Find a Safe Bank

   

Chinese mass counterfeiting gold and silver coins

A must-read if you invest in any type of silver and gold coins, especially American Eagles:

http://www.coinworldonline.com/counterfeits/articles/2008120...

Your rating: None Average: 5 (1 vote)

Comment viewing options

Select your preferred way to display the comments and click "Save settings" to activate your changes.

Does gold change color

I bought some austria philharmonics 1 oz coins that were shiny when I bought them. Months later I check them again and they are dull in color while my canadian maple leafs remain shiny. Is this normal?

if it drives prices down

then i'll buy.

Another simple Gold test.

I went to a rock show a few years ago in Arizona. They had beautiful mineralized rocks and polished stones from all over the world, I bought a few.

One vendor had what looked like real flakes of placer Gold in water in a small plastic container, at a cheap price. When I asked if it was Gold, they said yes.

Since the price was about $10. a capsule, I bought one,,,,went to my car,,,got a small open metal pan out and put a small amount of sand from the parking lot in the pan, a little water, and some {imitation} Gold flakes, and swished it around.

If it had been real Gold the flakes would have sunk under the sand when the swishing motion started.
Instead the flakes floated on the top of the water!

Conclusion:
It was dried flakes of Gold paint in the capsules.
I got my money back!

beesting

I have seen some panda

I have seen some panda silver coin with .999 fine silver marking selling at very low price. They are supposed to be place holder for the real ones.

I know there are companies

I know there are companies online that sell some sort of chemical and scratching brick that test to see if the coin is real gold or silver...

Probably a smart investment if you plan on buying some coins...

It's a real story

1) Chinese are counterfeiting. http://www.coinworld.com/counterfeits/articles/counterfeits.asp

2) It's mostly older coins: Indian Heads, etc, but there are some Eagles and Buffalos.

3) The UPSIDE is that the fakes are easy to detect with a 100th Gram scale. The Counterfeiters use less than pure gold or a lower carat. If you don't have a scale, I'm sure a coin shop or pawn shop probably does.

4) If you buy something on Ebay and it turns out false, keep the Ebay purchase printout as receipt (I do anyway) and just turn it over to the Secret Service.

There are still more 'real' coins in the market than there are fakes, so unless you're doing a lot of antique shopping on Ebay, I wouldn't worry too much. Trust but verify.

Life, Liberty, Property

don't believe this story..

don't believe this story.. this is about scaring the week hands out of the market and into treasuries. the price of gold may come down to 675 or so then shoot up to 1900.00 because then people will realize just how bad the shortage of gold and silver is.. take this with a grain of salt..

Dear Comrades In Golden Arms,

The following is the latest from Jim's Mailbox:

Jim,

Two rumors are starting to move around through the gold chat rooms. I wanted to give you a heads up so you can be prepared to quickly inform the community about them as you see fit. Both rumors have potential to shock weak gold holders into selling.

Volcker replaces Timmy. This could lead to a kneejerk gold selloff (based on the past) and equity volatility in both directions.
A gold exchange traders fund may have been holding bogus gold bars which have been fabricated by China. This piggybacks some phony Chinese gold coins that have shown up through an article in coin world. This would supposedly cause a selloff in GLD, therein frightening the community.

CIGA Ken

Dear Ken,

Volcker's history of jamming rates could only occur even then with the full support of the sitting administration. To believe anything like that could happen is madness. Replacing the Secretary of the Treasury by this Administration at this time is only something a chat group could come up with.
There is reality to fake gold. China is a whipping boy. We have more criminals in the West and need not look to Asia for crime. Maybe start looking in Washington and then move outwards.

If an ETF is in paper gold that fails or has purchased fake gold that is a problem for the holders of that fund and is bullish for gold. Buyer would stop buying paper gold except on the COMEX where they would take delivery out of the COMEX warehouse and stop those criminals from manipulating the gold market. I am always amazed at how silly people can be when it refers to gold.

The internet is a tool of manipulation across the board. Those that believe either of the above chat site madness as negative to gold are raving idiots.

Volcker would be bullish for gold as the Father of the Federal Reserve Gold Certificate Ratio, modernized and revitalized.

What is happening you ask? The Chairman of the Fed is speaking so gold should be lower and the US dollar should be higher. This is a market applause for his total fabrication of fact. Traders knowing this will jump on these directions, having succeeded in the past .

Listen to the Senators question Bernanke. People are getting red in the face mad at this ongoing monetary madness.

Consequences will not be voided .

Hyperinflation is the end of all this madness, lies and outright theft.

Respectfully yours,
Jim

"When governments fear the people there is liberty. When the people fear the government there is tyranny."
-Thomas Jefferson

I am more concerned about the return of my money than the return on my money. --Mark Twain

I second that, Sierra

I read a German comment on that "news" to the effect it's spinned to scare people away from gold. Not saying though, that, as in any good lie, there isn't a grain of truth in it.

Fellowship of the White Rose

They are doing what they do best....counterfit! Not a great

testament to the Chinese people if all they can do is produce cheap knock-offs!
~Your perception becomes your reality~

~Your perception becomes your reality~

Consider this.

Does the U.S. mint have a patent on gold coin designs pre-1933? If not, than what crime is being committed unless they claim to be of gold or silver and are not.
grant

Well I guess if they can

Well I guess if they can produce American Eagle coins, cheaper than the U.S. mint, as long as they are real gold who cares? Gold is gold, isn't it?

If it's real gold ... cool !

.

EUREKA!

What archimedes yelled when he found a way to distinguish "fake" gold from real gold.

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Start getting freedom today by dumping Federal Reserve Notes, Stocks, Banks and anything made outside the USA. Buy precious metals, real estate, businesses, food and guns and get your business community to use local or sound currenc

_ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
Start getting freedom today by dumping Federal Reserve Notes, Stocks, Banks and anything made outside the USA. Buy precious metals, real estate, businesses, food and guns and get your business community to use local or sound currenc

The comments on this thread,

and many of the other threads here on DP, about gold and silver, lead me to believe that a lot of you people who are talking about 'preserving your wealth' have no idea what your 'preservation of wealth' stash is really worth.

So, you think you got a great deal on Ebay, and you have a 'bunch' of gold and silver ( a bunch maybe meaning 1 gold coin and 5 or 10 silver coins ) that may be virtually worthless. Then you are going to spend some more money to buy some PVC tubes to bury this stash along a train track somewhere for when the SHTF.

I have to wonder if some of you are for real !

I don't think that Warren Buffet has this same mindset - and he, and others like him, has some REAL wealth to preserve !

But - whatever floats your boat.

Buy some seeds, and plant a garden.

that's a funny mental picture

maybe I'll find a rockwall ala Shawshank redemption....and bury some of my precious metals that way.

but let me be serious for a moment....I honestly never imagined the type of picture you paint....while reading many of these posts.

that tells me, you and I are coming from _very_ different perspectives.

but I'll put that aside for a second....let's just assume this picture you painted of some poor sumbich acting like gollum with his "precious" gold ring....burying his couple of coins in a hole in the ground.

so what.

sheesh....

Drive Down Gold?

Urban Survival was speculating in yesterday's post about this as a means to drive down the gold price cause a "just in time" rush to Treasuries bolstering the dollar.

www.urbansurvival.com/week.htm

"Want in on a little something the time monks are willing to share publicly? OK, try this one on --- but remember, this is a probability only and may or may not happen as expected...so think in terms of it being a possibility only for now...Ask yourself what would happen if a large financial entity - and it could be a private mint, an ETF, or something like that - was discovered in the next, oh, two or three weeks - to be holding a lot of counterfeit gold that was apparently made in China? Suppose further that the discovery happened during some kind of official audit process and that as word spread, it was discovered that not only were gold bars involved, but perhaps gold coins of recent vintage and maybe some involvement of silver as well. How would that work out?"

From my gold broker:

Gold is down because of margin calls. Hedge funds are selling profits to cover losses. I don’t think this (Chinese counterfeiting) has put any downward pressure on pog yet. If it hits the mainstream media, maybe. It would be good for the older more reputable dealers as the newcomers would lose business.

Can't see the article without registering...

Just another reason not to allow imports ffrom China....

Also, don't break open your monster boxes of silver.

I may not know the truth, but I know when I'm being lied to...

I may not know the truth, but I know when I'm being lied to...

a fake email address will do

a fake email address will do just fine.

Please become a fan: www.facebook.com/dailypaul

Last Amercan:I noticed that also. I took it a step...

further and did a net search and fold NOTHING. What does that mean? People should be cautious about who they are buying precious metal from. I buy from APMEX. They guarantee everything they sell and they will buy it back. That may cost more, but this and other reputable companies guarantee what they sell. They get their deliveries directly from mints around the world. Enough said about adding even more conspiracies that are unwarranted/unfounded.
This thread should be put in the circular file.

Here is some of the information from the article

I found this on a kitco thread:
http://www.tbrnews.org/Archives/a2921.htm#001

From the article:
A friend who has an extremely wealthy friend in Europe (on the order of several hundreds of millions) asked this person to make enquiries at his bank. The bank told him candidly that indeed, the Chinese are also faking sovereigns, half sovereigns, French 20 Franc gold, and various denominations of Nicholas II Russian Rubles, of all dates, as well as Swiss gold bars. They said any gold bars they are offered for purchase are both weighed and the serial numbers checked with the manufacturers. The Chinese do not know the serial and manufacture date numbering systems on the gold bars, and so that error is quickly detectable.

Oh those pesky Chinese

.
Next thing you know they'll be pirating DVDs.

Oh wait.

What???????

Are you some kind of racist or something? Besides, Chinks are good guys. They would never counterfeit or pirate!

—Cliff, Sioux City, Iowa
March’s song: “Champagne” by Kenny G
Throw-away tools of war



—Cliff in Sioux City, Iowa
———————
If you remember anything, remember the throw-away tools of war.

numismatic v. bullion

They are counterfeiting NUMISMATIC coins - coins that get their value from being a rare year or rare minting. Another reason not to use numismatic coins as an investment.

As the prior poster said, you CAN'T counterfeit gold bullion coins. There is nothing with gold's density to make them out of that isn't more rare than gold. Yet another reason why gold is nearly perfect money.

Silver, on the other hand, CAN be adulterated with lead. Large silver bars can be drilled and filled with lead and the result would be undetectable with a scale. But coins? A silver-plated lead coin would be too heavy and the benefit of trying to drill the rim of a silver coin, fill it with just the right amount of lead, and then patch it back up and restore the knurl on the edge of the coin would be an awful LOT of trouble for a little bit of silver.

Coined money

I agree, buying rare coins is a little foolish. They can easily be copied and I would challenge any coin dealer to tell the difference.
I have a small coin collection, but I never bought proof coins, usually went for the fair. They have a little more character and history all scracted up and used.
But that is the purpose of coined money, it is suppose to be circulated.
As for counterfeiting, I've always felt that gold is gold as long as they aren't trying to swindle you or chisel a little bit off the sides, it is fair trade.
grant

Bob Chapman is a big

Bob Chapman is a big proponent of buying numismatic coins as the economy goes does the toilet. He states this is where the big money will be made. Not that buying bullion coins shouldn't be purchased, but the rise in price of numismatics exceeds that of the price of gold as gold rises.

At least if you buy from a coin dealer, (a reputable one), and your coin is proven to be fraudulent, you have a good chance of returning it. Slabbed coins have serial #s. Worst case scenario if you suspect your coin might be fake you can contact the grading company to cross reference the number.

buying numismatic coins "at

buying numismatic coins "at the bottom", is no different then other investments...and the attempt to buy them at the bottom.

if people are still thinking in terms of investment, and how many FRNs they will get back in the future, then they aren't ready to buy bullion.

Acala, what is there to

Acala, what is there to prevent someone from making an alloy with gold's density (or close ti o it) and just coating it with gold or a gold-colored substance? I can't think of anything.

Can't be done

In order to make a fake gold coin with the same density as gold, you would need to have a substitute metal MORE dense than gold and then gold-plate it. There are no metals more dense than gold that are not also more rare and expensive than gold itself. Gold is more dense than lead. So it is impossible to make a fake gold coin out of cheaper metals and have the same density.

See this chart:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_elements_by_density

Only the metals farther down the list could be used to simulate the density of a gold coin. Most of them exist only in laboratories in microscopic quantitites. Some of them are highly radioactive and would kill anyone trying to machine them or cast them. Some of them are liquid at room temperature. ALL of them are more expensive than gold.

Now you COULD probably make a gold-colored tungsten coin that would be close enough in density to gold to fool a rough specific gravity test. But trying to make a coin out of tungsten would be brutal. It is one of the hardest metals (if not THE hardest) and has the highest melting point of any metal. So any kind of low-budget casting is out of the question as is any kind of stamping. Making a coin out of tungsten would be VERY difficult and the result woud be about as unlike gold as any metal could be. Except for its density. A simple stamp test would out a tungsten fake.

This is why a simple specific gravity measurement will ALWAYS out phony gold.

You are talking about

You are talking about individual pure metals. I'm referring to an alloy.

Doesn't matter

To my knowledge you cannot alloy two lighter metals and get a heavier one.

Of course not, but who said

Of course not, but who said it would be two lighter metals?

But

But there ARE no heavier metals available to alloy. That is what I am trying to tell you. Of course there ARE a few heavier metals, but they are more rare than gold and so not available. Name a commonly available metal that is more dense than gold.

This is true and a fair

This is true and a fair point. But if a faked coin is slabbed and sold how many people are going to go out of their way to check for a fake? I don't believe many. You'd have to get the coin regraded. This is why I said in another discussion it's easier to simply check the serial number given by the grading company.

a lot of them will be cautious.

especially after the first few people are allowed to stab themselves in the eye.

the only way millions of people will be screwed by such a scam is if the government gets involved.

Yes, as they are involved

Yes, as they are involved now. Not w/fake coins but w/market manipulation.

Nope

You can create an alloy that does either of the following two things:
Mimics the color of gold
Mimics the density of gold

But you can't do both. Gold is very soft.
If you have a fine gold coin (99.9% or better) drop it into concentrated nitric acid. Gold will not be attacked, but basically any base metal will be. This is the origin of the phrase "acid-test".

The only way to pull of a decent counterfeit would be to make the bulk of the coin from a base alloy that mimics gold's density and then plate it with actual gold. But then it wouldn't be soft.

Gold is very difficult to competently fake.

My Shelfari page

Acid test?

Is that right?? I love that I learned that today--that that phrase comes from something as cool as the test to ascertain the authenticity of gold. How cool? Who knew? Not I, but now I do! Thank you!!! :)

"The only way to pull of a

"The only way to pull of a decent counterfeit would be to make the bulk of the coin from a base alloy that mimics gold's density and then plate it with actual gold."

Exactly, that's my point. And there you have your fake.

Also, how many people have nitric acid lying around their home? And if it is plated with gold this test wouldn't work.

Well....

>>how many people have nitric acid lying around their home?
I can vouch for one.

If you don't have nitric acid, this would be my advice:
Weigh the coin
Find the coin's volume by displacing a liquid with it.

From that, calculate the density and compare to gold.

If that matches, use a sharp knife to mar the gold and look for a change in color.

My Shelfari page

One, exactly.To use the

One, exactly.

To use the other technique one would need laboratory grade equipment to be accurate. (The scale, graduated cylinders, etc.) Again, not something most people have lying around.

What can I say...

...other than "Tools make the professional."

Send your coins in question to me. I can assay them for you.

My Shelfari page

Right ! ... they'll be in the mail to you later today.

I'll send some real coins ( which I have owned for 25 years - before all this hysteria started ) to you, an unknown entity here on the DP, so you can return some phony crap back to me, certifying them to be legitimate !

ha ... ha ... ha !

Somebody might take you seriously, though.

You know what P.T. Barnum said !

That wasn't the intent

That wasn't the intent. He asked how it could be done. So I told him.
I have lots of posts like that.

Nitric acid is available online, as are graduated cylinders. The scale doesn't have to be *super* accurate, but milligram accuracy would be best. You could figure it out with a cheap digital scale. So maybe $100 for all of the above.

My Shelfari page

I was just pointing out how ridiculous some of the posts

on this thread . . are !

And the other point is who

And the other point is who in their right mind is going to put a knife to a numismatic coin if you care about its condition?

Good question

But if you suspect it's a fake, why do you care? Obviously you'd use non-destructive means of testing first. This is why I don't like numismatic stuff. I only buy generic bullion.

I can't solve all the problems. I can only offer trade-offs. If vinegar and measuring cups are the best tools you've got, and you don't want to damage your coin, you are going to end up taking the coin on faith.

Screw faith. I have chemistry.
:-)

My Shelfari page

I'd care because I could be

I'd care because I could be wrong. Besides that it's easier (and less destructive) to contact the grading company to verify the serial #.

Yeah, there's where...

Yeah, there's where you stepped outside of my realm of knowledge. I've only ever seen bullion bars serialized. Never rounds. And never coinage that was once meant to circulate. I'm guessing you mean the PCGS serial number?

But seriously.... if you have that, why in the world are you asking about detecting the fake yourself?

I dunno. If you give me a lump of metal, I can tell you how much of what is in it. But any chemical assay is going to be somewhat destructive. But it is nevertheless an option. Maybe not the best option. But there it is.

My Shelfari page

We were discussing

We were discussing numismatic coins, not bars or rounds.

Yes I was referring to the grading company's number.

"But seriously.... if you have that, why in the world are you asking about detecting the fake yourself?"

I'm not.