least about 14-16 years of silver in the ground at "current" prices; while at much higher prices, silver mining becomes more economic, and more deposits can be added to that "in ground" reserve number.
So, the question is really just asking, "When will we run out of "excess" above ground silver that can meet the supply/demand gap, so that the price will begin to really take off upwards?" Clearly, the world has silver in supplies above ground, and such silver supplies are dwindling in order to meet the supply/demand gap. About two years ago, the world started adding to above ground silver supplies as silver investors started buying, (and the silver surveys label investor buying as a "surplus". However, silver recycling was still greater than new stockpiling, which continued to deplete overall silver supplies.
Such a question as "When will silver run out?" cannot really be answered in advance, since nobody really knows how much silver there is, and who owns it, and at what price they are willing to sell it. Again, that brings us back to the nature of silver; it's inherantly private wealth, held anonymously. Estimates on "above ground" silver, in refined, deliverable form have ranged from 300 million ounces to 1 billion ounces, to about a high of 4 billion ounces if you include jewelry and flatware, up to 20 billion ounces if you include all forms of silver that have not ended up in landfills, out of the total of 43 billion ounces of silver estimated to have been mined in all of human history. Furthermore, nobody is arguing that the last bit of silver that exists needs to be consumed before the price rises substantially. The question is really about when will all the unwanted silver, in so-called "weak" hands of holders who don't really want it, be sold, to allow the price to rise to meet the majority of the expectations of the remaining wise investors who have planned in advance to actually store up some of the rare stuff.
But finally, I think the answer has arrived. The answer is "NOW!" Silver has run out, now! Or, in other words, most of the cheap silver has run out.
There are two excellent articles on the shortage of Silver that I'd like to bring to your attention if you have not already seen them:
This one is by "seekingalpha", and is very excellent, and very comprehensive.
The Disconnect Between Supply and Demand in Gold & Silver Markets
(August 18th)
http://seekingalpha.com/a...
The article goes over how the silver shortage is also affecting India.
He also covers the paper silver fraud that is commonplace and "standard business practice" in Wall Street brokerage houses.
This next article is short and powerful, and written by a coin dealer:
The Disconnect Between The Physical Gold and 'Paper Contract' Markets
(August 19th)
http://www.numismaster.co...
What's amazing is that last year, net physical silver investment demand was estimated to be about 30-60 million ounces, or about $1 billion worth.
Today, with 90% of the people in the U.S. being concerned about inflation, and a growing awareness of the danger of banks going bankrupt, there ought to be about 90% of the $14,000 billion of money in the banks that should be seeking to buy either some silver, or gold.
So, where do you think silver prices are headed? How can most of $14,000 billion enter a market of $1 billion that is already suffering a shortage, and prices not go up, a lot?
And oh yes, what about that current low price?
There's a short story that goes something like this. A lady wants to buy sausage. There are two butcher shops next to each other, one advertises $1.99/lb., the other advertises $2.99/lb. She goes to the $1.99/lb. shop first. But there's no sausage, they are out. So, she goes across the street, and sees sausage for $2.99/lb., and promptely complains about the price. "Why don't you sell it for $1.99/lb like the other guy?" Butcher answers, "Lady, when I'm out, mine is $1.99/lb, too!"
Price means nothing if you can't get the product. Many people are still sending money to dealers who will take your money, but have no silver, and no idea when they can get it.
Be very, very careful about ordering silver right now. Demand to know exactly when they can deliver. If they can't guarantee delivery within a week or your full money back, then consider that they probably don't have it!
Here's what I suggest. FIND YOUR LOCAL COIN SHOP and go there, in person. Or visit the dealers who are recommended at:
www.find-your-local-coin-...
In fact, now might be a good time to meet up other Silver Stock Report readers.
I suggest that everyone visit their favorite local coin shop on September 1, at 1PM. That's a Monday.
Sincerely,
Jason Hommel
www.find-your-local-coin-...
www.silverstockreport.com
www.miningpedia.com
www.bibleprophesy.org
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
Patriot or Profiteer?
Isn't it ironic that the same people that claim we have a silver or gold shortage, also want to see the dollar backed by one or both. How is that possible? In order to back a currency with a commodity, that commodity has to produced by the country backing their currency with the commodity and the country has to, at a bear minimum, have an expanding supply of the commodity to at least keep up with population growth. After all, if we are not producing it, what are we going to trade for it?
Are these same people patriots or profiteers? I thought the Ron Paul Movement was about restoring America, not seeing how much money could be made off her destruction. Rest assured, if the dollar actually collapses, the free world as we know it is over. You had better take some of those silver profits and invest in some language lessons of either Mandarin or Russian. If the currency collapses, the government is out of business folks. Most currency collapses end in either military dictatorships or strong man governments. So be careful what you wish for.
The biggest irony of all is assuming silver will outperform gold. No matter what your economic forecast for the future is: hyperinflation, stagflation or depression, there is only one way silver could outperform gold, global economic expansion. If either hyperinflation, stagflation or depression take place, the industrial uses that take up 90% of the annual production will decline,or at least logic would dictate so. And silver will fall. It is 20 years of global economic expansion that has gotten silver where it is today, not
inflationary depression.
If SIERRAHPBT is correct, and Ron Paul's warning of a global inflationary depression comes to pass, how would silver dodge the bullet? The only way silver is going to see $1000 an ounce is a hyper-inflationary dollar collapse. And the consequences of that happening far out weigh any profit potential. A global inflationary depression only guarantees higher food, medicine, and energy costs, not higher silver prices.
Don't bother responding to me, I'm leaving this board. Good luck to all of you that buy into SIERRAHPBT's silver fantasy. You are going to need it.
I like Silver, I like Gold too
I couldn't tell you if it will be inflation or deflation or a bit of both-I think it's up to the powers that be since they manipulate the heck out of everything including precious metals. All that glitters will always be desired for many reasons from practical to psychological. I think I'll keep what I have shortage or no, manipulated or not.
I hear a few years back you
I hear a few years back you could buy a house if you had a few tulip bulbs. Does that mean that a few tulip bulbs were truely equal in value to a house? Or could it be that there was a temporary psychological disconnect to real value? First we've had a mania in Stocks, followed by a mania in real estate. Why so hard to think that a mania in commodities might not follow? All these bubbles, or manias, have been driven by infaltion, and they all have had the SAME basic ideals held by its participants. "It can only go up". We heard it in the stock bubble. We heard it in the Real Estate bubble. Now we're hearing it in the Commodity Bubble.
In each bubble there have been good solid reasons why the bubble could not deflate. And these reasons have held true through each bubble, until suddenly the bubble began to deflate DESPITE the good solid reasons that STILL existed...
Think quality rather than
Think quality rather than quantity.
The point of backing currency with gold and silver is to prevent the government from being able to inflate or deflate its value.
Agreed
A 10% or 5% silver coin is still worth inherently more than a 100% paper dollar.
Shortages aside....
Shortages aside, the quantity of money is completely meaningless, so long as it stays relatively stable.
Read that last sentence again, because it is not common knowledge.
The entire world economy could be based on silver (or gold, or anything else) if there were only 10oz of the stuff in existence. The only difference that it would make would be the price (in silver) that goods and services command.
All that silver does in a silver-backed economy is give a reference by which everything else is valued. The idea that the quantity of something has any impact on its value as a medium of exchange is the flaw in logic that leads helicopter Ben to create more dollars because there aren't 'enough' of them.
Let's consider a hypothetical economy that runs on a silver standard. This economy has an aggregate silver content of 10.0000oz.
Now, suppose you are a participant in this economy holding silver.
You hold 0.001oz of silver. This means that you alone hold one ten-thousandth of the economy's value (IE, you are very wealthy).
The major consequence of such a small supply of money would be increased currency volatility. In this fictional economy, adding an additional 10oz of silver would be disastrous because prices would double.
So what if a cheeseburger costs you 0.00000000001oz of silver? Who cares? The guy on the other side of the transaction doesn't care about the quantity of the silver he receives. He only cares about what fraction of the national wealth it represents.
As economic activity widens, prices will fall unless more silver is discovered and put into circulation (deflation). If silver is being coined faster than the economy expands, prices will rise (inflation).
It doesn't matter if there is 1oz, or 1,000,000oz in the entire Earth! All that matters is that the supply doesn't vary arbitrarily. Quantity will effect value and therefore price. But that is all. It won't change the suitability of silver as a monetary unit.
Silver has been a good choice for use as money because there is such a quantity of it that the monetary unit under a silver standard is a size that is comfortable for human-sized actors to use day-to-day.
It is durable.
It is divisible.
It is homogeneous.
Silver is as close as we have come to "ideal money".
My Shelfari page
This may all sound good in THEORY
But the fact remains that there has NEVER been a 100% backed Silver/Gold system in this country BECAUSE THE SUPPLY has never been great enough to do so.
In your theory, a piece of paper could be substituted for the 10 oz. of silver and the THEORY would still hold just as true.
Actually, Lincoln's "greenbacks"
were actually silver backed. (Another bit of history that has been altered to suit the bankers.) In fact, Lincoln's money was doing so well, he was assassinated. As usual we do not know our own true history!!!
PyraBang for Liberty
Give source for that please
can you please give a source for this tidbit of history? thanks.
in 1981 the US government
in 1981 the US government had 3 billion ounces of silver in stockpile! you don't think that was enough? guess what its all gone now!
as for me and my home, we shall worship the LORD
Yes, it could
The supply is completely irrelevant as long as it stays in a range to make it practical. That's why copper and platinum aren't good metals for the purpose of commerce.
The US mint used to have a policy of free-coinage. You were once able to ship your scrap silver to the mint, and they would ship you (nearly) the same quantity of silver back as US currency. In this way, the supply of money was controlled by market forces. When deflation began to take hold, people would start mining/recycling silver to get (now, more valuable) money.
Throughout the history of the US monetary system, there have always been bank notes that circulated as if it were metal.
And there have been bank runs as a direct result of this.
So you are incorrect on the first statement. There HAS been a perfectly workable silver standard in the US until relatively recent history. The reason that metal has never been used to the exclusion of paper is a matter of the choice to favor convenience over security.
It has never had anything to do with the supply of metal.
It has had everything to do with the fact that metal is heavier than paper.
>>...a piece of paper could be substituted...
Yes, paper could be used instead of metals.
But then the problem is the discipline of the people who make the paper. Since human beings can't be trusted to exhibit the necessary discipline, metals are preferable in practice.
But technically, yes. Paper would do as well.
My Shelfari page
Our Gold or Silver backed currency
systems taha have existed in this country have NEVER been backed 100% by the metals. Such system has NEVER existed in the US. Typically around 10%-12% backing was found. There have been much better systems than what we currently have, but none of the systems could be called "perfectly workable". They all had their problems and typically DID NOT result in price stablity.
Further, there has always been cycles of people's desire to change the banking system. When on a gold standard, its all good and people think its the best thing there is, so long as the economy is working good. But when the economy goes south, it is usaully from either a contraction or an expansion in the money supply. And people seek to change the money system. Under a commodity moeny system, there usually comes a point that the money supply contracts, or supply of goods outpaces the growth of the money supply, and deflation results. This is why we've never had a 100% backed currency. As the supply of coin has never been sufficeint do so. Our economy had already been established prior to the Constitution, and foreign coin. To have declared only coin would have required revaluing everything, and would have resulted in a hobbled economy right at the start, when we we're the weakest.
Gold Standard
If you look at the older paper currency, you will see that they were actually certificates that could be turned in for gold or silver at the US government. When Nixon took us off of the gold standard in 1971, it was because they had printed out more certificates than we actually had physical gold to pay back with.
Up until 1971, our currency was backed by silver and gold, and before 1965, most of our coins contained some silver to give them actual value.
I am curious: what do you mean by 100% backed? What else was backing our currency prior to 1965? It looks to me to have been a truly gold and silver based currency system -- a system, by the way, which has existed many times throughout history. Currency is simply finding a medium of exchange that people can agree upon, and since silver and gold have intrinsic value and scarcity, it makes them a perfect candidate for a "natural" currency as opposed to the unnatural fiat currency.
One thing to note is that by its very nature fiat currency must be manipulated to maintain. Gold and silver can be manipulated, but it takes a great deal more effort. Fiat currency, since it is backed solely by the faith of a national government, can be easily manipulated by the powers that be which is putting a lot of power into the hands of corruptible men (absolute power corrupts absolutely). A gold and silver currency, while not perfect, at least reduces the risk of manipulation.
I posted this thread yesterday
I don't think anyone read it...
"A Brief History of Central Banking in the United States"
http://www.let.rug.nl/~us...
100% backing is when there is one unit of metal for one unit of Currency. A "Constitutional Dollar" is defined as 371.25 grains of silver. So for each $1 certificate issued, the Treasury MUST have 371.25 grains of silver held in reserve. This is 100% backing. There has never been such in this country. It has always been fractional reserve backing. Most commonly around 37.125 grains of Silver for each $1 certificate, or $1 of backing for each $10 of currency issued. This is essentially a 90% fiat currency.
Well, the link worked when I clicked it,
and I'd like to note, for those whom nitpick a persons post...The above should read "the ISSUER MUST have 371.25 grains of silver held in reserve". Notes were commonly issued by banks at times in our history, and there have been times that ONLY banks issued notes. So under a 100% reserve backing ANY issuer would need to have $1 of silver in reserve to issue a $1 certificate.