FORUM QUICK LINKS > News | Economy | DP Liberty Forum | Activism | DIGG! | Books | Videos | Events | RP Repubs | Rand Paul 2010

   

Do You Trust the USDA ORGANIC Label?

I'm just wondering.

output

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Absolutely not if you're

Absolutely not if you're trying to go truly organic, but it's a good start and, as a consumer, a much better choice than ingesting all the crap in most foods. Read the specs and you'll see that there is a lot of room for unhealthy ____cidal use, but the bigger loophole is in processing. The whole thing is rigged for larger-scale producers, which turns me off of it.

Even though they are a voluntary organization without rigorous inspection, I would trust Certified Naturally Grown (www.naturallygrown.org) more than USDA-NOP. I am in the works of developing an organic orchard business and would rather go CNG than USDA even if it limits my market access.

My Farm, a group in SF, California has a great concept!!

http://www.cityfarmer.inf...

Let's start this in our communities. My county, Palm Beach, has 1.2 million people.

Imagine if for each person there was a $50/week expense at the grocery store...that equals $60,000,000.

Take that $60,000,000 and multiply it by 52 weeks / year and that's $3.1 Billion dollars on Food.

If we start local farms in every home and community, like My Farm in San Francisco, we could start a new agricultural Revolution!

I want to start in Florida...anyone want to help!!

About the USDA Organic: There are many loop holes in the USDA Organic program in areas that help large companies and hurt the small farmers. I know this because I work for a dietary supplement company that uses organic ingredients.

Yours in Health and Freedom

Power to the people!

I love were you're going with this. This is the time for the Secretary of Agriculture to represent the majority of America’s farmers: [family, small and middle farms). And if they don't, we'll do it anyway!!! $$$$$
Locate your local farmer's markets. Ask them about their farm and their growing methods. Buy from them. It's an investment, I even give them more money to show my excitement and support, and playfully offer my help at harvest time.
About five years ago,us rawfooders began sponsoring local raw food pot luck once a month. We have a special speaker, Q&A, then we eat the finest fruits and vegetables.(uncooked) and whats left over then we exchange or give away. This is how I find the finest fruits and vegetables, and sure enoughh, many come from backyards!. We meet once a month and exchange locations of food source. Some are very exotic like Durian and Sipolte.
Bookmark: Natural Hygeine http://www.livingnutritio... they have a fine site with links, and a list of rawfood pot lucks around the United States and Canada.

.

I'm rasing my own produce

and meat, or I buy it locally from a group that farms the old fashion way before all the fertilizers and chemical additives

Mish on Schiff

My Understanding

is that USDA "organic" includes crops raised using organic chemicals. That is organic in the sense that they are carbon based, so it doesn't mean chemical free. I've never read the rules myself, but that's what I heard from a friend who runs a family farm. They seem to think that the USDA organic label isn't worth a hill of beans.

I don't think it does either.

I heard that for some goods, if a producer runs out of an organic ingredient he is permitted to replace it with a conventional ingredient and still carry the USDA Organic label. A person has to continually get behind the meaning of the words they use on labels and expect an attempt at deception. It's all about money.

----------------------
The Road Less Traveled by George Strait

OF DROUGHTS AND FLOODING RAINS (Video)

GREENING THE DESERT (Video) Water Harvesting Methods

GLOBAL GARDENER (Video)

You're partly right - the

You're partly right - the USDA Organic label is dependent upon the AVAILABILITY of approved seeds, pesticides, ingredients, etc. It doesn't mean a person can arbitrarily decide not to use an approved product simply because they don't have any at hand and would have to go buy some, but the provision is there that allows the use of ingredients that would otherwise be prohibited if there is no approved alternative. This is especially evident in processed foods and cosmetics which may carry the Organic label but actually contain many chemicals, even synthetic chemicals, simply because there is no approved alternative.

For me trust in the Organic label means constant verification.

Get to know your local growers. Remove the middle man as much as possible. Some local organic farms have tours you can go on where they show how they grow things.

----------------------
The Road Less Traveled by George Strait

OF DROUGHTS AND FLOODING RAINS (Video)

GREENING THE DESERT (Video) Water Harvesting Methods

GLOBAL GARDENER (Video)

I trust them as much as I trust the FDA

I trust that they will pass regulations not to protect the people, but to give big business an advantage over small business. "organic" is just a media buzz word and what the USDA has done is not strengthen consumer protection, but has weakened states rights to regulate and allowed foreign imports to meet these lower standards. They are slightly higher then non organic, but I would not look for the USDA symbol but buy locally grown and hydroponic. Hydroponic growth is really the wave of the future but has been fought by the USDA. It has no impact on soil and earth because they are not used and less water is required because it goes directly to the roots and not spread over the land. Hydroponic farms also require less land because you can build them vertically. Itr also puts less stress on the farm worker because they do not have to be bending down all of the time. The problem is that they require fertilizer and the USDA thinks if you use fertilizer you are not as good as "organic". Organic farms must rely on the earths natural methods of decomposition. Cover your fields in cow shit or even dead cows and that is ok, but to use a man made fertilizer is not. I can understand the concerns when it comes to traditional farming where most of the fertilizers seep into the land and water supply and are not taken up by the roots of the plants, but in hydroponic farming this is not an issue because it is done in a closed system. This closed system also allows for more seasonal crops to be produced almost year round on less land, with less impact on the environment. As for taste and nutrition, they are usually higher then organic. The problem is with the USDA, which has been fighting with them to be classified as "organic" and has put huge restrictions on what is defined as "organic" fertilizers. The USDA has done its best to limit hydroponic production by granting the favorable status to "organic" food and by doing this has slowed the growth of the most productive and environmentally safe way to produce quality food in favor of the slowest manner to produce food. With organic you have to show no pesticides were used on the soil in the last 20 years. With Hydroponics, you do not use soil. You can almost grow anything anywhere. To control the people you must first control the food supply. That is what the USDA is doing. By granting the status of "organic" to some food sources it allows them to charge more but limits the means in which they can produce and in most ways what they produce is of less quality and by a means less far productive then hydroponics and that means taken at its highest point is that on one acre of a hydroponic farm you can produce 10 times more then an "organic". That dose not even take into consideration that "organic" farms must be based in soil that already has natural nutrients. Its definition is based on soil, that which is already in the land and makes land with a better natural configuration more valuable then land with lesser mineral deposits. The truth with hydroponics is you can grow a crop in a desert using less land and water. The truth also is that hydroponics is the best way to grow weed and might be why the US government is so against it. Don't grow weed, big pharm dose not want competition. Today kids are more addicted to what they can steal from their parents drug cabinet and what their parents give to them then so called "illegal drugs" . Thank the FDA for that one!

i think the buy local and

i think the buy local and grow local movement is great for libertarians. makes us really focus on our communities in a small scale.

It's getting difficult to

It's getting difficult to trust anything from the government these days as they are doing such a great job of being untrustworthy in nearly everything they do.

I don't trust anything with

I don't trust anything with the word "Department" in it.

No kidding

Or "Administration".

Think about it... what does the "Food and Drug Administration" do? They *administer* food and drugs to the people. Enough said.

************
http://www.pyrabang.com - the Patriot newsfeed machine that will take a huge bite out of Google's ad profits and put them in your pocket!

Don't forget "Federal"

Don't forget "Federal"

And "Agency" or "Service"

Or "Inc." or "Corporation", either.

Have heard some good things

Have heard some good things and just read a study tracing the origins of inorganic arsenic (from pesticides) levels in rice. The organic rice had the lowest levels.

I've noticed better flavor from some organically grown produce. However, my high school cooking teacher had said hormones are used to produce the big bumps on the bottoms of apples because it's believed they are more appealing to consumers (silly). I've seen supermarket organic apples with unnaturally huge bumps.
.

Yes I believe...

...the United States federal government are Dickheads and Assholes... Oh wait that wasn't the question...

That made me laugh - Thank you

:)

do i trust the government?

do i trust the government? no!

Tomorrow for dinner

we are having free range rabbit. Shot by my eleven year old son on his first ever hunt. The day after that we will be having wild pheasant. Shot by my seventeen year old son on opening day. The day after that....well you get the idea.

The question was about food labeled organic

But didn't I see you on that hunting trip with Dick Cheney awhile back? How's the head wound?

_______________________________
DIEBOLD: "If Your Vote Counts, Then We're Not Doing Our Job."

Labels here

Labels on meet here dont have USDA..they have Canada-USA-Mexico

Freedom is another way to God...A corrupt government is a straight way to hell.

No.

If you'll look at the label of any of these dairy products, you'll notice that any of these products is super heated (all nutrients—I mean ALL nutrients—are killed). Why consume something that doesn't benefit your body in any way?

--Cliff, Sioux City, Iowa

I agree.

When it comes to not only dairy products but everything else too, raw beats pasteurized every time. Pasteurization kills EVERYTHING living in food, both good and bad.

Louis Pasteur was wrong and Antoine Bechamp was right.

************
http://www.pyrabang.com - the Patriot newsfeed machine that will take a huge bite out of Google's ad profits and put them in your pocket!

Wow… That’s a fantastic sight! I always knew Pasteur was…

was dead wrong.

--Cliff, Sioux City, Iowa

One thing about my logic; it almost always sounds logical.
Is my arithmetic methodology logical? You decide.

I don't trust

anything the government does. Go to www.cornucopia.org and see how Dean Foods was allowed to confine their cows and pass the milk off as organic. When I first started buying organic 10 years ago the small companies I trusted, then when organics got popular, General Mills, Mars, etc. started buying these family farms. Most of their products come from China. Oh yeah I trust organic from China! Buy local, that is the only answer.

We agree on that!!!

The federal government pretty much consists of troublemakers (the leaders) and idiots (the followers). Everybody else works in the private sector.

--Cliff, Sioux City, Iowa

Ha!

That's like saying free-range chickens are free-range! The USDA regulations are such that chickens penned up in a barn so tight that they can't walk around without stepping on each other are considered free-range.

I just took tomorrow's dinner out of the freezer - we are having either Greta or Larry roast. We know exactly what they ate and what they were treated with. To us, that is better than the "organic" label. They are actually pasture-raised, not pasture-raised or organic through a USDA loophole.

I worked for the USDA for 7 years...

until I resigned. No, I do not trust them.

I think early on

it was probably more genuine than now. It is a government seal after all and you all know that our government loves you.

Wholefoods had an ecoli breakout

They're all a scam.....believe me. You need to do some on-line checking for locally grown organic....like farmers markets, etc. Denver has a few of these.

Deb

I only believe half of what

I only believe half of what I see.

IMHO

it has to be better than the chemical, additive, preservative, added to the
other now sold-
grow your own as soon as you can
rabbits crap use that for fertilizer, make your own compost
use that for fertilizer
there are alot of alternatives to buying in a store
work with neighbors and do some trading



"Our Day is Coming"


★★★thank you RON PAUL★★★

it's an indicator

but, I do trust the background, reputation and statements of individual companies.

Is this a joke post? There

Is this a joke post? There have been loopholes big enough for a tractor to drive through under USDA organic standards.

I don't think

anyone is passing non-organic products off as organic, but the usda's definition of "organic" is not anywhere close.

They need to have a different standard: "sustainable." Sustainability is much more important, and sustainably-produced food will usually be organic, or mostly organic.

The problem with organic is that it cuts out a lot of sustainable garden techniques that do no harm. I don't feed my chickens "organic" feed, but I guarantee you that my eggs are produced in a more sustainable way than the "organic" eggs you buy at Whole Foods. But my eggs wouldn't be allowed onto the shelf at Whole Foods!

There is a giant industry, "big organic," that is organic, but is not much better than the non-organic industry. "Organic" by itself doesn't do it-- food economies need to be completely torn down and rebuilt.

Google "Joel Salatin" and/or "polyface farm" or "beyond organic" for more.

My sources tell me

that the USDA is one of the only agencies that is EXTREMELY on point. when you make a purchase you can trust the usda label. cant say the same thing for the fda.

I reserve the right to govern myself.

I have been involved in battling the USDA over Country Of Origin

Labeling (mandatory) for many years. And I can tell you for sure the USDA cannot be trusted! They provided a loophole in the COOL regulations to allow the big meat conglomerates to LABEL the beef "Canada, Mexico, U.S.", even though a roast will certainly be from a critter from ONE country! The intent of the legislation was that consumers could KNOW which country the beef came from---but USDA's final rule gave the global corporations the right to cheat!
R-CALF USA is fighting USDA over this, so if any of you raise livestock, please consider becoming a member and giving a donation for the ongoing legal battle. www.r-calfusa.com
R-CALF members are also fighting the NAIS. (Animal I.D.)

Thank you for the responses. What is your take on USDA ORGANIC

"Only a virtuous people are capable of freedom. As nations become corrupt and vicious, they have more need of masters." Benjamin Franklin
---

BEEF FROM URUGUAY?

USDA Organic? No.

Others, like QAI and the various state tilths, yes.

USDA Organic is not 100% organic, only 90-95%. The other 5% can be gods-knows-what garbage.

Not for a New York minute.

Not for a New York minute. The USDA makes rules that suit their Big Ag buddies. When they re-defined "grass fed beef" to include beef raised in confined feeding operations (CAFO's) if some natural feedstuffs, like corn on stalks, is included in their feed, I lost any trust at all in anything the USDA says. They are the agricultural equivalent of the FDA, prostitutes who serve their corporate masters, nothing more.

Pat

BOHICA!!

Laugh

Good question! How'd ya know what I was thinkin' years ago.

Actually organic requirements, even though I haven't actually studied them, only heard a couple of things, may be over-strict?

Lookin' through organic fertilizers you'll find that there also embedded with misrepresentation, deceptive labeling, etc., of the products. Go to OMRI for an independent analysis of organic fertilizers. Hopefully their independent huh.

http://www.omri.org/

http://www.omri.org/OMRI_...

Who uses organic fertilizers?

Compost your own.

I'm All For Compostin'

But, it's not very realistic.

For a large garden, I have never seen anyone who has enough composted matter to spread over the entire area, maybe after a few years it"ll eventually be be spread over it. Compost seems to be more for flower beds, something small like that.

For a vegetable garden I prefer the plowing-in of the old plants and green manure cover crops and maybe organic straw (best to a person finding that) laid upon the garden surface, decomposes eventually throughout the year and\or is also plowed-in at the end of the year. Love composted animal manure but try to find organic manure less you have your own "preferably cattle" manure from your own property. Leaves may be one of the best and most practical for a lot of folks, if you have them untouched from synthetic fertilizers. And possibly, the good ole thousands of years old practice of using "bat guano", interesting study if nothing else. N some seaweed is interestin' stuff, not gonna harvest it here in Ohio huh. There's some interesting products though. Moral of this story, generally: "feed those worms" 'n that thar soil!

I go here, there is one in Kentucky, across the river from me.

http://www.wormsway.com/

No offense, you get the idea.
... ... ...
Laugh, my initial response above was a bit "off rocker". I don't trust USDA much either. They most certainly need to be watched. I don't think this food is the "real stuff", or some of it rather, would be a better way of describing it.

Sure it is realistic

Get a ComposTwin and have at it. Toss your lawn clippings, deciduous leaves, banana peels, apples cores, all your green garbage in there.

Talk to your local zoo about composted zoo manure--hippo crap is fantastic fertilizer!

Alfalfa pellets for citrus trees works excellent.

And yes, the worms are very important.

I Appreciate Your Interest

Still, for myself, I can't see having enough compost for an entire 1\2 to 1 acre garden.

I like: having a temporary garden space for three years while building-up another space for the same three years. Oh yeah, that's a good way to go. Not many people see it that way or do it that way, but it's a good thought in my book, a good practice, good method.

That zoo stuff is interesting, really. That takes a serious gardener for that idea. Serious!

affirmation: President Paul

affirmation: President Paul 2008

Good question. Our farm has been certified organic since 1989. I'll get back to this later tonight; I've got things to do before the sun goes down.

I want to

since we are 99% organic. However, someone at work said they saw a peice on TV that said as long as it was USA grown you could pretty much trust it, but if grown out of the USA no. I try to buy as much as I can that is locally grown. A lot of the fresh fruits and vegatables I see labled organic come from South America. Our local stuff is seasonal. I can and freeze as much as I have time to do. I never ever trust strawberries that aren't in season or locally grown. We do without.